Fantom-G

Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 07:55
I'm considering buying a used G8, to use mostly as a home studio workstation and as a "stage piano" (meaning, I'd take it to gigs to play mostly bread & butter sounds live). So that said - I'm interested in the workstation features such as sequencing and sampling as well.

I would buy a stage piano like the Yamaha CP5 or the Roland RD700NX (the "ivory" feels amazing), but I also feel like would want to have a hardware workstation for a change, and got a good deal on a used G8. I've got a Mac laptop loaded with various software instruments and Logic & DP7, so of course won't be relying on it exclusively for creating music. I've actually performed live with my laptop and a 88-key MIDI controller...but it's just such a hassle.

This forum is filled with so many threads regarding the G's limitations, disappointments and downfalls, it's increasingly difficult to find a concise thread - so I thought I'd start a new one asking the very question.

Could someone knowledgeable summarize a brief list, perhaps, on why to pass on buying a Fantom-G in 2012!

I'm well aware that it was first released incomplete, the ARX cards are discontinued (as is part of the model lineup), the sounds were supposed to be "the best of SRX" but weren't, etc...but is there something that's still horribly wrong even after update 1.30?

(And also, what's a suitable price for a used G8 these days in your opinion?)

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 10:15
For a start, why would you assume there is something "wrong". Yes, I know, you've heard a lot about it here. That's what's "wrong" with it ;-)
I've used/use the G8 live and at my home studio (not so much as I would like now but that has nothing to do with the G8), it has a awsome weighted "ivory" keyboard, the sounds are just great (I never understood that "best of SRX" thing) - more on some sounds, not so better on others, it works like a top sampler, the sequencer works fine if you get along with its system, the display is a great help on navigating functions, it's built like a tank and... yes... there are some flaws like in just every other thing on the market.
In the end, if you like the weighted keyboard, and I believe you will since you also considered the RD-700 and some of its sounds I guess you'll be just fine with it.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 10:33
The G8 is more "incomplete" than wrong.. and yes there are certain things that make it very irritating when attempting home production however, for your intended purpose it is still possibly the best available bang/buck solution.. a good spread of sounds, large friendly easy to use UI and the sequencer works perfectly well enough for your application and is a big bonus when playing live as is the ability to play sampled instruments.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 10:54
Yeah, well, see this is what I'd like to hear more about:

- Why is it "incomplete"? What crucial is missing?
- What irritates you the most, regarding home production?
- the sequencer works fine if "I get along with the system" - what does this mean?

I guess I assumed there is something "wrong" with it because that's just the overall impression I had, reading all those discussions on here. And I was wondering if the situation had improved along with the 1.30 update - I know people are also quite upset that a 2.0 update probably won't see the light of day.

And yes, I'm a pianist so a weighted keyboard is a must.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 11:57
To me, the biggest problems lie in the sequencer. For anyone who has any background in sequencing, it is extremely frustrating and limited. You see, the sequencer in the Fantom is a dumbed-down loop / beatz recorder, with everything centered around patterns that you are expected to loop, reuse, etc. And don't even get me started on it's HORRIBLE support for non-4/4 time signatures.

YES, of course if you have enough patience and remaining sanity you can sequence whatever you want on it, but let me tell you, if you are coming from a Logic / DP background you are going to be sorely disappointed (and probably in utter disbelief).

As far as the "other side" of the G - performing / sampling - I don't have any major complaints. The sounds that are there are good, but again (like on the Jupiter80) it seems like Roland are more interested in putting at least 1 patch representing *every instrument on Earth* rather than really focusing on what keyboard players need. I keep coming back to the fact that there are no Mellotron patches on the Fantom-G -- now, I know not everyone needs Mellotron sounds, but for an all-in-one workstation to not include any, well, it shows how out of touch Roland is with its keyboard-player base. The same could be said about Choir sounds, which I think is another important one to be in there.

The best thing about the Fantom-G is the Live Set / performance aspect. Playing a show with multiple live sets for each song, with tons of layers and splits, feels very comfortable and you really feel "in control".

