Fantom-S and Fantom-X

1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 02:27
Way to go venkiee, This is a major discovery regarding the Fantom's operation system. Could you do us a favor and take a digital photo of your Fantom's display when it is displaying the Memory Information screen. You know the screen that reports the amount of sample, user, and card memory? I'd like to see if the Memory Information screen reports the actual 1,000Mb +32Mb of sample ram. I'll be heading to NAMM next week and I'll ask the Roland guys if they know of any experiments with 1GB or greater memory sticks. It would be great if I could take a copy of your photo with me.

---------------------------
When most people go to work they work. When musicians go to work they play. Which do you prefer?
---------------------------
When most people go to work they work. When musicians go to work they play. Which do you prefer?

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 04:46
Sorry to break in and spoil everyone's party, but does nobody else feel that so what if it'll take 1GB since it's way_____too_____slow_____even____with___512MB____to operate anywhere near efficently. (Probably why they said 512mb is the limit).

To me, this is a serious sticking point on the Fantom since you can't really use it as a 'proper' sample editor cause it's just takes too damm long - sort it out Roland on the fantom Z.......

Steve

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 05:50
That's why..it took a very long time to load samples...like my old Triton loading samples from CD-ROM...(a bit slower than..)

What I guessed was to get rid of user queries regarding loading time of samples..Roland restricted to..512MB

Anything above that is under user's discretion....same as the capacity of the CF card they mentioned..but most of our members using 4GB CF card....I myself use a 2GB XD card....

I have no digital camera...but will try to borrow and take photos...of the info screen..

------------------------------------------
Image
Venkiee
Fantom X6 (fully maxed)....Triton Extreme....Edirol MA-15D monitors....Yamaha 03D....
Protools Digi002R....Reason 3....
Custom made PC....
------------------------------------------
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v149/paul24/palpatinehologram.gif[/IMG]
VEN KIEE
Fantom XR (fully maxed)....Korg M3.....Tascam FW1804....Cubase 5....Reason 4....
What about the Fantom XR module??
Would a 1GB work too??
...and how about using a PCcard with 2gb or even a microdrive?!

anyone knows?

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 15:28
This does not make sense to me?
Roland would not hold back that their product holds less RAM than it really has the ability to do more?

Dam it, I just bought a 512 stick of Muskin RAM and for 30 bucks more I could have had a Gig stick from Newegg.

I didnt read in the JUNO manual about any CF card limtation so I have a 2 Gig card of Scan Disk Exetreme III and it works very well.

I'm mad,
Rich

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 16:05
Yamaha did the same thing. The users discovered that they could put upto 1 gig ram in the Motif ES but yamaha said only 512 mb ram is possible.



---------------------------------------------------------------
If at first you dont succeed, then skydiving is definitively not for you.


---------------------------------------------------------------
If at first you dont succeed, then skydiving is definitively not for you.

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 18:12
Sorry to break in and spoil everyone's party, but does nobody else feel that so what if it'll take 1GB since it's way_____too_____slow_____even____with___512MB____to operate anywhere near efficently. (Probably why they said 512mb is the limit).
Yup - the sample loading performance isn't anything great and it includes all current hardware workstation. I barely can wait for 200Mb and 0.5GB is simply unbearable when waiting for. So for 1Gig you will have to sacrifice around one hour to load.

I don't know where problem is but hopefully it will be fixed in new products.
(and possibly eased in current ones by firmware updates - if Roland would allow compression for ram samples?)
Hard On!

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 19:50
Radek...Loading time is acceptable if you are not playing live...Didn't we wait during old akai samplers?

C'mon....this time issue is not a big thing to me as the KB can be made to do something...which is not mentioned usual

------------------------------------------
Image
Venkiee
Fantom X6 (fully maxed)....Triton Extreme....Edirol MA-15D monitors....Yamaha 03D....
Protools Digi002R....Reason 3....
Custom made PC....
------------------------------------------
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v149/paul24/palpatinehologram.gif[/IMG]
VEN KIEE
Fantom XR (fully maxed)....Korg M3.....Tascam FW1804....Cubase 5....Reason 4....

