Fantom-G

The Fantom G and people moaning about it

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 04:30
The only thing I want to say is: live and let others live. If you have to say something good about the FG, say it. If you have to complain about something, do it. Equally rights to everyone. It's ridiculous that people who have issues are told to make music or "use" the "fantastic" board instead to complain. It's IMHO equally ridiculous to advice somebody to sell his gear because he has issues. A honest poster will point out the good and the bad sides of the keyboard if asked to. That's what this topic IMO is all about. And not about the number of sounds and expansions.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 08:31
Well the original poster was just amazed at the G and could nt understand why people bemoan the G.
Since alot of us come from the X there has been major comparisons disappointments and frustrations this is where most grievances come from.
The G as an instrument in its own right is a great machine its only when you come from X to G do you start to feel frustrated.
Its usually just disheartening when a board that has so much potential is badly marketed and supported.
Knowing that just a few software tweaks could make this board top class.
but thats that and we have what we got, so all we can do is use it to it fullest despite any further lack of support.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 10:35
aster wrote:
Triton Extr-88
M3-M(Radias,EXB-M256)
Roland Fantom G7(ARX-01, ARX-02,1 GB Ram)
Yamaha Motif Rack XS
Roland XV-5080 Xpanded SRX SRJV
Fantom XR

Is this a live rig ? To me your set up looks duplicative...how do You use this set up ? What's the logic behind it..it appears very workstation Based / sample based sounds...
ok now that that's over... maybe I can address this question.

"Is this a live rig? Yes This is mainly a live rig, but does get some studio work as well.

"duplicative" yes somewhat... but to me the Roland stuff all has a different sound to it. Plus the interfaces make for a different user experience with each one. The Korg stuff is not duplicative (IMO)

"How do I use this set up" Currently I am using the Triton Extreme as a master controller for everything (as far as playing the weighted keys) The onboard controllers (knobs, etc...) on the Extreme help me as far as modifying parameters on the various modules. But the Fantom G is the king controller.... (we all know that) I have combis set up in the Extreme where I have saved the different controller mappings to the respective module. (example: A combi on the Extreme called Motif XS Rack has settings saved in it where the controls are mapped to the most frequently used parameters on the XS rack... same thing with XR etc...) (you can also use Programs to do this, but with Combis it makes it a little more seamless because in a combi you can specify the midi channel that THAT specific combi is transmitting on... where as in program mode it's just always transmitting on the global channel. When I use a combi I can tell the XS rack combi to transmit on channel 3 ONLY... so when I'm in the combi, the extreme is ONLY sending messages to the XS Rack (because it's getting messages on midi channel 3).

Another nice thing about the combis is that I can specify a combi that is transmitting on ALL the midi channels that my modules are reading from... and control all of them at once. This is what I'm currently working on. But with a limited amount of control knobs etc... on the extreme it's kinda hard to be able to control everything you want to control on the modules at the same time... (but the Fantom G helps in this regard quite nice. It's just a matter of me getting it all set up. I don't want to get TOO far into it though because I am considering the Kronos. But working on my setups will make it that much more easier when I and if I do get a Kronos.

"What is the logic behind it?" - I don't know exactly what you mean with this question... I assume you mean the logic behind my set up? Please clarify (specifically what you mean) and then I'll answer that one.

"it appears very workstation based, sample based sounds" - Yes you are correct. Romplers galore!!!! Is that a bad thing?

Looking forward to your responses!!! And I hope I answered your questions effectively.
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 12:43
train wreck? I don't get it.... LOL. fill me in.
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 15:14
Quinnx. wrote:
Its usually just disheartening when a board that has so much potential is badly marketed and supported.
Knowing that just a few software tweaks could make this board top class.
but thats that and we have what we got, so all we can do is use it to it fullest despite any further lack of support.
completely agree. :)

imho hardware workstations are a thing of the past. real workstations are now controller + DAW.

i think roland will release a massive 88key controller + software packages next and concentrate more on building digital pianos where performers are not very computer savvy. i had to force myself to get back into DAW since my last system from 15yrs ago lol but now im not looking back. korons = old news.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 16:59
kenchan wrote:
imho hardware workstations are a thing of the past. real workstations are now controller + DAW.
They are a thing of the past for serious all in one solution when it comes to recording. But they are still the best option for performing live.
There is no point for Roland in releasing a controller and a DAW. There are dozens of controllers and DAWs already on the market.
If Cubase/Sonar/Logic/Ableton/GarageBand/ProTools/Digital Performer/Reaper/Tracktion/Studio One and a few dozens of others don't do it for you, there is now way that Roland will be able to give you anything above that. The same is IMHO true for controllers.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 18:55
mojkarma wrote:
kenchan wrote:
imho hardware workstations are a thing of the past. real workstations are now controller + DAW.
They are a thing of the past for serious all in one solution when it comes to recording. But they are still the best option for performing live.
There is no point for Roland in releasing a controller and a DAW. There are dozens of controllers and DAWs already on the market.
If Cubase/Sonar/Logic/Ableton/GarageBand/ProTools/Digital Performer/Reaper/Tracktion/Studio One and a few dozens of others don't do it for you, there is now way that Roland will be able to give you anything above that. The same is IMHO true for controllers.
when you say all in one recording... do you mean for instrumentation or vocals too?.... either way.... what about what the Fantom G... or the Kronos offer (as far as "all-in-one" solutions)...?
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 19:27
Yes, I mean everything, the instruments, regardless if vst or real and also the vocals. Especially vocals can be tricky. The singer makes mistakes, sings slightly out of tune or thinks that he/she can do better. It requires multiple takes, sometimes quite a lot of them. It also requires the recording engineer not to step in with technical issues. On software you don't have to bother with anything. If you're experienced with your software, you'll support the singer instead of let him wait until you handle your tool. With software you can repeat the same parts of the song while the software creates a new track or lane and automatically mutes the previous one, nothing gets lost since all is recorded onto HD with lot of space, and so on.
Neither FG nor the Kronos comes nowhere near to what any recording software can give you. Not to mention proper monitoring for you and the singer and some other tasks.
And at the end, even the mixing part can't be done properly on the FG. Especially not because of its limitation. Mixing vocals requires a good EQ, Compressor and often a deesser. That's 3 effects agains one available on the FG.
A hardware workstation is good to put some ideas onto the tracks or to prepare the keyboard tracks, but certainly not to record, mix and master a final radio ready song.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

