I think most of the negativity regarding the Fantom G initially involved the lackluster ac. Pianos plus it was kind of half-baked when it shipped from the factory in May '08. You could not export sequences as .mid to a computer until a later OS update fixed that issue. There were several other bugs discovered initially as well so people were complaining somewhat about them also. Which I guess worked because Roland eventually resolved several of the bug issues over a total of three or four OS updates with the latest OS being 1.50. There are still a few issues with the Fantom G OS but it is much better than when it originally shipped needless to say.
Having owned a Fantom G7 since May '08 I still really like it and the sounds are still some of the best that you'll find on any workstation currently on the market. Yeah, that includes Korg's latest addition Kronos also in my opinion.
A bigger gripe Fantom G owners had was not so much about the few shortcomings on the Fantom G but rather complaints regarding Roland staff who ditched Fantom G owners on this forum leaving them high and dry to fend for themselves. Roland abruptly cut off all communications basically after OS 1.40 came out leaving users scratching their heads as to why Roland would just "up and run" off and quit engaging their customers verbally. I think Roland simply couldn't 'take the heat' i.e. they didn't know how to handle the strong opinionated debate on this Forum and because they couldn't "stand the heat" they simply got out of the kitchen. To the Fantom G owner's chagrin I might add. But it is what it is.
I don't blame Roland U.S. or Roland U.K. for what was ultimately Roland Japan's decision to "pull the plug" on communications. Many Japanese don't really like heated confrontation and Roland Japan CEO and other higher ups at Roland Japan are obviously in that percentile of those who don't.
Roland Japan has also apparently "pulled the plug" on any further development on the Fantom G so OS 1.50 is likely the last OS we'll see plus no more ARX cards either. But the Fantom G is still a highly usable workstation keyboard that has many wonderful sounds and a lot of advanced features, like seamless sound switching and a huge LCD screen, amongst others. It is a highly professional keyboard that's built like a tank and therefore should last quite a long time giving users years and years of playing enjoyment. Which has been my experience after owning my Fantom G7 for over 3 1/2 years already.
Next on tap? Roland is diligently working on their next top-of-the-line keyboard product but it's anybodies guess when they'll finally release it. I'm assuming it will be a 'true' workstation with a Sampler, on-board Sequencer and hopefully Expansion capability and also 256 note polyphony with the caveat - [varies according to sound generator load

]. Whatever that means.