New purchase concerns
22 Aug 2004, 23:27Hi everyone,
This is my first post and I've been reading with great interest on this forum. It's great to have so much valuable information available.
I decided to replace my 16 year old Roland D-20 and have ordered the Fantom X8 as well as the SRX-06 and SRX-07 expansion boards. Everything is on backorder until mid-September
My dealer let me take their display model home for a couple of weeks so I got to test it out pretty well. Here is my take on the Fantom X
Likes:
- Piano is amazing, X8 keys have great feel too.
- Strings and pads are great
- screen and interface is superb
- sampling abilities
- solidly built unit
- you can mount the Fantom as a drive on your computer desktop (very cool)
Dislikes/Concerns:
- 3 effects compared to competitors (Korg's 5, Yamaha's 8)
- loud buzzing that occurs sometimes when going through patches
- no breath controller input
- less foot pedal inputs than Motif
- the Motif had great sounding guitar strum arp patterns, not sure if these can be done on the Fantom though...
I demoed the Motif ES as well and I really liked the orchestral instruments such as flutes and horns etc (the flute sounded very realistic). The MLan option is quite interesting too. However, the interface just doesn't hold a candle to Fantom's.The arp was really cool as well but I still kept going back the Fantom because I actually liked the sounds better on it. I really like strings and pads and Roland seems to have a very healthy selection of them. Also, the piano on the X really sounds great!
I am having a little bit of buyers remorse since this is a huge purchase for me (about $5,000 CDN). I never really listened to the Korg Triton series since I thought polyphony would be an issue with its 60/60 split setup. I am now wondering if that was such a wise move on my part.
I am concerned however, that there seems to be a lot of negative hype around regarding the Fantom. I've done a lot of reading of reviews, mostly on the internet, and some of the things I ran into are:
- supposedly Roland is not being used by many bands these days? Apparently you don't see much stage presence etc. Having gone through all of my concert DVD's I must say that I didn't see any Roland, mostly Korg
- the various bugs that have been pointed out. Someone even posted something about a logic board replacement recall? I have noticed a loud buzzing sound that happens occasionally, when I am changing patches (scares you to death when it happens). This occured on all the store models I have demoed. Has anyone else noticed this?
- a lot of people have commented that Roland is a very difficult company to deal with. Even the dealer I ordered my Fantom from stated this. They originally told the dealer mid-August availibilty then a week later it was changed to mid-September. The dealer said Roland is not the easiest of the companies to deal with. They also seem to get low marks on Harmony Central reviews. Are they really that bad? I can't imagine that they could be that different from their competitors.
But, I look at my trusty old D-20. It still runs today just like it did 16 years ago. A real work horse. I am hoping that the Fantom X8 will last me quite a few years too. They seem very well built and solid.
I guess I'm just looking for some reassurance that the Roland is the way to go. It seems like a lot of people believe the Motif ES is the best workstation out there. But again that could be just hype too! I hate making these big purchases (which I don't do very often). It's very confusing to know which one to get.
Anyway, thanks for listening.
This is my first post and I've been reading with great interest on this forum. It's great to have so much valuable information available.
I decided to replace my 16 year old Roland D-20 and have ordered the Fantom X8 as well as the SRX-06 and SRX-07 expansion boards. Everything is on backorder until mid-September
My dealer let me take their display model home for a couple of weeks so I got to test it out pretty well. Here is my take on the Fantom X
Likes:
- Piano is amazing, X8 keys have great feel too.
- Strings and pads are great
- screen and interface is superb
- sampling abilities
- solidly built unit
- you can mount the Fantom as a drive on your computer desktop (very cool)
Dislikes/Concerns:
- 3 effects compared to competitors (Korg's 5, Yamaha's 8)
- loud buzzing that occurs sometimes when going through patches
- no breath controller input
- less foot pedal inputs than Motif
- the Motif had great sounding guitar strum arp patterns, not sure if these can be done on the Fantom though...
I demoed the Motif ES as well and I really liked the orchestral instruments such as flutes and horns etc (the flute sounded very realistic). The MLan option is quite interesting too. However, the interface just doesn't hold a candle to Fantom's.The arp was really cool as well but I still kept going back the Fantom because I actually liked the sounds better on it. I really like strings and pads and Roland seems to have a very healthy selection of them. Also, the piano on the X really sounds great!
I am having a little bit of buyers remorse since this is a huge purchase for me (about $5,000 CDN). I never really listened to the Korg Triton series since I thought polyphony would be an issue with its 60/60 split setup. I am now wondering if that was such a wise move on my part.
I am concerned however, that there seems to be a lot of negative hype around regarding the Fantom. I've done a lot of reading of reviews, mostly on the internet, and some of the things I ran into are:
- supposedly Roland is not being used by many bands these days? Apparently you don't see much stage presence etc. Having gone through all of my concert DVD's I must say that I didn't see any Roland, mostly Korg
- the various bugs that have been pointed out. Someone even posted something about a logic board replacement recall? I have noticed a loud buzzing sound that happens occasionally, when I am changing patches (scares you to death when it happens). This occured on all the store models I have demoed. Has anyone else noticed this?
- a lot of people have commented that Roland is a very difficult company to deal with. Even the dealer I ordered my Fantom from stated this. They originally told the dealer mid-August availibilty then a week later it was changed to mid-September. The dealer said Roland is not the easiest of the companies to deal with. They also seem to get low marks on Harmony Central reviews. Are they really that bad? I can't imagine that they could be that different from their competitors.
But, I look at my trusty old D-20. It still runs today just like it did 16 years ago. A real work horse. I am hoping that the Fantom X8 will last me quite a few years too. They seem very well built and solid.
I guess I'm just looking for some reassurance that the Roland is the way to go. It seems like a lot of people believe the Motif ES is the best workstation out there. But again that could be just hype too! I hate making these big purchases (which I don't do very often). It's very confusing to know which one to get.
Anyway, thanks for listening.