Fantom-S and Fantom-X

S/PDIF: crackling noises

S/PDIF: crackling noises

2 Dec 2009, 00:39
I get crackling/popping sounds all the time when I connect my Fantom S to my audio interface (Echo AudioFire 2) through a digital (coaxial) cable. It happens with all sample rates and clock source changed from internal to S/PDIF. When I change it to internal, crackling stops (but, of course, at the same time I can't hear Fantom either). Any suggestions? I'm new to hardware recording (I have used mostly soft synths so far). I also have a Motif ES Rack and the digital connection works perfectly (using the same coaxial cable and the same audio interface).

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

2 Dec 2009, 11:22
If it's a broken digital converter or output, would anyone venture to estimate what typical repair costs might be if I send it to Roland Factory Service in CA? I've never dealt with them so far. I just wonder if it may be cheaper to buy a used Fantom S (they sell for about $500-600 at Ebay).

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

6 Dec 2009, 18:13
I believe this was a mother board issue that was fixed on later Fantom X models. I have read here on the forum that Roland has fixed the problem, but you would still have to ship it to them. If I were you I would call Roland directly and ask them. Can't hurt...
wudsiba
Fantom X6
Audio exp.

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

20 Dec 2009, 14:42
Thanks for the heads up, but I just got mine back from Crescent Technologies (handles insurance claim/tech work for Guitar Center) and my FantomX8 is still doing the same thing. I've connected through a bunch of known-working S/PDIF audio cables to no avail. The Balanced outputs (1 and 2) seem fine, but when it comes to the digital output, it's a mess. As a side note, I've also returned my Mbox2 for a new one, thinking it may be the problem, but it wasn't and everyone's clueless about the real problem.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!
-Ryan Fyffe (Dallas, TX)

p.s. I've attached a sample of the signal in mp4 format, if it helps.

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

22 Dec 2009, 20:33
reread my post... and call roland
wudsiba
Fantom X6
Audio exp.

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

6 Jan 2010, 17:23
Don't know if this helps, but i had the same problem with you (same crackling but less of it). I use an E-MU 1212 on my pc and the problem was that i had the ASIO Buffer Latency set to the lowest possible value wich is 2ms. So i started raising the latency 1ms at a time, and at 5ms the crackling stopped. My clock source is also set to "internal" and sound comes out just fine.

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

11 Jan 2010, 02:30
No real help here, rather a "me too" post.

Fantom-X 6 S/PDIF output hooked into Mbox 2 set to internal sync (via driver panel). Worked like a charm all night. Woke up this morning, doesn't work anymore - hissing, crackling whenever any note comes out of the Fantom.

I thought it might be a Mbox issue until I bumped into this thread (which, of course, doesn't mean it isn't a Mbox issue...)

No restarting of anything and no sync settings changes could fix this.

Since I'm on a tight deadline, here's my 2c : get a quality analog cable and save yourself the aggravation. I've yet to find the person who listens to a good track and remarks, "Oh, I see you've recorded the piano digitally". :)

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

26 Aug 2011, 08:02
I stumbled across this thread again by accident. Kinda late for an answer i guess but it might help someone else...

The low latency was not to blame after all.
The solution for me (E-MU 1212 PCI) was to select external sync and specificaly S/PDIF. I guess that way the Fantom itself does the syncing so no more pops and cracks.

Digital doesn't have a huge difference in sound quality, but it does sound more clear and crisp.
Also, it's convenient to always have an extra input/output handy!

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

14 Feb 2012, 12:36
fixxxer113 wrote:
The solution for me (E-MU 1212 PCI) was to select external sync and specificaly S/PDIF. I guess that way the Fantom itself does the syncing so no more pops and cracks. Also, it's convenient to always have an extra input/output handy!
Searching Google for the exact same problem, I found this thread (and also became a member of this site). My SPDIF is crackling too, but I have a different scenario. Instead of a Fantom, I have a V-Synth XT, but I imagine the digital output circuitry is the same or very similar.

I am trying to use the SPDIF coax output (but with sporatic crackles) connected into the SPDIF digital-input on an audio interface, two of which I am testing: an M-Audio Fast Track Pro and a Focusrite Saffire Pro 14.

The Focusrite interface does allow a SPDIF sync option, but that did not help. When using the M-Audio interface, the problem still exists, but it seems worse. More constant clicking and crackling. And this all occurs when no sound is playing through the SPDIF. DAW is just stopped; audio engine running. Crackling is quiet. To hear it best, headphones are used and the volume is cranked to max.

Now, get this. My DAW is Sonar X1. In order to achieve the best low latencies, I am using WDM driver mode. Latency is about 4.5ms @ 48kHz. Though nice to have low numbers, it seems BOTH interfaces have the SPDIF crackling when operated in WDM mode. In ASIO, at first tests, the crackling seems non-existant.

So what's up with that? How could the mode of the drivers used for the audio interface affect the SPDIF signal?

I am willing to bet (just a guess) a Roland audio interface (e.g., the Quad Capture) will work great. It is because of this sneaking suspicion that I may go that route anyway.

Any advice? Theories?

PS - I wonder if the crackling would also be experienced on an OPTICAL SPDIF connection?

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

2 Mar 2012, 11:03
With respect to my above situation...about a week ago, I finally troubleshooted and solved my problem. It turns out that my motherboard was to blame. Apparently, Gigabyte mobos are prone to weird hardware latency problems. My particular mobo was the GA-EP45-UD3P, which at up to this point, was a rock-solid board. Even after reinstallations of Win7, stripped down and running bare bones in the hardware department, the latency issue still remained. Now keep in mind, these latency issues are separate (but related) then the audio latency we all know, i.e. the ASIO latencies, etc. These latencies, however, are observed as "delays" in the program DPClat.exe.

Anyway, by replacing my Gigabyte board with a new/old Asus P5Q, my audio cracking problem no longer exists. I am able to run small ASIO buffers with good audio latencies, even up to 96Khz with my interface.

Bizarre.

Re: S/PDIF: crackling noises

22 May 2012, 00:09
I got a crackle from the Fan X going into a RME Fireface 400. It was like an old record crackle in that it came around every 1-2 seconds and then was quiet. Only when I held the note down though, when all notes were off, the crackle was gone.

Anyway, I got the "record crackle" to be more manageable on the FF400 as follows. Go into Fireface Settings and click on the DDS tab. Enable DDS. If you raise the multiplier to 2x, you can hear the crackle happening twice as fast...like the record is now on 45 rpm instead of 33. Raise it to 4x and I assume it is 4x as fast but it is mostly outside the range of human hearing at that point and can be easily EQd out. Kind of a crap fix but it's something to try.

AHA, put the Fireface in AutoSync Clock Mode (instead of Master) and Preferred sync as SPDIF in and ... clean as a whistle! Seems the audio card sync needs to slave to the Fantom.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X