Integra 7

The Best Piano thus far

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 09:36
The only sad thing is you can have a great piano/Ep sound etc. but if the PA at the event stinks it takes away from the
beauty of the instrument. At some small events Im using a A&H mixer TRS out into my own MAudio BX8As and many times it sounds better than the PA (and its in stereo).Bigger events you couldnt get away with it of course.Ive done this a number of times and what a difference.At some places Ill go main out into the PA and control out to the BX 8as,but at other places I dont go thru the PA at all and I definately have enough volume for these speakers, I usually have to turn them down LOL In this case I go out 25' each side and slightly turn them for the other musicians to hear (one speaker elevated and the other on the floor for bass) and use a very light open Sennheiser headphone via the A&h mixer for myself it works quite well,along with a floor monitor of the band.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 10:36
steve77 wrote:
...but if the PA at the event stinks it takes away from the
beauty of the instrument..
Very true. Even the best, most detailed piano (or any patch, for that matter) can be totally destroyed by a bad audio system or a horrible mono keyboard amp. As we all know. ;)
Dany wrote:

PS:
MrDuke wrote:
Even though a modeled piano (which always includes a sample, by the way)...
Your statement is of course wrong! Pianoteq (http://www.pianoteq.com) doesn't use ANY samples and it is solely based on physical modeling!
-
Are you absolutely certain? I was under the impression that all even 100% physical modeling instruments used the tiniest of samples, usually for the attack etc. I know Roland's SN stuff works this way, as Anotherscott pointed out. I'm not familiar with Pianoteq, but judging by the examples on their site, it sounds incredible if it indeed is "all computer code".
howardS wrote:
Kenchan, I would want the upright in my RD700NX for those songs where a concert grand is just too thick. A lot of pop songs over the last 40 years were recorded with upright pianos so I would like that as an option. That is why I think it is great that the Integra-7 includes an upright model.
I'm with you here! It's too rare (actually, non-existent) to have an Upright patch/model in a stage piano! It makes a world of difference sound-wise, compared to a grand. And for jazz, it's even better when the samples are "imperfect" or otherwise mangled to sound vintage.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 10:47
MrDuke wrote:
I was under the impression that all even 100% physical modeling instruments used the tiniest of samples, usually for the attack etc. I know Roland's SN stuff works this way, as Anotherscott pointed out.

To reiterate, the SN pianos in the RD/FP/Jupiter/Integra work this way, but I think that the SN pianos in the V-Piano are actually entirely modeled.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 12:20
MrDuke wrote:
Dany wrote:
MrDuke wrote:
Even though a modeled piano (which always includes a sample, by the way)...
Your statement is of course wrong! Pianoteq (http://www.pianoteq.com) doesn't use ANY samples and it is solely based on physical modeling!
-
Are you absolutely certain? I was under the impression that all even 100% physical modeling instruments used the tiniest of samples, usually for the attack etc. I know Roland's SN stuff works this way, as Anotherscott pointed out. I'm not familiar with Pianoteq, but judging by the examples on their site, it sounds incredible if it indeed is "all computer code".
From the Pianoteq website: "based on physical modelling and real time sound generation". In the manual for v4 it states "based on physical modelling.... Notes are ... played (“constructed” in real-time, as on a real piano), not just read from the disk or the memory" (p.7)

The installer is tiny and no samples are separately downloaded during installation.

I've been using Pianoteq for a couple of years and I really like the sound of some of the pianos. The tweakability of things like mic positions and lid etc are nice, too.
Andy

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 17:18
howardS wrote:
Kenchan, I would want the upright in my RD700NX for those songs where a concert grand is just too thick. A lot of pop songs over the last 40 years were recorded with upright pianos so I would like that as an option. That is why I think it is great that the Integra-7 includes an upright model.

