Fantom-S and Fantom-X

New purchase concerns

New purchase concerns

22 Aug 2004, 23:27
Hi everyone,

This is my first post and I've been reading with great interest on this forum. It's great to have so much valuable information available.

I decided to replace my 16 year old Roland D-20 and have ordered the Fantom X8 as well as the SRX-06 and SRX-07 expansion boards. Everything is on backorder until mid-September :-(

My dealer let me take their display model home for a couple of weeks so I got to test it out pretty well. Here is my take on the Fantom X

Likes:

- Piano is amazing, X8 keys have great feel too.
- Strings and pads are great
- screen and interface is superb
- sampling abilities
- solidly built unit
- you can mount the Fantom as a drive on your computer desktop (very cool)

Dislikes/Concerns:

- 3 effects compared to competitors (Korg's 5, Yamaha's 8)
- loud buzzing that occurs sometimes when going through patches
- no breath controller input
- less foot pedal inputs than Motif
- the Motif had great sounding guitar strum arp patterns, not sure if these can be done on the Fantom though...

I demoed the Motif ES as well and I really liked the orchestral instruments such as flutes and horns etc (the flute sounded very realistic). The MLan option is quite interesting too. However, the interface just doesn't hold a candle to Fantom's.The arp was really cool as well but I still kept going back the Fantom because I actually liked the sounds better on it. I really like strings and pads and Roland seems to have a very healthy selection of them. Also, the piano on the X really sounds great!

I am having a little bit of buyers remorse since this is a huge purchase for me (about $5,000 CDN). I never really listened to the Korg Triton series since I thought polyphony would be an issue with its 60/60 split setup. I am now wondering if that was such a wise move on my part.

I am concerned however, that there seems to be a lot of negative hype around regarding the Fantom. I've done a lot of reading of reviews, mostly on the internet, and some of the things I ran into are:

- supposedly Roland is not being used by many bands these days? Apparently you don't see much stage presence etc. Having gone through all of my concert DVD's I must say that I didn't see any Roland, mostly Korg

- the various bugs that have been pointed out. Someone even posted something about a logic board replacement recall? I have noticed a loud buzzing sound that happens occasionally, when I am changing patches (scares you to death when it happens). This occured on all the store models I have demoed. Has anyone else noticed this?

- a lot of people have commented that Roland is a very difficult company to deal with. Even the dealer I ordered my Fantom from stated this. They originally told the dealer mid-August availibilty then a week later it was changed to mid-September. The dealer said Roland is not the easiest of the companies to deal with. They also seem to get low marks on Harmony Central reviews. Are they really that bad? I can't imagine that they could be that different from their competitors.

But, I look at my trusty old D-20. It still runs today just like it did 16 years ago. A real work horse. I am hoping that the Fantom X8 will last me quite a few years too. They seem very well built and solid.

I guess I'm just looking for some reassurance that the Roland is the way to go. It seems like a lot of people believe the Motif ES is the best workstation out there. But again that could be just hype too! I hate making these big purchases (which I don't do very often). It's very confusing to know which one to get.

Anyway, thanks for listening.

Re: New purchase concerns

23 Aug 2004, 02:39
Hi seadragon.

I don't know that I'll be able to fully assuage your concerns but I can give you some facts about the Fantom-X. I cannot give you many facts about the Motif ES or Tritons as I don't have either.

- I'm not sure stage time on your DVD collection is a good measure of quality or usability. Depends on the genre of music you have on DVD. If you're into hip-hop, you'll notice a lot of Korgs on stage. ;-) Roland is apparently trying hard to get into that market (perhaps successfully). It also takes time for workstations to become stage-accepted, so to speak. I must admit, though, that I see far fewer Fantom-X keys on stage than I did the XP-80 many years ago. That board used to show up all the time!

- Bugs? Yes, there are a few bugs. One of the most severe was remedied in the latest OS update for the Fantom-X (version 1.01). There remain some minor ones and one arguably major one (namely an apparent sequencer timing issue under heavy graphical display activity). Yes, I'm aware of the reported main board recall. That has been confirmed at a Roland dealership level in the UK (i.e. no upper level management at Roland has confirmed this yet as far as I know), but the Roland US division is not yet acknowledging any such recall as of yet. This is reportedly due to the timing issue under high graphics activity, but this really seems like a software issue and not a hardware issue as it only shows up during certain display activities. There has been a confirmed report (from the Fantom-X product line manager, John Fogels) that a second OS revision is already in the works. It is unclear as to whether this revision will correct the bug or not, or when it is due for release. As I understand it though, the Motif ES and Triton have had their share of bugs. I have no details on them though.

Regarding the "buzzing" sound you hear: yes, this is a result of changing MFX algorithms under certain circumstances (as yet undetermined). This is a known issue and was a problem with the Fantom-S, if I remember correctly, but was fixed in subsequent OS revisions. The problem seems greatly reduced (but not eliminated) with revision 1.01 of the Fantom-X (I had version 1.00 and updated to 1.01).

