Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

29 Jul 2004, 16:40
Hi all. I've been reading this site for sometime now, but this is my first post. I'll start by apologizing, because I'll probably ask some questions which have been asked before.

I was totally convinced that I was going to buy a Fantom X8 until just this afternoon when I found this site: http://www.harmony-central.com/Synth/Data/ - they have user reviews for lots of stuff. The Fantom X gets much lower ratings then the Motif ES and the Triton Studio. I understand that some people just have a hate on for things, and some people love things to death, so I usually toss away the top and bottom types of reviews in my head. However, it seems that the Fantom gets railed on for its sounds being not so great, among other things.

I realize that this is a somewhat biased place to ask this question, but do you ever regret not getting a different workstation?

Also, I read that the Fantom X can not record a sample while playing back from the sequencer. Is this true? If so, how can you record a vocal part, or guitar part along with the song? This to me appears to be a crushing blow to the Fantom.

The one thing that I really love about the Fantom is it's user interface. I think it's important to be able to be creative when I feel it coming on and not worry about futzing with the machine to make it do what I want it to.

Anyways, I'm sorry if this is a lame thread, I'm just really confused and I want to buy something soon because I just sold my old board. Now I have nothing.

Thanks!!

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

29 Jul 2004, 18:26
i've been reading Harmony-Central for a long time now.

Read the reviews there with a grain of salt, because it can be a very biased place sometimes. Some users have an agenda to promote certain companies, especially Yamaha.

Some of those negative reviews of the Fantom's sounds are a little ridiculous.

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

29 Jul 2004, 20:02
I bought the Fantom X8 a little over a month ago.

Like you, I extensively read Harmony Central for a bit before committing to making a purchase. What I gleaned from that exercise was that there is no single workstation which will do EVERYTHING... whichever way you choose to go there will be some degree of comprimise.

I think the criticism of the Fantom sounds is generally unwarranted, although I suppose is depends on what type of music you want to create. What swung it for me in the end was the X8's "ultimate piano" patch... by far the best grand piano sound in a workstation I've heard.

I love the fact that the X8 connects to my mac without the need for a separate USB device, and that it will mount on the desktop as a drive for easy transfer of patch and song settings.

I hated the fact that I couldn't find instrument definitions for Logic Pro 6 for the X8 (and so had to type them all in by hand) where it would have been a cinch to get one for a Korg Triton. But that's a small gripe I suppose.

Oh, I guess I should say I've also had reasonable experience with the Korg Triton too, so I hope this is a reasonably objective opinion.

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

29 Jul 2004, 20:30
First know that no question is lame. Even though others have posted this same question, i'm sure it'll be asked again.

B4 i respond though here's a question for you. Have u gone to a music store (like a guitar center) and put each respective keyboard thru its paces? If the sounds of the instrument are really important to you, with an open mind, demo each keyboard for yourself and go in, knowing what your ear needs to hear to make a decision that YOU will be happy with! Because in the end you'll be alone (or on stage) with the keyboard that you ultimately purchase.

The FantomS/X can sample while the sequencer is playing. It actually gives you 5 ways to sample. Theres regular sampling, re-sampling, auto divide sampling, mix sampling and solo sampling which allows the user to record vocals guitars, etc. This is what Korg users call "in track" sampling. Roland just has a diff approach to essentially the same feature.

No, personally i don't regret my Fantom S88 purchase. Not only is the Fantom's User Interface the best of the three hands down, its also a great sounding professional machine for all genres of music. Try out the units that are in the running for your money and when your 'gut' (and your ears) tell you that "this is the one" don't second guess yourself cause that's when you'll really be disappointed that you didn't stick with your first choice.

And lastly, a good percentage of the reviews on sites like Harmony Central and Sonic State are by people who have never demoed the keyboard for themselves or they are bandwagon reviews that go with whats popular in the industry. Could be they want more people to buy the keyboard they bought to make themselves feel good about a keyboard theyre not really happy with. Misery loves company u know;-). Again, try the keyboards for yourself. I'm assuming your referring to the Korg Triton Extreme or Studio, the Yamaha ES and the Fantom X. Whatever you like buy and be happy what u bought cause in the end you'll be the only one playing it. Period.

