Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Fantom X is a no go

Fantom X is a no go

22 Sep 2004, 17:59
To my Fantomized friends,

As you may recall, I was awaiting the arrival of the Fantom X8 I ordered back on August 5th. Unfortunately, I have cancelled my order due to a problem at Roland Canada. I am now getting a Motif ES8 tomorrow.

What happened was that I ordered the X8 on Aug 5th. Roland told my dealer that it would be delevered mid August. I checked back around Aug 15 and was told that Roland changed it to mid September. Still I waited. Then I checked a couple of weeks ago by calling Roland directly, they told my they just received a shipment of X8s and I should have mine in a few days. I waited another week and called them again, only to be told that there was none in stock. So now, I would have to wait for another to come from Japan. I then asked if they could look up my specific order, and they could not find an order for me! I was at the dealer when he placed the order so I know the dealer did their job fine.

So, Roland completely screwed up my order and I am not going to wait another 2 months to get the X8. I am getting the ES8 since I really liked it too and was debating between the two. I picked up Cubase for my G4 Mac and will be using it for sequencing anyway. I must say that I really do like the Fantom X. It has many great features. The ES also has great features and some not so great ones too. But, in the end this is the decision I made. I should finally be playing a board by the weekend!

Thank you to everyone who has responded to my past posts. I will keep checking in here even though I won't own a Fantom. I think everyone here is great and I really enjoy this site. As I stated in another post, I think this is one of the friendliest forums I have ever seen on the internet. Truely inspiring!

Best regards,
Ken

Re: Fantom X is a no go

22 Sep 2004, 18:31
Hey Seadragon Hold off on that thought, If you want to Deal with long and Mcquade I can get you a Roland Fantom X8 in no less tha na week . As roland head quarters is just down the street.



Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: Fantom X is a no go

22 Sep 2004, 18:37
Hey Partho,

Thanks for the offer, but the ES is a done deal. It will be ready for pickup tomorrow. Plus I have already paid for it. I actually am looking foward to geting the ES. The way I am looking at it is that I have never owned a Yamaha keyboard yet, so this is my chance to get first hand experience with it. I was really torn between the two when I first went shopping for a new machine. What I might do is pick up a FXR or an X6 someday to compliment my setup.

Thanks again!
Ken

Re: Fantom X is a no go

23 Sep 2004, 02:47
No worries! Yeah Motif has some great feats too! so no worries, still a quality board! No pads though:( I was thiknin bout doing Motif ES and SP-606 but i thought might as well just get the FX save some money for mainly the same thing.

Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: Fantom X is a no go

23 Sep 2004, 16:48
I understand your pain seadragon. I just picked up my X8 here in Calgary on Tuesday night. I had been waiting since the beginning of August and had been promised that "it's gonna be here tomorrow" like 15 times. My dealer traced back the problems and they are at Roland Canada. They are so unbelievably bad. They even told my dealer that they had shipped one overnight for me, and when it didn't show up and they traced back as to where it was, they admitted that they had never shipped it overnight... it was shipped regular freight. I was totally ready to cancel my order and get an ES8, but then it came in. Mine was the only one that came in (they had backorders for another 2).

Anyways... I am still fuming at Roland Canada over this - I probably should have cancelled my order just on principle.

Alas, I've got it and I'm quite satisfied. :-)

Re: Fantom X is a no go

23 Sep 2004, 17:22
seadragon,
You have made a right decision by getting the MOTIFes. You won't be disappointed at all once you get around it and know what you are doing. You can always switch to Roland if you want. but give the motif a month. try it and then go try the Roland after that. personally I felt that the only good thing about the Fantom-X was the piano. the rest of the sounds were repackdge and old compared to the motif. Your welcome to ask me any questions if you want or you can go to www.motifator.com there is nice people that will answer your questions.

Re: Fantom X is a no go

23 Sep 2004, 18:13
Hi,

Good luck seadragon. However, the Fantom is the better buy if you want great sounds quickly and with the minimum of complexity.

I only had the Motif 6 ( not ES ). I admit to being pretty dumb, but even I have got a song on the sequencer on my Fantom X 6, and the piano sounds kick ass. I never expected to advance so quickly on this baby, honest.

The Yamaha has a great sound, but I found it rather complicated in comparison. Hope you get on with it OK.

Good songs to you,

Harstro

always learning there is more to learn
always learning there is more to learn

Re: Fantom X is a no go

23 Sep 2004, 20:06
Hey everyone,

Well, my ES8 is now setup and I have been playing with it for a while. I must say that I am very impressed with it. It does sound different than the Roland. I don't mean better, just different. For instance, the Roland has very nice chorused strings. The ES has them too, but they sound a bit brighter to me. However, I have not even touched the programming end of it yet (only had it for about 2 hours).