The reason I would want to eventually get the Integra-7, Kenchan, is so I could have something portable to take to rehearsals and then bring home for further tweaking. I hate having to lug so much gear back to my home just to work on splits and other stuff like that.
i see... i only play my own stuff and the only upright i kinda played around with was the nord's rain piano which sounded very mello and nice. yah, I7 would definitely be more portable than the RD700 for sure. :D hahaha.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 17:25
Waaay more portable. I picked up a Soniccell recently though for $120 (crazy, I know!) and will see if I can use bring that into the mix. Of course, the Integra-7 beats that with it's SuperNatural sound engine, all the SRX cards and the multiple outputs.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 17:29
and for those interested, i have the RD700NX, CP1, and VPiano, along with piano teq, and some other virtual piano's like garritan, thegrand3, etc in my mbp. it has been my long journey to have a nice real piano sounding instrument since...hummm early 1980's. and for me, the RD700NX made my journey complete.

the virtual instruments definitely sound nice, but you really need a fast computer to play it without drops...and that's only one side of the equation. you need a nice keybed like the PHA3's to play the nice pianos.

pianoteq sounds too fake to me. it's dynamic but sounds like a banjo or something on the lower register.

the CP1 is great as an electric piano, and while the acoustic piano's sound pretty, it's not realistic in the upper registers. sample loop is audible too unless you use both tone generators and mix it using one of the tone generator as a sub tone. also no damper noise. with light keybed it can throw one off when playing another digital piano or acoustic piano as the feel is so different to say a PHA3 keybed. it's a nice looking unit though and very reliable. the latest firmware has improved dynamic range so if one hasn't done the update yet, make sure you do.

the VPiano is very dynamic but as mentioned, the sound is unique. it's a luv it or hate it relationship. it's imho geared more for the classical piano player. it's a very reliable instrument though, and dynamic range is its selling point, i think. a professional pianist would enjoy it as a practicing tool in his/her home, imho.

the RD700NX is definitely the winner for me. sound wise you get a nice yamaha, steinway, and some other piano which im not very familiar with or use. roland doesn't associate the brands of the piano's with the patch so i dont know for certain but the concert piano defintely sounds yamaha, the studio piano sounds steinway, and brilliant...sounds like a VPiano...hahaha. no latency like virtual instrument...extremely stable and reliable performance, super nice keybed, dynamic range is very good (just add 30+ on the layer velocity sensitivity, play with keytouch, and you get even more dynamics), tweakability...and dynamic damper noise! :D and if you can play well on the PHA3, chances are, it will translate well to other digital and acoustic pianos.

if the I7 offers the same tonality as the RD700NX and damper noise (someone please confirm this), it could be a true winner to use with my FantomG8 (PHA2).

and no, ive not considered the kronos as im not a fan of that RH3 keybed feel... a nice piano sound requires both realistic sound engine and keybed. RD700NX delivers that in one package.
Last edited by kenchan on 28 Nov 2012, 17:32, edited 1 time in total.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 17:31
howardS wrote:
Waaay more portable. I picked up a Soniccell recently though for $120 (crazy, I know!) and will see if I can use bring that into the mix. Of course, the Integra-7 beats that with it's SuperNatural sound engine, all the SRX cards and the multiple outputs.


the complete piano SRX will bring it to the pre RD700NX, so should be pretty decent? how about string resonance though? does sonic cell have tweakability for that? i know my FG has it and can tweak it a little bit. one of the main problems with earlier piano samples is the lack of (or tweakability of) string resonance.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 17:59
I had SRX11, Kenchan, but did not like the artifact noise that was in the samples. In addition, of course, the samples in the upper region of the piano worked as if there were dampers on them so they didnt work like a real piano. On the X and later the samples above F6 or something like have a release time of infinity (I hope that makes sense to you). So in the end, I actually prefer the pianos in my X over the SRX11 and I find the SonicCell fairly playable.

What do you mean about string resonance, Kenchan? I dont see that paremeter as being tweakable in the G manual.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 20:06
I see. If the soniccell works for you that's great. Its a nice compact package for sure.

Oh, it mightve been called sympathetic resonance in the FantomG8 inside pfx.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 20:29
Oh, sympathetic resonance. That is MFX No. 78 on the X and the SonicCell and is pretty tweakable. I this it actually has more parameters that on the G.

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 21:13
In defence of Pianoteq, I've managed to tweak one of the uprights to sound remarkably close to my Knight K4 upright. I don't find it at all fake sounding. You pays your money...
Andy

Re: The Best Piano thus far

28 Nov 2012, 21:26
Hi Andy. Which version of Pianoteq are you running?

Re: The Best Piano thus far

29 Nov 2012, 03:27
kenchan wrote:
...and for those interested, i have the RD700NX, CP1, and VPiano...


I guess you aren't short on ca$h. That's $15,000 in just three keyboards!!

Re: The Best Piano thus far

29 Nov 2012, 06:00
HowardS, I'm using v3.6.8. i haven't upgraded to v4 yet.
Andy

← Back to Integra 7