Here's a link for some video and audio demos if you'd like to get a glimpse of what the Fantom S/X series keyboards are really capable of.

go to:

http://www.rolandus.com/products/details.asp?catid=8&subcatid=36&prodid=Fantom%2DX8




"Don't make excuses, make progress"
TRIPLE THREAT PRODUCTIONS

"Don't make excuses, Make it happen"

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

29 Jul 2004, 21:52
Here's my opinion on the biggest difference between the three: ease of use.

With the Roland I have maybe looked at the manual 3 or 4 times since I bought it. It's easy to remember how to do just about everything.

Yamaha: I read the manual online and literally studied it for hours. Then I went to the store and couldn't figure anything out. The sounds were beautiful, probably the best, but I couldn't remember how to do anything. Then I read the manual again for hours and came to the conclusion that Yamaha needs to rewrite its manual. Motifator.com has pages of tutorial on how to do simple things like use the sequencer. I could explain the Fantom sequencer in one page and you would remember it.

The Korg is real nice. I love the arpeggiator in Korgs. User interface is nice. I think the sounds were a little flat. The polyphony is split 60 60 between two DSP chips so you really only get 60 notes max at any time. Seems like kinda dated technology, but you could say that about Roland synthesis which is based on the JV1080 (1994).

If I were you (and I've blabbed on enough I know) I would take at least 3 trips to Guitar Center and audition all three for a few hours. Have a list of things that are important to you and try those features. Don't get caught up in gimmicks that are nice to have, but not necessities.

GOOD LUCK!!!
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

29 Jul 2004, 22:38
But not a single one of them are so difficult to use that you can't figure it out and eventually breeze right through all parts of the OS.

And I'd recommend at least 3 trips to the store, too.

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 00:48
When you go to the junk store to compare these boards, always hook them up to the same monitors and amps. Don't be fooled by technology. A $40 dollar pawn shop board can sound real good through a $5,000.00 PA system. Keep your eyes and your EARS open. JMIO

"Be careful who you listen to, it might make you think"©Pianodick
"Get a man drinkin' or get a man thinkin' he'll wind up looking for angles. Get a man smokin' or get a man chokin' he'll wind up looking for angels!"©2006 All rights reserved

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 01:12
Thanks for your great replys guys (and gals?). Lots of good advise here.

I went to a music store tonight and played with the Triton Extreme 88 and the ES 6 (didn't have an 8 in stock). I really liked the touch screen of the Triton, and I also liked the synthy type sounds - but the pianos fell short for me, and they are really really important to me (as I am first and foremost a piano player). The ES had a great piano sound, and otherwise pretty good sounds. The screen really sucks, and I could understand how people would think it's hard to use.

I never really got into much of the sampling or sequencing features yet as I don't know how to use them. I have to find a store that has an X8 in stock.

One quick question again... just to clarify (thanks for answering KeysBe Me) ... but you really can essentially use the sampler as a digital recorder on the X8? This is definitely one of the most important features to me. The only reason I keep asking about this is that one of the reviews I read somewhere about the Fantom X said you couldn't do this... and it sounded weird to me that you couldn't because that seems like a standard feature to me... but i just wanted to clarify.

Thanks for all of your help!

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 07:31
I haven't spent much time at HC . After looking at the Fantom reviews, there is a group of bogus postings.
One dude claimed to have tested and played the Fantom Extreme
thoroughly.


GregC
GregC

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 07:48
Yes, you can use it as a digital recorder. I have used it as a live two track for a string quartet

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 09:19
For workstations, I have a Fantom S, S88, and a Triton Studio 88. I play with 3 different acts and approx 70 gigs a year. I do use them in my studio, but mostly for live gigging. I am also primarily a piano player. I have the SRX-02, and SRX-07. My Korg has Classic Keys expansion. Since you’re looking at the FAX and TE, I’ll comment on things that are more Roland vs Korg rather than specs. My two cents:

For ease of use in general, I find the Roland easier to use than the Korg. The screen layouts are more comprehensive.

