scramble wrote:Steve, have you played around with the Keyboard Velocty Curve, and the Keyboard Velocity Curve Offset? I've done this on the 08, and it's really made a difference.
Oh boy have I!
I finally "discovered" (and this may have actually be new in the 2.0 update) that there's a velocity curve for each part - 4 types and off in addition to the global action.
Here's the thing - even if I set it to heaviest and 10, and then go in and pick the curve that makes you have to whack it to get louder notes, it STILL always gets up to 128 pretty easily.
I've put it in a MIDI Monitor to check. I have the Roland A-800 Pro and it has a multitude of curves and here's the difference - I can set that on a medium high one and I simply can not hit the keys hard enough to trigger a velocity above about 110.
But I can still barely hit the FA's keys and get it up to 128 (or 127 I suppose).
I've recorded passages with both and on the whole, the FA registers about 10 units higher than the A-800.
There are also velocity offsets and limits you can set per part, but there is still no way to bring the top end down - you can bring the bottom end up, and you can make it not play if you hit it too soft or too hard, but there's no way to "limit" the top end so it doesn't get above 110 - which is where the "clang" happens in the SN-A piano sounds.
I mean seriously, I really don't have to hit it all that hard to get the top velocity and clang out of it. I suppose that's good if you want that, but I don't.
The A-800 gives me much better control over Piano and other "dynamic" sounds. So I think if I ever gig with it again I'm going to use the A-800 even though I don't really need to - so the Pianos will sound good - set the FA to a synth action for everything else (which it seems to do well with) and use the A-800 for anything where more "finesse" is needed (and aftertouch).
I have them both set up with my recording/sequencing rig so if I want to do piano, I use the A-800 for that right now.