30 Aug 2011, 19:51
not to bring up old news.... but remember we talked about utilizing the gear...;)

you can re-sample the vocal with the EQ, then with the Compressor... (I don't think we have a deeser LOL)
or would that not work right? (i'm just saying...)
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

31 Aug 2011, 04:38
apex wrote:
you can re-sample the vocal with the EQ, then with the Compressor... (I don't think we have a deeser LOL)
or would that not work right? (i'm just saying...)
Yes that would work as a primitive freeze function in the case you also keep the unprocessed wave file. However, it's not really what I would call "working". It's a workaround and the more you have to use it, the more cumbersome it gets to work in that way with the FG. You make one settings the first day, resample it, come back the next day with a fresh ear and conclude that you don't like the results. Now you have to go back to the original file and do the whole process all over again. And that's just for the vocals. Apply that to other audio tracks and you'll spend more time with workarounds than actually working on and with music.
As I said, a hardware workstation these days simply can't be used as a serious instrument for recording, mixing and mastering. Some musical styles are maybe possible, but for most other styles the software is simply the way to go.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

31 Aug 2011, 07:51
Quinnx I think that is a decent summary...

Despite the bold specifications and claims the fantom G is not superior to its predecessor in many ways and never even met the functionality clearly stated in its documentation...

But it is a great hardware platform with clearly good processing power, and great build and user interface.. it could have been a really great machine..and THAT is the most annoying thing.
Quinnx. wrote:
Well the original poster was just amazed at the G and could nt understand why people bemoan the G.
Since alot of us come from the X there has been major comparisons disappointments and frustrations this is where most grievances come from.
The G as an instrument in its own right is a great machine its only when you come from X to G do you start to feel frustrated.
Its usually just disheartening when a board that has so much potential is badly marketed and supported.
Knowing that just a few software tweaks could make this board top class.
but thats that and we have what we got, so all we can do is use it to it fullest despite any further lack of support.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

31 Aug 2011, 14:04
mojkarma wrote:
kenchan wrote:
imho hardware workstations are a thing of the past. real workstations are now controller + DAW.
They are a thing of the past for serious all in one solution when it comes to recording. But they are still the best option for performing live.
There is no point for Roland in releasing a controller and a DAW. There are dozens of controllers and DAWs already on the market.
If Cubase/Sonar/Logic/Ableton/GarageBand/ProTools/Digital Performer/Reaper/Tracktion/Studio One and a few dozens of others don't do it for you, there is now way that Roland will be able to give you anything above that. The same is IMHO true for controllers.
yah, but i dont care about performing live... lol ;) jk. DJ's are using laptops now. just use that and controller surface for your orange button performance. or just record the whole damn thing and pretend like you're doing something on stage with your headphones hanging from one ear.

ofcourse there is a point for roland to release a controller and DAW. dont be so selfish thinking everyone enjoys those cheezy plasticy spring-back synth keybeds. i want PHA3 with escapement on my controller and hook it up to my MPB to run DAW. i could careless about cakewalk though. :D hahaha.

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

31 Aug 2011, 14:39
There is absolutely no real "workstation" equivalent in the controller+DAW world ... The wide variety of quality sounds, relative ease of use, stability and all-in-oneness has yet to even be attempted yet ... (Sure you can do some of this with current "solutions," but in this case, less really is more ... )

If Roland doesn't do it, you can bet your last dollar Native Insturments will when they release a keyboard version of a Maschine-like DAW and soundset (pure speculation on my part but I truly believe they will ... )
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: The Fantom G and people moaning about it

31 Aug 2011, 15:00
Diametro wrote:
There is absolutely no real "workstation" equivalent in the controller+DAW world ... The wide variety of quality sounds, relative ease of use, stability and all-in-oneness has yet to even be attempted yet ... (Sure you can do some of this with current "solutions," but in this case, less really is more ... )

If Roland doesn't do it, you can bet your last dollar Native Insturments will when they release a keyboard version of a Maschine-like DAW and soundset (pure speculation on my part but I truly believe they will ... )

yep! the opportunity is there for roland to introduce a new workstation of tomorrow and leap ahead of kronos. kronos is a glorified workstation of yesterday imho. i will not be buying hardware workstations any more as DAW+controller is much more effective, expandable, and versatile... and carrying an extra bag with laptop and hard drive is nothing to me. heck, i can just borrow a keyboard and hook it up to that instead of lugging around a 70lbs (G8).

my setup is G8 + DAW. that's it. and just borrow a keybed if i move around, carry just my mac and some prepheral. :)

← Back to Fantom-G