So, as long as you don't touch the sequencer, I think you'll probably be happy.

Rick

---
[Fantom G6] [Fantom-S61 + SRX01/07/09] [SH-201] [JP-8000] [D-50] [D-5]

Widow's Walk ~ http://www.widowswalk.ca ~ http://www.myspace.com/widowswalkprog

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 12:08
I would agree with rbarkhouse in regards to sequencing with the 'G'. Mastering phrase-based sequencing when coming from a chrono-linear sequencing background has been my biggest challenge.
PiaKnowGuy
Please feel free to listen to Pirates
[img]http://www.piaknow.com/1goldpiaknowlogonew-thumbnail-thumbnail.jpg[/img]
PiaKnow

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 13:37
No sequencer on any workstation can hold a candle to even the simplest of PC based midi sequencers. The fantom G has its sequencer derived from, but not equal to, the MV8800, which imho is one of the hands down best and simplest to use hardware sequencers..

Phrase based vs linear requires a bit of a mind shift.. thats all... its simply not what most folks are used to.

The issues with the FG sequencer are more at the detailed phrase edit level where the logic of action is not fluid.. hence the FG is great at capturing segments and sketching ideas but it is a bit tiresome for full music production... By analogy I mean, if you had a car and a bicycle at your disposal, i doubt that you would take the bike to go 500 miles...it would do it, but why bother?

HOWEVER again, in your application where you are likely to be transcribing sequenced material from your PC into the fantom for live playback it operates flawlessly, and in combination with live mode with seamless switching makes FG perfect for this type of use...

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 13:51
Considering that you already have a software solution in the form of DP7 and Logic, I'd really pass on the try to be involved into using a workstation sequencer. Put simply, if you are experienced with Logic/DP7, you'll spend seconds to accomplish certain tasks for which you'll spend minutes and more otherwise on the FG sequencer. The features are simply incomparable between a software DAW and a workstation sequencer. And I don't see why you would go the hardware route while you have fantastic solutions right on your macbook. But that's just me.
I don't use the sequencer on the FG so there is nothing I can tell about. For the rest and what's "wrong" with the FG, well, the cumbersome limited file system is one thing. But there is no need to go further into details.

But there is something other "wrong" with the FG and that is its weight. It's a monster and barely moveable. If you want to use it for gigging, be prepared to have a hard time and you want be able to do it by yourself, especially not alone and without the help of other people. It's also big. Add to its weight a hard case and there are some women weighting less than this beast! :)

In your situation, I'd rather go with the RD700NX. It's lighter, it has a more compact size which makes it also easier to transport, it has an even better keybed for piano stuff, it has bread and butter sounds, you can use those sounds also in your production and you can create all your music on logic/dp7, make a mix down and play it right from an usb stick on a RD700NX. The piano sound is also substantial better than what you'll find on the FG.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 19:38
For me, the G shines as a live board and a sampler. I looked at all the alternatives and kept coming back to the G6. It's very well built, and is very fast to create splits and layers, and the seamless patch change is a must if you like to gig with one board and switch between sounds. Generally it works very well. I haven't really used the sequencer yet so can't comment on that. The downside is the lack of file utilities when it come to moving multi-sampled instruments, and some bugs or missing features, which lead to that "slightly unfinished feel" but it hasn't been a big issue for me. My Fantom exists in the studio alongside Logic Pro so it fits in well as master controller. I was also familiar with the Roland sound engine which factored into my decision, as I wanted something with a small learning curve, which it had for me. I have all three ARX cards and 01 and 03 are brilliant. 02 I haven't been blown away by compared to the stock EPs. Most of the sounds on the Fantom range from excellent to acceptable, synth sounds being the strong point, organs and strings the weak point, but programming and sampling can get around those issues. So all in all I'm happy. As for weight, I have no room for the G8 but you may want to think about the weight issue as it is very heavy. For gigs and G6 or G7 may been better as the even the G6 is about 25 kgs by the time you get in into a decent case.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

7 Feb 2012, 22:09
Could someone knowledgeable summarize a brief list, perhaps, on why to pass on buying a Fantom-G in 2012!
Right now you have the advantage..
The G has matured since it was released and you can get it cheaper than it was originally marked up.

