Fantom-G

I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 11:50
It's been about 3 months now and noting from roland about up grading the Fantom G, and korg keep lowering there price
on there M3 plus they our offering for free a whole new sound set for free 340MB(or somthing like that) of sound the price is $1799 at guitar center and i paid $2600 for the Fantom but so be it i need a board with inspiration to it now not later. I been holding on to see what roland was doing to do but......
Let me know Fantom clan is that the right choice?

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 11:54
I would like to "understand" the reason for this beeing your 1ST post here. I think you've got it pretty much decided.

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 11:59
It depends if you can make the music you want to make on the M3.

Even with the new samples added, it is best to give it a thorough run though to make sure the sounds you use the most are as good or better than the G.

In my case, the Piano and EP's are of utmost importance, and the G is better in that category for me.

I would like both potentially, but again if you only can have one, make sure it suits your needs.
www.songsforthemaster.com

Strange ...

18 Sep 2008, 12:11
... How people make their 1st posts here :).

I'll give you the benefit of doubt here (That Ur not a Korg agent, or are not trying to spark up controversy ;)!!) and make some comments:

I have both the Fantom X6 and the Korg M3:

1. I bought the M3 for Karma, some of the stock sounds and of course the Free RADIAS EXB analogue, and it suits my needs very well for that.
2. I would never sell my Fantom, simply because I realize that there are some things the Fantom can do, and the Korg cannot. In short, I can probably live without my M3 and still make music, but never the reverse.
3. The Fantom sound engine (IMHO) is far more advanced and tweakable than the M3's. Live playing features are amazing.
4. The Fantom sounds much 'warmer' than the M3, honestly, I kinda like and welcome the change in timbres now that I have both, but still like the Fantom sounds over the M3 for everything ranging from Lush strings, Warm and gritty brasses, sweet flutes, pompous orchestral sounds etc. etc.. You gotta remember that I have the SRX expansions as well. I think that the G sounds (Or has the potential to sound) much better than the X, but it was way too expensive for me and I just could not escape KARMA ... ;) (Horrible Pun, sorry guys).

Not trying to push you either way, but giving you some data to make a calculated decision, do with it what you will ..

;) Manish.
;) Manish

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:21
Everyone to his taste, so what...

I personally woulnd't even take a M3 into consideration: no comparable live functionality, better EPs and other sounds I use a lot on the G etc.

But there's one thing I understand about the anger:

The G was supplied with a soundset which still leaves a lot to do better and some to do much better.
It still has no fully functional sequencer, not even on the level the manual describes.

And no lousy Roland manager is seen anywhere communicating about these OS and sound problems and the schedule for doing something about it with anyone of the customers, not even in the most well known and basic forum.

From *this* angle I *fully* understand each and every customer who says goodbye to a company who doesn't invest a bit in customer relations and has
- no own forum
- no members sent to the biggest existing forum
- no easily accessible support email adresses for technical and upgrade questions
- no soundbase for users, who instead have to do such supportive things for other users on themselves without *any* Roland support

I guess that this message above is only the tip of the iceberg, because I could name a dozen people who left their Roland keyboards and switched to Korg, Yamaha and Kurzweil recently for similar reasons.

Roland is suffering a mass loss of mucisian customers, and missing attraction of new ones even for fine new gear - the Roland G could already be *the* top workstation with first class development and support - without even noticing it or showing any reaction.

So on one hand I think anyone replacing a G with a M3 underestimates the potential of a G, but on the other hand I understand very well that disappointment and anger about Roland customer politics can and will lead to more and more of such decisions...

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:24
No I'm not a korg agent, i been on this site reading what people been saying about the Fantom G, and i also own the fantom G i been waiting for 2 months now, not saying a word
just to see was Roland going to jump on the ball and fix the problem we all have with the Fantom at this point. I'm not here to say the korg m3 is better then the fantom or none of that. I just need to know truely from members who own or who have own a M3 to let me know if i'm making the right choice. Thanks!

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:29
understanding wrote:

"...fix the problem we all have with the Fantom at this point."

Sorry mate, I don't have any problems with my Fantom. I do have problems with some people who do, though.
I also got a KORG M3-M over the weekend. Came across a nice deal.

I sold my Fantom-X for Fantom-G, but didn't end up buying Fantom-G. Instead I got the Alesis Fusion. And now I got the M3-M. I got these two at about the same money I sold my Fantom-X for.

I haven't given up on Fantom. I am hoping Fantom-G will be fixed. My only problem is with it is the effects routing copied from YAMAHA. Other than that, I could live with it. I will give some more time to Roland to fix the Fantom-G. Until then I am using Fusion and M3-M. Maybe I will get the Fantom-XR, but not Fantom-G until it's fixed.

My most favorite features from Fantom are
1- ability to program patches and drumkits from song.
2- ability to change tracks while recording and the rehearsal mode.
3- effects routing on Fantom-X.

M3-M is VERY different from Fantom-X or Fantom-G. I hope "understanding" undesrtands what he is getting. There are some things that you can do on Fantom-X and Fantom-G that are just impossible on Korg M3.

I agree with manish on most points.
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:37
I hear you man, that free upgrade Korg just did is killing it right now, it makes me wish i never sold my M3! I would say wait unitl at least November/Dec and see if they give an update, new patches, new ARX , something...you don't wanna feel dumb and sell and then two weeks later they have a ridiculous update with 500 new patches, better sequencer, etc. If they don't, you can always cop a M50 when it comes out and have all the sounds of M3 without the sampler! That's what i'm gonna do...

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:38
understanding
I'm sorry, but don't you think you should have asked BEFORE doing it TODAY? And what kind of answers are you expecting to get from a Roland forum?
I don't know what the heck you want a keyboard for or what you do with it so I might just say: "oh yeah, go for it"

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:38
there are thing s in the G that i cannot live without...(i.e. live switching, audio tracks, ease of sampling, 16 pads) and i also know that it will get better though no one has an idea of when it will... i just caution you like madahorn to make sure that you have thoroughly put both machines through its paces... the M3 is no slouch but the things that put the G over the top for me were mentioned above... happy hunting

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:40
Ok, a question for making Hip-hop, R&B, And pop, which board is the best FG, or M3?

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:45
thats for you to decide understanding... make that determination in your mind THEN decide what to do... not the other way around

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:50
I did not take it in yet to GC I'm reading everyone responce to deside. even if i do trade i will get a Fantom G if they fix the problem but what if they don't fix it until next year? I will be creating music until then you know must keep the production going out fast and freely with no set backs i'm all about the sound.

Re: I'm trading in my Fantom G for a Korg M3 today at GC

18 Sep 2008, 12:52
Strangely enough, you haven't pointed yet what the "problem" is...

← Back to Fantom-G