Hello,
I don't have first hand knowledge of other boards, including the Fantom (know the Fantom Rack module well though).
I would say, you should go to a keyboard forum as well just to get 2nd and 3rd opinions.
The general consensus I gather is that the go to for Organ sounds are the Nords.
Especially for players who like drawbar control.
A lot of people also really like the Pianos on the Nords as well.
As far as being a classical pianist - what are you used to playing on? We have a Steinway D.
Yamaha doesn't sample Steinways TMK - they sample Yamahas!
So you're never going to get anything better than a Yamaha. Some people are OK with that. I think Roland used to at least sample Bosendorfer, Baldwins, and Steinways.
My feeling is, the most realistic sounding piano I ever heard was in a Roland KR 770 digital piano - and it's because that was built into a spinet like cabinet some serious speakers in it so it moved air very similar to a real soundboard which made it "feel" real in the room.
I find when I'm listening through headphones, it always sounds "artificial" in some way - like I'm listening to a recording - that's been through a mic, pre-amp, console, etc.
Classical recordings themselves all sound different - so it's hard to define "the" piano sound - I mean, there might be an "acceptable" range but if you're looking for something "definitive", I'm afraid all you're going to get are opinions.
The FA series doesn't have any built-in drawbar control - you can change the settings on the edit screen (scrolling, selecting, wheel-dialling, etc.) but in order to control them externally you need something that can send SysEx messages (and you have to program all the messages...)
So if you do a lot of drawbar work, with the FA you would have to save a bunch of preset drawbar positions and then select between them (which is now easier in 2.0 and actually quite do-able).
But changing them on the fly or making multiple changes gradually and such - not practical as is.
You'd need a controller keyboard with sliders that can send SysEx, or a DB-1 type controller (I think that's discontinued).
FWIW, I think Roland has "cheated" by moving things like Leslie cab sounds to an Effect rather than putting them in the sound itself. As such, their Rotary and overdrive (especially) effects are not very professional sounding. A lot of people on other forums complain about the Leslie (but then again, most people will also tell you there's a huge difference of the sound in the room versus the sound coming out through a speaker or headphones).
Also, again, though I've heard so many organ tones on recordings that there's no such thing as a "definitive" organ tone.
So for me, having MANY organ and piano sounds from which to choose is more important, so you can get what you need for a particular context, instead of "one sound to rule them all".
Another "for example" is that so many modern recordings are so drenched in reverb and even delay that you don't really even need a piano to sound "real" or even "good" becuase the effects make it sound like all the other ones out there and we accept it as "good" becuase it sounds like the other things we percieve as good!
User interface (and intuitive layout as well as large screen) was one of the best features of the FA series from the beginning. Can't compare to others directly, but it's really wonderful. The new 2.0 update also makes the Pads that much more versatile. The interface is, in short, amazingly well thought out and practical.
Can't comment on the weight but I understand the entire series is practically breaking weight records for lightness - but so are a lot of other manufactures.
For road-worthiness, "built like a tank" is what you usually want, even if heavy, and I think we equate light with "cheaply made" now and "less sturdy" so take that for what it is. If you're transporting it A LOT, then weight could be a deciding factor.
Latest technology. Check. Cutting edge. Supernatural sounds, and everything else is PCM. Even the GM sounds sound good! Sequencer is user-friendly and intuitive. Expandable with up to 2 expansion sound sets. Can store as many sounds from the Integra downloads as you have user memory slots for.
USB is both Audio and MIDI. Works fine. Sound quality is fine - digital at better rates than you might get out of a budget standalone interface.
It's super easy to record it into a DAW with the USB Audio interface. Play and you're done. Sounds the same as coming out the audio jacks on the FA.
Now: Sampling:
It is NOT a "sampler". You can not sample in a sound and map it to the keyboard. You can't say "Fame", and play it up and down the keyboard, changing the pitch and length of the sample as you go up and down.
It is a "sample triggerer" or "loop launcher". You can record an audio clip (or import one) and assign it to a pad. Then you press that pad and it plays that sample.
If you wanted to play a single sample across the keyboard (which can play the pads on channel 16) you'd have to sample C on pad 1, C# on pad 2, D on pad 3, and so on. It's possible to batch import, but man, time-consuming and not worth it.
Plus you can only have 4 samples playing back at once.
So it's best for triggering say, a sound effect, or a drum loop you're going to play over.
It could be a "backing track" of Bass, Drums, Guitar, and you playing keys live, and you could turn on and off the Guitar, Bass, and/or Drums on the fly as you like, and you could change to other pre-recorded Drum, Guitar, and Bass patterns, but you can never have more than 4 going at any time.
I believe they can be as long as you have time for on the SD card.
You can record internal sounds to the pads (so it could be used as a scratch pad for recording ideas).
I would say, while you can edit start and end points for loops in the FA, as always, doing this on a computer screen in a DAW is probably more practical. But you can easily export/import so that's not a biggie.
So your biggest drawbacks are:
1. Not a full fledged sample if that interests you.
2. No drawbar control onboard if that interests you.
Otherwise, other "drawbacks" would be options that are more of personal preference - do the pianos sound as good as a Nord - maybe, maybe not. Do the basses sounds as good as a Yamaha? No. Are the Strings awesome, yes. Does it have a bajillion synths? Yes, but so does everyone else.
Great all around board with tons of features at a very reasonable price.
Are there things others do better? Yes. Are there features it doesn't have? Yes (ooh, check on aftertouch on the 88 if you need it). Will there be sounds you like better in other synths? Yes.
But as a whole package instrument, it's certainly top notch. Though the Fantoms are nothing to sneeze at.
I think they're trying to bring in Fantom like features in quality to a lower price point and attract the home producer wannabes while appealing to the EDM crowd as well. Which they've accomplished.
Whether that makes it as good as a Fantom, well, can't comment on that.