Overall at the price you can get it for on ebay... its a good deal.
everything works
and with patience if you have that.. there are unlimited possibilities.

If i knew as much as i know now about the G and had the cash to get one at the price its going now I would get it..

Its a good investment as long as your in it for the long haul and its not just a fashion item as it would appear to be for most who dont take time to master it.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

8 Feb 2012, 02:02
Thanks for all the helpful replies, guys!

I think you misunderstood a bit when I said I'm coming from software sequencers - it's actually the other way around, I'm very familiar with hardware workstation sequencing (and the limitations), and just like pretty much everyone else, started with hardware workstations before eventually moving into software. The reason why I said I'd like to have a hardware sequencer for a change is that it'd be nice to have an actual instrument you could write music on instead of always touching a computer.

So I suppose it would indeed be more like a "scratchpad" for ideas, loops and beats. That said, I'm actually very comfortable with the phrase-based workflow method - that's how most my songs begin, as grooves, chord patterns. That's actually how it's done on a Motif as well, you build Patterns which you then chain into a Song.

What I'm actually most worried about now is the weight and size of it - it does seem like a beast, for all the wrong reasons, and makes me re-consider this even more.

What about the Wave ROM? 256MB seems awfully little in 2012, even though I know it's not strictly "about the number".

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

8 Feb 2012, 06:59
256 Mb might seem a small number, but it's not about size, it's about how you are able manage those samples, and Roland does that very well. Some older expansion boards (SRX) have only 64 Mb but they are done great, orchestral ones still hold their own against multi-giga-byte libraries, and it's not the only example. As for the sequencer, I don't see why it would be a downgrade for the Fantom G, it's just a little different. The classic options for midi editing present in all the Roland workstations until now are in the Fantom G, with a few exceptions (that can be worked arround very easily) due to the phrase based system. Wich, by the way, works great for me. On older sequencers, if you want to modify a part that appears many times in the song, you have to go to each of these loactions where the "phrase" appears and modify it or copy the modified part every time you need. Not with the G. A phrase modified in one place is automatically modified everywhere in the song. If you want to have an exception, you can just duplicate the phrase. For quickly arranging songs, the G's sequencer is excellent. But it's a type of sequencer that does require some keyboard skills. Think about one thing: if you would be playing in a band and some day you would go to a recording studio, what would happen there? The drummer is recorded via midi? Or the guitarist, the keyboardist, the bass player and so on? No! They will all be recorded as audio. And in this case, there will be no midi event editing and things like that. You would have to rely on the musician's ability to sync themselves, etc. And with the G you have all the tools for quantization, changing velocities, gate time, transpose, change channel etc. So there is no excuse in not dealing with song creation, really. And the OS is fine enough now, after the 1.31 and 1.50 updates, there could be a few more improvements of course, but there's nothing to keep you from working with it.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

8 Feb 2012, 08:41
The only thing I find disappointing about the G is the internal accoustic piano sounds.

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

8 Feb 2012, 09:30
Just to put in my twopeneth, from a live point of view the G is quite simply awesome. I love it. If you want to see what it is capable of you need to watch this video by Frost* Keysman Jem Godfrey.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kka2WgAmUsA its an entertaining watch!

Re: Could someone summarize what's "wrong" with the G?

9 Feb 2012, 10:11
jur451c wrote:
Just to put in my twopeneth, from a live point of view the G is quite simply awesome. I love it. If you want to see what it is capable of you need to watch this video by Frost* Keysman Jem Godfrey.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kka2WgAmUsA its an entertaining watch!
What is he actually doing here? You can't see the screen. Is that a "Live Set"? It looks really useful, but is something like that easy to do?

← Back to Fantom-G