- Roland technical support, at least in the US, is very poor. I've heard very good things about Roland Canada support though, so you may be in luck in that regard. Roland US has never had passable support. They are improving though (going from no support to bad support is an improvement).

Build quality is still relatively high, though there are some noticeable cut-backs in this area as well (namely the plastic display cover with poor adhesive to hold it on; the Fantom-S used screws, the Fantom-X uses glue). The overall construction is quite solid though. Roland seems to be relying on older (and time-tested) hardware designs, particularly in the key-bed area. The "Progressive Hammer Action" keyboard on the X8 has been around since the PA-5 and, I believe the X6 and X7 use a very similar keyboard to that of the D-50 (and XP-60 and XP-80).

I won't tell you that you've done the right thing by going with Roland, but I can tell you that I believe that the Fantom-X has a number of advantages (and disadvantages) over the competition (as you pointed out). Is there a return policy from the dealer? Or perhaps a trade-in option? You may consider asking them just in case you decide the FX is not for you, though your weeks of trial time should have given you a good idea. When I bought my Fantom-X8 from Sweetwater, I was told by the sales rep that I could return it within 30 days if I found it unsuitable for my needs. I didn't need to take advantage of that, but it was nice knowing that I could if need be.

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: New purchase concerns

23 Aug 2004, 04:48
Hey there, I am exactly at your point where I have acutlaly bought a Triton Extreme and am getting the FX8. So let me help you out.

First of all about your or pros and cons.....

1. The effects on Fantom X it seems they are less. But really there isnt because there are 3 MFX's, 1 Chorus, 1 reverb, 1 input type, and a Master Compressor wehre as Extreme is 5 Input Effects (usually youll put a reverb in. (im a reverb freak and Fantom X as Nathan told me has the best reverb) 2 Global Effects, and 1 Master EQ....EQ can be one of the effects on the fantom. So really Its only less by one Effect Process. BUT!! i can tell you this. Roland's Effects are the best, probably Best on the market. All Guitar effects units are made by Boss which is Roland and is renowned itself to be the best! So Effects sounding wise the Fantom X Shines. I domnt have much expereicne for Motif ES as the Screen is waay to small for me. I mean Geez. I heard its a great machine though so check it out.

2. Pros never use Motif ES either. Only Korg Triton, And the reason is simple, Triton bases themselves on sponsors, Sponsoring tons of artists, Such as Linkin Park, But just as any instrument Companies tend to do this and because of it Whenever you read any Reviews on Motif or Fantom , The editor will always try to put you to get a Triton. Dont be fooled. Paul Oakenfeld Uses Fantom X And really Paul Oakenfeld is amazing, if not jawdropping.

3. If you want to know about the Arp. Nathan can tell you more but, I do not know if you know that the Arp on Fantom is acutally Programmable so you can make your own in any steps, Prob use a 16 step and you can make your own guitar strum. Really The FAntom is more of a creator Workstation where as the others seem to be more of a "Preset" Workstation. But i mean Its a "workstation".

4. You might be thinking that The Fantom X does not have a ribbon controller like the other 2 do but I beleive that the D beam is somewhat on the same category and does differnt things also!

Hope this helps you !
The only hting im confused about is how many layers a performance can hold cuz the Extreme can put up to 6 Layers into one combi, and the Motif and Fantom use performances.

Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: New purchase concerns

23 Aug 2004, 05:10
Hi all.

Partho: In response to your question regarding the number of layers allowed on the Fantom-X, the Fantom-X (like all Roland XV and older Super-JV synths) can have up to 16 layers across the keyboard. Performances are not quite like Combis on the Triton because the Combis (if I understand correctly) hold all panel settings and arpeggio settings, etc. A Performance on the Fantom-X does not contain these settings, but only Patch selections and effects settings for the 16 different Parts of the Performance. However, the Fantom-X introduces a "Live Play" mode which is basically like a Combi in the Triton (so I've been told by other Triton and Fantom-X owners here on the forum). You get 320 Live Play sets. Each one contains a Performance and all the panel settings along with it. It also displays a text file for you that you can scroll through (for performance notes, etc). This feature is only on the X6, X7, and X8, not on the XR (at least I don't think it's on the XR, I have an X8 and haven't tested the XR, so I could be wrong on this).

If my information is correct, 16 layers compared to the Triton's 6 and the Motif's 4 (playable from the keyboard anyway) is far superior in terms of sound options. You can trigger up to 16 sounds at once with one key (or split the keyboard into 16 zones if you like) with the Fantom-X. This is apparently not possible with either the Triton or Motif.

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: New purchase concerns

23 Aug 2004, 10:06
hey sea, I have the Fantom XR and Extreme 76.
If you are very conservative( I am with my $), I suppose you could wait for January NAMM and see if Y/R/K does any major workstation announcements. I would not decide based on any rumors you hear prior to that.
Re: your dislikes. That loud buzzing or static burst hopefully will be corrected in a future OS . The other dislike items you listed are features on the ES Motif. Is buying an ES worth it just for those features ? I think not.
Locally, here in No. California , the Fantom X's are selling just as well as the Triton Extreme.