For live playing, the Rolands are very difficult for selecting sounds - there is no numeric pad or dedicated bank buttons. Even after over a year, I still fumble around scrolling to my sounds/combis, or just trying to find sounds on the fly (nearly impossible). The favorites function on the FAS is great though. The Korg is a breeze live with the touch screen and numeric pad. The Korg interface IMO is better for live playing.

For Sounds, both sound great. I think the Roland/SRX piano is better than the Korg piano. The stock FAS piano is hurtin’. If I’m doing a solo piano gig, I always bring the FAS88/SRX. If you adapt your playing to it’s idiosyncrasies, the SRX can sound remarkably good I have programmed a piano in my Korg that is really good live in a mix for rock and blues, but the Korg falls short IMO for solo piano. But you can buy samples libraries for KORG (which I don’t have). I like the Roland EP’s better – more bite and spank. I briefly tried the FAX and thought the piano was really nice. I have limited experience with Yamaha, but I think the Motif ES has the nicest piano and EP’s out there, but the interface is difficult IMO.

Organs – I have some really good organs programmed on both units. The Roland does a really good job. But, the Korg can do Killer organ. Korg has the upper hand with organs IMO. As well, Korg’s leslie similar is quite a bit better IMO. Korg drums are also better. But, I understand the FAX has some new drum samples.

Both have good systems for sequencing, but they are very different. If you plan on sequencing, I would take the time to understand how they work.

The rest of the sounds are mixed bag. Both boards sound really good in general for pads, brass, etc. I think in general Korg sounds bigger or more ‘fluffy’, while the Roland is more tighter and focused.

Sampling – I find the Roland much easier to use when sampling. But, I don’t find the quality as good. For me they usually come out thinner and not as punchy. I’ve tried everything and cannot get the results I want. IMO, The Korg sounds better in that regard - but not nearly as easy to use. Also, you can’t have samples automatically put alongside sequencer tracks on the FAS. You can sample while the sequencer is running, but you have to manually put the wave into a performance, and then trigger it with the sequencer – it’s not an easy task IMO. The TS automatically does it for you.

Talking weighted actions: For piano playing, the FAS88 keys are definitely heavier and more dynamic. Korg’s keys are not as deep and faster. I can really smoke on the TS88 after playing on the FAS88. I like the Roland’s feel better, but you need to keep in shape if you want to be aggressive. I guess I would say – Roland for piano, Korg for organ/synth. I won’t comment on synth actions because I don’t like any of them. I only use my FAS for rehearsals and gigs with tight spaces.

As far as durability, you need to be very careful with Korg’s stuff. They chip really easy. Roland has a better design – the metal ends are great.

In the end, I would try them all out, and decide for yourself based on what you need. All of the workstations out today soundsgreat and are very capable. For me, the omission of a number pad and bank buttons on the FAS is a major issue. But if you’re not playing live or you don’t do a lot of changes, it might not be an issue for you.

If I had to choose? Well, this is a Roland forum. Both boards have their pros and cons. They both sound great. But, for gigging the Korg is better – and I gig a lot. So?


bb
bb

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 11:34
Billip:
"One quick question again... just to clarify (thanks for answering KeysBe Me) ... but you really can essentially use the sampler as a digital recorder on the X8? This is definitely one of the most important features to me."

Well, it depends how you define a digital recorder.

If you think of digital recorder as a regular hard disk based multitrack digital recorder, then Fantom-X is not a digital recorder. It's doesn't record audio directly on the Flash Card on a track. It creates samples in the memory, you have to save to the card and then assign that sample to a key to played back in sequencer. These samples must be reloaded to memory upon restart. There are no hard disk or flash card based 'aduio' tracks in Fantom-X.

If you think of a digital recorder as a sampler capable of recording long samples to RAM, then yes it a digital recorder.

There was a long discussion about this few months ago...
http://forum.fantomized.info/?action=show_thread&thread=2550&fid=3&s=0&e=15

--------------------
Remember that there are only 3 MFX + 1 Reverb + 1 Chorus in Fantom-S/X and you have to share them across 16 parts (patches) in a song.

live a musical life
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 14:21
One quick question again... just to clarify (thanks for answering KeysBe Me) ... but you really can essentially use the sampler as a digital recorder on the X8? This is definitely one of the most important features to me."