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 20:13
slow loading times have to do with the computer specs inside the board. When the Fantom came out they didn't use the lastest computer hardware because it would have made it very unaffordable.

There is no way to speed up the process until a newer board has better computer hardware.

For short sample takes it is very fast and that is what it was originally designed for. For long ones it takes a while but I walk away and do something else and come back to it.

I'm just glad Roland put so much into this package and made it affordable for the common guy like me.

I always say problems are possibilities.

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

10 Jan 2007, 21:49
da-man,

I second your statement. Must accept that this hardware processor was probably the best at the time of launch of this keyboard....now it's almost 3 years since Fantom X was launched...Any software upgrade will not speed-up the loading process of samples...

---------------Any way it does the job perfectly than any other synth.....IMHO

------------------------------------------
Image
Venkiee
Fantom X6 (fully maxed)....Triton Extreme....Edirol MA-15D monitors....Yamaha 03D....
Protools Digi002R....Reason 3....
Custom made PC....
------------------------------------------
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v149/paul24/palpatinehologram.gif[/IMG]
VEN KIEE
Fantom XR (fully maxed)....Korg M3.....Tascam FW1804....Cubase 5....Reason 4....

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

11 Jan 2007, 05:46
I've got to disagree da-man and venkiee - processors cost very little and the interface could have been upspec'ed without passing it on to the consumer. It is/was a cost saving sure, but it's too much of a compromise IMHO. Shoot the accountants.......

I think product design lead/cycle times is also a culprit, the design is taking too long - and the move in computer harware over an eighteen month period is two fold (moore's law).

I admire your bravery Venkiee - but for me it makes the Fantom inoperable as a 'one stop solution' for sample editing/creation etc.

Steve

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

11 Jan 2007, 07:01
I think the machines like Fantoms weren't supposed to handle so big ram samplesets. No one could predict memory will get so cheap so it's why there wasn't too much attention about loading performance. We can see it in deficiences in file system also. Anyway not everyone will use sampling as it's perfectly ok to stick just to pcm rom based sounds.

Hardware wise it shouldn't be any problem to have fast I/O thought. Ten years ago a PC has much faster I/O performance and there were pressures to improve it constantly (because of benchmarks what could affect selling of units) so it's pretty common to be able to zip 50Mb/s from hdd to ram in current PC.

Personally I don't like so big samplesets and will not use more than 100Mb at once so it's not much of problem. But I can imagine someone would like to use different big samples and it's hard to disagree as it's now it isn't convenient as it should.

For a fix in firmware update - we don't know without any knowledge about hardware internals. If I/O is done using polling technique it possibly could be improved. Perhaps if someone really tried a clever trick could be found?
Hard On!

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

15 Jan 2007, 00:01
So I wonder if this experience will translate to something like the MC909? I need to buy some RAM for mine and this sounds interesting.

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

15 Jan 2007, 00:52
Roland can give a Firmwire update to settle the loading time issue.

Also if it is done, they are matching the Motif XS, I could say... (my own opinion)....

------------------------------------------
Image
Venkiee
Fantom X6 (fully maxed)....Triton Extreme....Edirol MA-15D monitors....Yamaha 03D....
Protools Digi002R....Reason 3....
Custom made PC....
------------------------------------------
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v149/paul24/palpatinehologram.gif[/IMG]
VEN KIEE
Fantom XR (fully maxed)....Korg M3.....Tascam FW1804....Cubase 5....Reason 4....

Re: 1GB Stick of SDRAM in Fantom X ???

15 Jan 2007, 06:28
I do not see how a firmware update would improve the loading time issue. In my view the loading time is determined by hardware configuration, not software. Software optimizations may improve speed by perhaps 10-20%. Anything more substantial will require an hardware upgrade.

---
New here? Check this out!

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X