Fantom-S and Fantom-X

What's so good about the Fantom X

What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 07:43
Hey all

I'm (a newbie) in the market for a Fantom S but don't want to be left behind.

I've owned Roland gear before: W30, D50, XP50, XP60, XV5050....

But what's so great about the Fantom X that I should spend the extra £500 on? I'm quite skint at the moment, but have just sold an XV5050 to get a Fantom.

I should probably only consider a second hand Fantom S 61 - or should I go without keyboard for a while to save up for the X? I've read the Roland site to try figure out what the main difference between the S and the X is - but as far as I see there's not that much difference.

Could someone possibly summarise the main working differences between the two (assuming for X6, not the X8!) in a list?

That would be very much appreciated!

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 07:54
Fantom-S: 64 voice poly, 64 Mb ROM, up to 288 Mb RAM, up to 128 Mb SM card, USB, 4-shade LCD

Fantom-X: 128 voice poly, 128 Mb ROM, up to 544 Mb RAM, up to 1 Gb PC card, USB, USB-MIDI, colour LCD, improved pads

This may help you better: http://fantom.wilkesworld.co.uk/s%20x%20comparison.htm


Artemio.

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 09:06
A 2nd hand FS61 will cost you around 1/2 the new price of a X6 in the UK

an FS61 went on ebay just for 740GBP. Turnkey are advertising the X6 at 1599GBP

Lawrence
Occasionally Grumpy Old Professor of Fantomology
Loz

What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 09:16
I recently bought a Fantom-S and returned for one good reason. With 64 voices of polyphony playing ONE piano sound with any sustain pedal ate up all of my voices.

The Fantom series uses stereo tones which can be up to 4 layers which means each note can use 8 voices potentially.

64 voices divided by 8 equals 8 notes simultaneously under the worst circumstances. I don't expect to use many of these 8 voice sounds and if I do like one of them I will edit it down to a 2 or 4 voice sound.

So though I could play my piano sound there would be nothing left for drums, samples, other tracks. Those other types of tracks won't use as many voices because they are typically simpler patches.

I really don't need the color screen and I think the S's sounds are top notch. Its sounds are so top notch I am selling other gear that I have relied on for years. Also I plan on making use of software such as Reason and Reaktor.

The X is definitely worth it for the extra storage through its PC card slot which currently supports 1 GIG using an adapter and SD camera memory or compact flash. I suspect it will support external hard disks that can connect via PC card, but we'll see. When you have something that can take up to 544 MB of samples good storage is important. The S can only store up to 128 MB of samples (smart media slot) even though you can load 288MB into its memory.

The X also has an improved user interface. We don't really know all of its improvements yet, but in the next two weeks I should know better. I have an X on special order from Guitar Center and I will get it soon.

Hope this helps...
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 09:30
"The X also has an improved user interface."

apart from color which you say you don't really need, the UI of the Fantom-X is virtually the same as the Fantom-S. And contains hardly any new functionality other than that required to support new features such as MIDI over USB . Roland have confirmed that.

Lawrence
Occasionally Grumpy Old Professor of Fantomology
Loz

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 11:55
If they improve one thing is it not improved?

Why do I sense a negative vibe?
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 12:21
I am not negative to the FX at all. You obviously haven't read my appraisal of the FX in which I concluded
"The Fantom-X clearly improves over the Fantom-S in all the major areas. Nothing is taken away and most things are increased, except the cost which is welcome. The Fantom-X is clearly an evolution of the Fantom-S with a specification and prices that will keep the Fantom range very competitive."
http://fantom.wilkesworld.co.uk/fantom%20X%20review.htm

You are the one stating it has an improved UI as a justification for buying it. I am just pointing out that the improvements are so minor it shouldn't be a major factor in that decision.

Lawrence
Occasionally Grumpy Old Professor of Fantomology
Loz

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 17:33
To clarify:

1. No one (except Roland employees) has actually touched a Fantom-X yet.
2. We have had limited contact from a Roland Product manager who has given us a few cryptic statements about what's new.
3. There are known user interface improvements such as a dedicated piano mode key on the X-6 and X-7, dedicated rhythm on/off button, pads can act as jump keys and/or part mutes, dedicated Sequencer edit and Patch edit keys, improved use of the sampling input.
4. No one is trying to attack the Fantom-S (nor should they in this community) so no need to defend its greatness. I would have kept it if it could have handled my needs.

I am hoping to help here, not offend, but if offering someone some assistance with trying to figure out what to buy is offensive I think we need to straighten out priorities here. Let's be respectful, yet honest about what these devices can and can't do.
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 17:43
Get the "X". I've never regretted getting the more expensive version of a particular synthesizer line. I've always regretted getting the cheaper version. Over the long run, the extra money will become less and less a factor. But the improvements in functionality will always be there.

But never mind all that - When's the darn thing gonna get here?! :-)

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

18 Mar 2004, 18:12
Well MIDIguru you are the one who injected some fire into the debate by stating "Why do I sense a negative vibe?", when there was none.

Lawrence
Occasionally Grumpy Old Professor of Fantomology
Loz
Well guys

Many thanks for your very helpful comments on this thread. I'm used to forums where if you ask a simple question you get answers like "do a search", but this advice has been nice and specific.

I agree with 2Tim316 who says that you never regret spending that bit extra. I've always done that.

That said - I'm jobless, with a car to run, and with lots of student debt! The only way I can justify buying at all is because I'm earning the money for the Fantom from doing gigs... and I'm using a D50 as my second keyboard at the moment (could really do with sampler as well). I will of course be buying second-hand.

I have a few more questions about the Fantom S:

Basic questions - and I assume this is possible but can someone confirm: I need to assign imported samples to one of those pad things. And set decay rates so that I only have to hit a pad once and it holds the sample whilst I am playing (say, for a rain sound in "it's raining men"!)?? Can someone confirm I can do this? I know you can't get great dynamics out of the pads but as long as I can hit them hard and get a sound it doesn't matter.

Also, is the S61 keyboard semi-weighted? I already have a Roland FP3 (graded hammer stage piano) and I could do with a non-weighted keyboard for drum programming.

I have a possible seller for £750 here in the UK (there's also one on Ebay but the reserve is apparently high)... but it's quite a drive to pick it up and could do with getting one near London for around that price. If anyone hears anything, let me know!!

Or if any UK person is selling up to get the X then please get in touch!

One more thing: can someone recommend the cheapest source for SRX cards in the UK?

Re: What's so good about the Fantom X

19 Mar 2004, 08:26
1. you can do anything with a sample. Set it to loop so it carries on, or assign it to a patch and filter it etc
You can also set up the pads so they always operate a fixed velocity - so you dont have to worry about hitting them the same each time

2. semi weighted FS61 - no

check out Sound-On-Sound reader ads.
Currently they are several at the £900 mark
http://www.soundonsound.com/readersads/AdBrowse.php?page=9&Cat=7

Loz
The artist formally know as Lawrence
Loz
Ta Loz.

Best place to get SRXs?

And if you had to choose between the Bass and Drums card and the Dynamic Drums, which would it be?

Many thanks

Mat

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X