Fantom-G

I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

what I have seen ...

19 Sep 2008, 09:24
... with other workstations with regards to multi-effects:

There are always strings attached .... (I dont like strings, but sometimes in the interest of pragmatism, one must go other routes). For example the M3 has 5 insert effects (over and above the total effects etc.) and 2 oscillators per program.

But I dont like the fact that there are certain 'double' effects, and using them causes you to lose an effect slot, similarly, using dual oscillators per program reduces the polyphony to 60 (from 120). The sequencer cannot support as many notes as the Fantom does, and there are quirks with arranging songs that you have to work around to get stuff done ...

Even with the much revered Kurzweil PC3, there are strings attached with using effects and stuff ... and you have to make it work if you want to create music with it.

With Roland, WYSIWYG, no strings attached, and I like that ;)!
If they advertise per part effects, it's exactly that, regardless of what effect you use.

I love my recently acquired M3, but am not ashamed to call attention to it's shortcomings ... if it helps others make a calculated decision.

Peace ...

;) Manish
;) Manish

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

19 Sep 2008, 09:46
Just for the record: I went to GC the other day and the G8 on display was in terrible shape, dirty finger prints all over the display, I did not know it had a touch screen........Oh, it's a touch screen that records finger prints.

Seems to me, if I was sell a $3000+ instrument, I'd keep the display clean and play it through a good monitoring system.

Just so you understand my view point I bought the Fantom G7 yesterday, and I love it, it fits right in with the my M3 and Motif XS. But, I've had to give up the Fantom X7.

I guess my point really is I love all the keyboards, I just hate GC. So I recommend no trading with GC.

And don't think for a minute that the M3 is a better sounding instrument that the G7, They both have strengths and weaknesses. Make you're choice based on your workflow and desired application.

The M3 provides a lot of instant gradification, where the G7 requires a little more work......but a good song can sound like a hit in any of the G7's, XS's, M3's out there.



PS I did not get the G7 from GC, I got it at SA.
Fantom G & X7, Motif XS6, M3, V-synth, JP8000, M1, Wavestation, Radias, Nord Lead 2X, Karma, Snow, electribes and other groove boxes.

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

19 Sep 2008, 10:29
I too have an M3 61 that sits beside my FG 88 in the studio. As I stated in other post, this is my first Roland.

What I wanted to add to this thread is that side by side, out of Yamaha HS-8M monitors, the G, sounds better than the M3. That being said, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the M3, it sounds great also. The FG is my live rig, because the M3 doesnt switch sounds without cutting off.

I owned the M3 since it first came out, and the M3 forums were littered with complaints about how the M3 was not better than the Extreme, or any other synth for that matter, how its sounds were just redone versions of Trition wave forms, how every one was trading thiers in to get a Fantom or an XS. Everyone complained about the weak sound set, lack of clarity on expansion USB (i think this is still the case).

Does any of this sound familiar?

I guess my point in all of this is, be patient. I didnt panic with my M3, despite all the haters and whiners that can post almost anything without qualification on a forum, and I have recieved significant updates. Now many of the original M3 haters have had to eat crow.

It seams that this is the normal product lifecycle. I work in technology for large scale implementations in the worlds largest banks, and I see this trend here also. Phases. Thats right, Phases. Everything has its phase. We are in Phase 1 of Fantom G. The M3 was in Phase 1 on its release, now it is in Phase 2 (after a phase 1 A soundset addition). These take time. From a project perspective, if I can get you 80% of the way there and you get 80% of the benefit, why not take it.

To my clients, I put it this way... You are going to get $1000. I dont have the whole $1k now, but I can get you $800 now and the other $200 in a year. Would you not take the $800 now? What if I said, in a year, the $200 might be $400 or $800, then what would you say? This is exactly what happened with the M3. The $200 that MOST bitched about not having, turned into another $800.

Having all $1k is not realistic in today's fast paced everchanging economy. By the time you would release it, you would be dated, and have to start over. Nevermind the fact that the cost increased exponentially with every delay. That cost is past on to you. Imagine the G, fully updated with every wishlist item, a complete blow your wad board. Now it cost $8k, ala OASYS. Would you be happy? No. The whiners would be on here whning about that too. Pick your poison.

I enjoy my FG for what it is now- a brutal LIVE synth. I enjoyed my M3 for what it was when I got it, everything else is added bonus, more return on my investment. Will the FG follow, ABSOLUTELY. This is how all technology products work.

Be free, make music..................PEACE


Dustin....AKA Subpar

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

19 Sep 2008, 10:42
I deside to keep the Fantom G and add a korg rack and conbind them both for sounds.

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

19 Sep 2008, 10:54
By Korg rack, do you mean M3M (module it wont fit in a rack) or a Triton rack....just looking for clarity here...

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

19 Sep 2008, 20:15
Well I can guarantee I will NOT be buying the next fantom for at least 3 years after it is released.
I have the Vsynth (original) and plays well with the FG.
I got the ARX02
so im pretty much got everything to last the next millenium.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

19 Sep 2008, 22:21
Exactly Quinnx!
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

20 Sep 2008, 00:24
I hear u dustin-- I got my G7 knowing its only 80% and I love it and even so, looking forward to what 90% and what that may be as if 85% is not enough to do some damage.. patient is pain but like they said, no pain no gain. you did mentioned that you used a pair of Yamaha monitors. I am thinking of getting me a pair of studio monitors for my G. Hows mackies compares to it?

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

20 Sep 2008, 01:49
get krk rockit 8's. 500 dollars and sound better then mackies

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

20 Sep 2008, 03:39
Can't agree.

For my ears even the Yamaha HS80m sound better then the KRK RP series, and from my view the KRKs RPs hardly can compare with Mackies. Friends who have the KRK Rokit tell me they experienced some unwelcome midrange problems (slightly resonant frequencies with certain instruments and voice ranges).


KRK build great Monitors, but you probably have to get some from the more expensive VXT series to get premium results. But if you spend that much money you could as well prefer a pair of premium Genelecs.

In the price range up to 500$/pair I still prefer the Yamaha HS80m over anything else.

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

21 Sep 2008, 01:03
I agree completely about the Yamaha. In the room I tested they sounded better than th KRK. The Mackie sounded great too but I just could justify the extra $$$ I have no complaints about the yamaha though. I highly recommend them.

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

6 Nov 2008, 16:34
I would like to trade my Fantom X with Fantom G!

Anyone interseted?

← Back to Fantom-G