GregC
GregC

Re: New purchase concerns

23 Aug 2004, 15:44
Nathan, Partho and Greg,

Thank you all for your replies. I was at my dealers store today and listened again to the Motif ES and a Fantom X6 and I still like the sounds on the Fantom. I don't know what it is exactly, but it has a softer, less harsh sound than the Motif. I realize that auditioning instruments is a very subjective issue.

I do hope that they fix the issue with regards to the static burst that happens every so often (happened again today on the X6). When you are working late at night, that sure scares the hell out of me! Not to mention if it happened in a live gig, the audience would surely not appreciate it.

The reason I was at the dealer today was because my SRX-06 board came in. I took it home today (even though I am still waiting for my Fantom). I found the demo songs on the CD in high quailty AIFF format. WOW! I was blown away by these songs! They gave me a real good idea as to what I can potentially do with the Fantom. I was very impressed. So, now I think I will just chill out and wait for the phone call telling me that I can come in to pick up my X8.

Thanks again!!

Can't Wait!

27 Aug 2004, 16:53
Hi seadragon... just thought I'd share that I am also in Canada (Calgary actually) and am also waiting for my X8 to come in. Roland Canada is sure having time keeping these units available for it's customers. I'm hoping mine will be here the first or second week of September. :-)

Can't wait!

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 17:30
Hi Billip,

Yes, I am looking forward to picking up my X8. Roland Canada is getting the X8s in on September 10th (so I've been told), so I should have it by the 12th or so. I had the display model from the store at home for a couple of weeks and got the feel for it pretty quickly. I've never had a weighted keyboard before and I REALLY like the feel of the X8. You can play much more expressively I find. I could have kept the display model, but I always like "new in the box" when I purchase something, especially something this expensive. I don't want a machine that many other people have had their paws on.

My dealer called Roland Canada the other day and asked about the static burst problem. Roland told him that they are aware of the problem and that the model I will be getting will be free of this problem. I won't believe it until I see... I mean Hear it. That suggests to me that they have either updated the software or hardware. If that's the case, they will have to do something to fix the units currently out there.

I tend to agonize over almost every big purchase. I wish I had the cash to pick up the X, and a Motif and a Triton. But, reality is I can only get one. It's been a tough choice, but I am now satisfied with my purchase. The fact is that they are all great boards, but I really like the interface and overall "feel" of the X.

When did you order your X8? What was your purchase experience like?

BTW, there is a review of the X8 in the August 2004 edition of Music Tech magazine. They gave it a glowing review (9 out of 10).

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 20:31
Hi seadragon.

"When did you order your X8? What was your purchase experience like?"

If that was a general question to everyone and not directed at Billip, I had a pretty good experience with Sweetwater (via web http://www.sweetwater.com). I ordered mine a few weeks after it was announced at Winter NAMM in January and I received it in mid February if I remember correctly.

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 22:14
Well my purchase experience really sucked. This is mainly due to the fact that I have still yet to actually see or touch one. Not one music store in Calgary (a city of nearly 1 million people) has one in stock, and all of the stores I spoke to don't plan on stocking them. So my order had to be a special order, and I had to put down money for them to bring one in (even for me to just try). I ended up putting a little money down to secure one... and then after all of that I learn that they are backordered until the end of time. I've been waiting for over a month.

Having said that, I'm excited to get it because I really think it will be exactly what I want. I tried the Motif ES and Triton Extreme (both the 88 key versions) and have played an X6, so I know what the sounds/interface will be like. I also played another Roland keyboard with the PA-5 keybed, so I'm pretty confident that I know what the key feel will be like.

I really wish we had great music stores in Calgary that stocked a lot of keyboard stuff, but we don't. In the end I think it will all be worth it, and I can't wait for this thing to finally get here!!! :-)

PS: Nathan, thanks for putting some of those Fantom X preview sounds on your web site, they were very helpful to me when I was deciding on which keyboard to buy. Thanks!

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 22:22
Sorry to hear about your bad experience Billip. That is rather odd that there would be no Fantom-X8s in a city as large as Calgary (aside: I visited Calgary many years ago; nice city from what I saw), especially seeing as they have one or two here in Fresno, CA (a city of only about 450,000). It's not as though Calgary is so far away that they couldn't be shipped there. Anyway, I'm glad those previews helped you out.

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 22:24
Thats kinda weird guys Cuz i live in VAncouver BC and We have tons of X8s because the Roland HQ is in BC itself i beleive. So yah.

Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 22:40
I've always been pretty impressed with the selection and stock of stores in Vancouver as compared to Calgary. Another reason I need to move to Van! :-)

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 23:25
Haha! Its a good place, but not for music, well Canada is not good for music ahha Othe than Toronto! I wnan move to CAli

Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: New purchase concerns

27 Aug 2004, 23:29
Though I'm not much into performing, San Francisco seems to have a very active music scene. Maybe you should take a trip to SF Partho. I think your band would gain a few fans there (not that you don't have any where you're at now).

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X