The other thing is the keyboard itself feels different. It feels a little lighter to me compared to the X8. The Full Grand sounds very good. I think Roland has the edge on this though with their new piano.

However, this thing has AMAZING guitars. The steel string guitars sound absolutely real. I found myself playing chords and sounding like I was strumming a guitar.

Anyway, I really think that the X8 and ES8 are fine machines. I guess that's what is great about the keyboard market. There is a variety of sounds and capabilities on each machine. I am very happy now. I'm sure I would have been just as happy with the X8 too.

Yes, Roland did drop the ball on my order. Even my dealer said that they have had difficulties with them in the past. I was told many times, just like Bilip, that it was on the way. Only to find out that they seemed to have lost my order or not even processed it. This may be an isolated case, and no company is perfect. I just would have appreciated a phone call back from them telling me what was happening. I have read many a good thing about Yamaha support. They have a promotion in Canada that started Sept 1 and they are sending me the Motif ES DVD, 128 MB Smart Media card, 256MB or DIMM RAM and a $75 coupon for the purchase of a Yamaha accessory. I am VERY happy about that.

Anyway, back to my exploring!

Ken

Re: Fantom X is a no go

23 Sep 2004, 20:26
xmor,

Thanks for offering to answer my questions, I'm sure I will have some! So far I like what I've seen. It certainly is different in getting around, but I must say, it's not as hard as I thought. I have been navigating fairly easily with it tonight. Also, it sounds so much better away from the noise of the music store. You can really hear the sounds for what they really are like and I do like what I hear.

Ken

Re: Fantom X is a no go

24 Sep 2004, 02:12
yeah the guitars sound great, i just bought a electric acoustic though so i just sample it thru my FX. Simple Chords on a guitar are much easier played on the Guitar. I must say it soundsgood though, But Nylon Guitar on the fantom is amazing- Flamenco. I have a ES6 at my house right now, Rented it from The local music store, I like alot of the features its defintily 2 menus faster than the Fantom X but seeing and adjusting your filters and what not is way easier on the Fantom- Espcially TVA's and TVFS



Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: Fantom X is a no go

24 Sep 2004, 08:58
Good choice seadragon, congrats!!!!
maybe u can get a FXR in the future sometime, and expand an already great machine. soon u will 'see' and understand yamaha's engineering mentality(the ease of use, most ppl here just could'nt POSSIBLY understand). u won't be disapointed. although u would of been equally happy with the X too... But good choice once again..

now, go off and make some awsome tunes man......

Septimo ,'^)
Septimo ,'^)
X6
XT
MV-8800!!!!!!!

Re: Fantom X is a no go

24 Sep 2004, 12:28
Septimo,

Yes, I do think I would have been very happy with the X8 too. They are both great machines! I hooked up the ES8 last night and within a short time, I was already editing voices (not serious editing, just messing around). I actually had no problem navigating the ES, even with the smaller screen. And I haven't even opened the manuall yet.

But as far as the fear of having to navigate on the ES, now that I have one, I really don't think I'll have any problems. I'm very impressed with it!

Ken

Re: Fantom X is a no go

24 Sep 2004, 21:35
Thanks Nathan,

I'm sure the ES will suit my needs for a long while. I really think I will end up getting some form of Roland someday too. Roland synths have always had great sounding strings and pads, which is the kind of sounds I've always loved to play. The ES has them too, but they don't sound quite like the Roland flavor. I think I will miss the pads too. But hey, if I can pick up an X6 at some point and stack it over the ES, WOW, that would be something!

Ken

Re: Fantom X is a no go

28 Sep 2004, 05:28
Ken, I sympathize with you on the frustration of buying a Roland keyboard in Canada. I ordered my FX7 May 1st and waited til mid August. In my haste, a week before the Fantom arrived, not knowing when or if it would be shipped, I picked up a Triton Extreme, and liked it alot except for the piano sounds and a few of the solo acoustic patches. I took it back and a few days later the Fantom arrived, along with one of the expansion boards I ordered. Unfortunately, there was a pretty loud rattling sound coming from the instrument's right side below the pads every time I hit a key, even in the lower registers, so I returned my long awaited Fantom and bought a G5 Mac instead. Nice and powerful, but loud fans buzzing constantly are quite annoying. I got a call from Long&McQuade the other day informing me a new X7 was ( incredibly) in the store if I still wanted it. I could've returned the Mac to get the Fantom, but I decided I'd had enough of the chase and let it go. I'm very happy with GarageBand and Reason as my "workstations", and for now I'll find a way to muffle my G5, write some tunes, and save up for the next bout of newgearfever I always suffer whenever the Big 3 announce a new flagship.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X