You might be dissapointed with save/load times. Let's say you record 4 tracks of stereo audio for 5 minutes. That's 10MB/min X 5minutes X 4 tracks= 200MB. It will take a little over 10 minutes to load and about 15 minutes to save. This is each time you turn the Fantom on (go to load) or go to turn it off(need to save).

That's assuming you only need one take for each track. Let's say you are carefull with your takes and only wind up with 2 or 3 takes per track. Now its 400-600 MB and 20-30 minutes to load and 30-45 minutes to save.

How practical is that?

Also there is no EQ on each track which is essential for recording/mixing.

All workstations suffer from this slow load/save limitation. If you need something to record vocals/guitar then get a hard disk recorder (you will be able to take advantage of its built in mixer). Or set your PC up for recording.


When we say that the Fantom-X can be used as a recorder it's kind of meant in the same way that you can use a paper cup to fill a swimming pool.
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: Arg!! Which workstation to buy?

30 Jul 2004, 17:54
I agree with almost everything said so far in this post. It's a really hard decision. This year's candidates (Fantom-X, Triton-EX, Motif-ES) are all so good in different ways that it really makes it tough to choose.

There has been a good deal said about overall "fatness" of a particular instrument. I agree that it is perceptible. My opinion - Triton EX fattest, Motif ES second fattest, Fantom-X is least fat. In fact the Fantom can even sound somewhat anemic at times to my ears. Especially the carryover waves that have been recycled through Roland's product line since the early nineties (c'mon Roland put those to bed once and for all!)

That being said compared to what was available even a few years ago all of the workstations sound great. So this question of which is best is one that only a few hands-on comparisons, separated by at least a few days each, can answer. It would be great to find a store with all three units displayed at once. My local Guitar Center affords me this option.

For me, first of all the Triton Extreme is out. It is a cool board, but it's overpriced, and its technology is aging - it uses the same voice and polyphony allocation that has been around for coming on 10 years. I guess if you're a Korg guy you might be interested, but I'll wait to see what they do at the next NAMM show. That leaves Fantom-X verus Motif ES for me.

Why I continue to lean toward the Fantom in the face of the Motif having more of a pleasing soundset for my uses, better expandibility - i.e. the PLG boards offering entirely new forms of synthesis, the new acoustic piano PLG board, and the MLAN digital interface which will allow 16 channels of audio and almost unlimited MIDI to travel over a single FireWire cable, is that the Motif by very virtue of having all of these features crammed into a crowded front panel with a relatively small monochromatic LCD, almost shouts that it's difficult to use in real world production or gigging. Just cruise over to Motifator.com and read the Motif ES forum section. You will see hundreds (thousands maybe) of posts requesting help for a myriad of usability issues. It seems like you've got to jump through a whole bunch of hoops to get music out of this machine. Is that how you want to spend your time with your workstation - posting to a bulletin board and waiting for replies which may or may not work?

I think that Winter NAMM 2005 will see Yamaha and maybe Korg releasing a new generation of workstation each having a big, friendly color LCD like Fantom-X. Korg will probably update their soundset and polyphony allocation as well. Both units will probably interface much more tightly with the computer. Roland will most likely not update the Fantoms anymore. They may take 2005 off from the workstation release cycle, since they released Fantom-S in 2003 and Fantom-X in 2004. I think we'll see another boutique product like the V-Synth, and alot of software stuff. Of course Roland always surprises, so anything's possible.

In the meantime, and this is what I consider, even if something perfect for your application is announced in late January 2005 at NAMM, it won't really show up until around May 2005. So we're talking 39-40 weeks here. In that time alot of music can be made.

Bottom line - the Motif continues to tempt with its great sounds, polyphony (well over 200 if you add the new PLG acoustic piano board and maybe one other), effects (at least 8), and interfacing (MLan). But all of this crammed into a small monochromatic LCD which is only a window into an operating system that many, many users seem to struggle with, even as they gain more experience, tilts me back away from the Motif and towards the Fantom-X.

It's great to have all those features, but if you can't get to 'em easily, what good are they really? Best of luck with your decision.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X