FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08

Is Roland going to react

Is Roland going to react

20 Sep 2018, 17:03
I allways had the feeling that Roland introduced the FA series as an answer to the Yamaha MOXF synths. I wonder if Roland is going to react with the introduction of Yamaha MODX?

Any thoughts?

Re: Is Roland going to react

20 Sep 2018, 18:52
Get your point as the new Yamaha is creating quite a buzz it seems, but react with what?

FM has never been Rolands thing as far as I am aware, the FA short of a few sequencer tweaks and allowing samples to be used to create custom patches is pretty much the perfect workstation sound wise and lets not forget its a proper workstation with a real sequencer, and they already brought the mapped samples in a firmware update for one of the other Roland synths, so I am sure they could easily add it to the FA.

They could compete with a firmware update and that would do it, come on, if they allowed custom sample based patches what else would anyone need?

Re: Is Roland going to react

21 Sep 2018, 06:28
As an MOXF and FA owner, i gotta say i find the two worlds apart in what they do, so i agree with you rick1234 - what exactly do they respond with and why?

This is how i see it as owner of both:-

Right now the FA is a powerhouse of sounds - There's tons in there, some great, some poor - whereas the MOFX was a tighter somewhat more refined soundest of useable sounds. The MODX is just expanding on that more and adding the FM, which like you say isn't really Roland's domain anyway. But they're also moving backwards from the sequencer aspects with the MODX, so it's moving the two even further apart than the MOFX/FA gap was previously.

The MO's also have such a different sound vs Roland, it's a much warmer analogy sound whereas i find the FA to be a more digitally sounding analog vibe - i can't quite get the right words to express what i'm saying, but how i approach and play each instrument is radically different due to the sound sets they have, and also the quick controls and filter characteristics of each. So different.

The FA is much more of a workstation in the traditional sense whereas the MO range, and especially the MODX now is a performance synth. Where the FA lacks vs the MO range is with it's playability and musicality, i.e. the sense of it being a refined instrument, loaded with performance modes and the arps from a player perspective are just pure joy.

A refined FA that adds that real time performance aspect (i.e. the multi arps, arranged by styles and variations), better articulations for acoustic sounds (Control flutes/strings etc), a pattern based sequencer for quick ideas where you can switch between verse/chorus on the fly AND adding your own samples to tones - now that would be the answer if they wanted to reply.

However, as i see it right now the FA and MODX can happily co-exist... It becomes more complicated when you look at offerings from Korg and Kurzweil however, Kurzweil gets a lot of love and maybe Roland should be focusing on their activities more than Yamaha, who have got the performance/arp based systems nailed imo.

Right now, if you're a player then the MODX wins hands down, it actively encourages you to play and with all the performances and layering/arp options it really is a dream. But, if you're composing your own music, or have a specific sound/style in mind then the FA is very strong. And on top of that, if you're comparing 88 keys then, well, i think the FA-08 has the better keys too. But they're all pretty good (other than the FA-06 lol).

Re: Is Roland going to react

30 Sep 2018, 07:50
I both agree with you that the FA is very different than the MO’s. When Roland would choose to copy the Yamaha’s than no-one would buy the Roland, beacause Yamaha makes the best Yamaha synths.

But still, I think that the FA was a reaction on the MOFX and offcourse Roland made their own kind of Synth with their own ingredients with things they can do best. But since technology has evolved and Yamaha has introduced their Montage and now the MODX, I wonder if Roland needs to evolve the FA too. I am not sure it can be done with a firmware update so samples can be loaded like the DS synths. And there are plenty of other wishes from FA owners, like making your own exp board for example.

So I don’t think Roland is going to react and put FM in an upgraded FA, but I wonder if Roland is going to react and upgrade the FA or make a new synth line to compete with the Yamaha.

Re: Is Roland going to react

1 Oct 2018, 05:01
The only new technology that Roland could put into an FA class synth/workstation would be the ACB engine from the boutique ranges. I can't think of much else they've got out there really.

Trouble is, it's not really giving you much more than the current SN-S engine, it's just another variation of a theme. BUT! If they made use of the screen and actually gave you the UI of a Juno 106, 808, SH-01 to play with which interprets the ACB engine - that would be an absolute killer feature, and would directly step in the path of Yamaha's FM-X engine.

In fact, that level of interaction is right up there with the Kronos, and i can't believe to design a few UI's takes up significant resources, it's only a still image with some controls placed on top that link to the underlying synth engine.

In fact, it's even possible that they could have room for user synths were you create your own backgrounds and place the controls that you want on a single page and share them across the community - just think of how cool/massive that would be!

They could also double the MFX power so you can have 2x per 16 parts may open up the sound possibilities more, but they would need to increase the ability of the FX available, i.e. get some warmer/analog sounding distortions/amps in there - personally i find the MOFX effects to offer many warmer options, and the MODX is a step up from that too.

Then, looking at the range, if they sort out the FA-06 keys, well, those changes would see a lot of people interested i think.

Then can come the other options like Touch Screen, Sample import/Flash memory, user library sharing/editor etc. Even aftertouch should be a consideration as i've seen a lot of unhappy people complaining that the MODX doesn't have it. Not sure if that's a niche market or not, but it seems important for people who like to buy these synths and use them as dual purpose midi controllers.

There's many routes, but not a clue what fits into budget! But Roland need to think what would excite it's users and read the negative reviews of it's competitors, as that's where they could sweep up. :-)

Re: Is Roland going to react

9 Oct 2018, 19:52
Soundwise, I believe the two (FA and MODX) form a perfect pair. Roland has its SuperNatural sounds, VA synth, clonewheel engine, sequencer and pads. Yamaha has almost 6 GB of factory samples, 1 GB of user samples, FM synth, SuperKnob and Envelope Follower.
But I prefer the MODX8 to the FA08.
Its action is lighter, ideal for pianos as well as synths and strings, and it has a wonderful open space to the right, ideal for a MacBook Pro.

Re: Is Roland going to react

10 Oct 2018, 07:46
Skijumptoes wrote:
It becomes more complicated when you look at offerings from Korg and Kurzweil however, Kurzweil gets a lot of love and maybe Roland should be focusing on their activities more than Yamaha, who have got the performance/arp based systems nailed imo.
I own an FA-06 and a Kurz PC3. I can tell you straight up the love for Kurz comes from it's intensive editing (so much control it's crazy), sound sets, and midi control (16 arps, with tails, bounce back, etc to control how the arp functions in every given variation). The UI on Kurz is so god damn awful it's amazing they sell any units, but the sounds make up for it. My Kurz has a sequencer, song mode, riff mode, etc, but they are all so complicated and time consuming that by the time you've managed to input the first note you've forgotten the entire riff or creative flow. TBH I found the FA sequencer to be a bit of a let down. As a result I use a synthstrom Deluge to do sequencing, and my FA has sat in a box for over a year as the Kurz slays the FA sound wise - there is no comparison there!

If you wanna look at what Roland could, and should do to the FA series, it's go back to the Fantom G series and do some minor tweaks. The Fantom G series was the best workstations Roland ever made, and their price to this day helps support this. The FA's drop like a stone in value the moment you buy them. You could also look at incorporating some of the crazy powerful features of the V-Synth series as well. Still to this day that synth gets praise for its sound crafting tools.

Plenty Roland could do, but I wouldn't count on any of it. Something tells me their Music division is downsizing the creativity as their commercial sectors continue to grow massively (they make loads of random machines for companies, all crazy expensive but top of the line, like mass printers and other commercial gear).

← Back to FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08