Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Fantom X in Canada?

Fantom X in Canada?

22 Jun 2004, 17:40
Hey folks, I was wondering if there are any Canadians here who've managed to pick up an FX7 in Canada. My local dealer (a national chain) tells me there aren't any available in Canada yet, and they haven't a clue if or when there may be. Normally I'd be more patient, but they're sitting on a pretty sizeable deposit, not to mention a Korg Triton I cashed in for the SRX boards (also "on order"). Knowing how things are in Canada, the government is trying to figure out how the colour display might adversely affect the cable television market, or whether there is enough French Canadian content in the wave ROM. Feh!

Fantom X in Canada

27 Jun 2004, 07:32
Hi,

I have got a Fantom-X 7 from my local dealer in Halifax 3 weeks ago (4020$ included tax).

also, pleassssssse check out Triton Extreme before geting X. I'm not very pleased with this machine.

And if you ejoyed extreme, wait a little, I've heard there will be a falgship out, soon(Extreme is not their flagship).

Sam

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 11:26
''or whether there is enough French Canadian content in the wave ROM. Feh!''

Impressive.........

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 12:20
Hi
Yeah it seems Roland dealers here doesn't have a clue about what's going on with their synths.
All the models (6,7,8 and XR) are now available in Canada.
Don't pay more than 2750$ for a X6 and 1600 for a XR.
No longer part of the gang...

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 15:56
Flowing : "you're not pleased with your Fantom? Why?"

Well, for too many reasons!

1. Just a color LCD, some piano, guitar and bass sounds, and your ready to change the name from S to X ?! I was expecting to hear much more new sounds from X.
Watch their demos. They are introducing Skip back Sampling and Dynamic pads as new features! they have nothing new in X to introduce!

2. A pro keyboard should be made by pro people! More than 50 sounds on X have a really terrible noise! I think some one should teach Roland that after sampling you should use some noise reduction and mastering effects!!

3. You can't use this keyboard for gigs. there is a killer delay while switching between patches(even in performance mode!).

4. Dynamic pads and D-Beam should be used on a home keyboard, these are toys! No pro musician need this stuff.

A big change between S and X should be the Dynamic pads. They should be something MORE than a drum controller. This keyboard really needs a numeric pad.

Is this a pro keyboard?

I don't know so much about Extreme. Do you?

sorry for my english,
Sam

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 17:03
Sam - Many have complained about the things you mentioned, but what is the noise in many patches that you mentioned? What are some of the patches involved? Is the noise still present with one or all of the effects disabled?

Don't know much about the Triton Extreme either. Never liked Triton's two-oscillator-max program scheme and having to load multis/song mixes from disk (rather than in flash memory), so never seriously considered the Extreme.

Your English is great, by the way...

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 21:44
Thank you Flowing.

I have forgotten this: "The Standard by which all other Workstations are measured!!" has only 3 multieffect channels, and the least wave ROM memory between it competitors(if they are still competing with Roland!)

There is 2 type of noise in X! The first one seems to be a bug and it appears while switching between some patches with delay or distortion effects(Should I wait for an OS update?) The noise is like a radio noise while your are seeking for stations(but too loud!)

The second one, is just because of bad sampling and as you mentioned most of them won't be heard with effects turned off. But in that case you can't hear the patch itself! Because of their very low gain.

here is some*: (I have listed more, but I don't know why I clicked the "clear form" button!:(( )

1. PR-F:086 Darmstrat X (turn off the effects and listen again)

2. PR-F:106 Doubled Bass

3. PR-G:012 Dust Bass (listen to the release noise! :D)

4. PR-C:117 Good Old Hit (low range)

5. PR-G:068 Bon Voyage (low velocity)

6. PR-C:092 Dirty Voltage (low velocity)

7. PR-C:074 Sneaky Leady

8. PR-C:076 Clone Zone (low velocity)

9. PR-G:098 Dirty D/A (out standing!)

10. PR-E:046 DarknessSide (high velocity)

11. PR-H:034 Mod Scanner (great for noisicians!)

12. PR-D:039 Atmorave (low rang, high velocity)

13. PR-D:069 Tempest

14: PR-D:078 Sugar Synth (turn the effects off)

want more? buy one!

Sam

* I am in university residence and never had the chance to listen the patches from speakers. I am using headphones and in my opinion these patches are not playable. If you have a S or X please tell me how the noise is heard from speakers.

March 14th 1984
Music student at Dalhousie
Gears:
Fantom-X 7
M-Audio Firewire AudioPhile
Steinberg's full pack
Native Instruments' full pack
+20 gigabytes of other VSTi and samples

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 22:17
I am not defending Roland for the bugs, but don't distort the facts like this:

"1. Just a color LCD, some piano, guitar and bass sounds, and your ready to change the name from S to X ?! I was expecting to hear much more new sounds from X.
Watch their demos. They are introducing Skip back Sampling and Dynamic pads as new features! they have nothing new in X to introduce!
"

Actually, there is a lot of new stuff in Fantom-X.
- double polyphony
- More sound ROM
- double Sample RAM
- much more storage with CF card
- 2 new banks of patches
- Much better piano
- Digital IN
... and lots of user interface improvements.
And if you are comparing Fantom-X with Triton Extreme, you don't know what Fantom-X can do, and what Triton Extreme can't. Don't go there.

"4. Dynamic pads and D-Beam should be used on a home keyboard, these are toys! No pro musician need this stuff.
"
-hmm.... do you know how many 'pro' musicians use pads ? a lot! I agree that the pads need improvment, but they aren't useless. However, I could live without the D-Beam

"This keyboard really needs a numeric pad. " You can use the pads as numeric buttons for most of the functions.

And all of the patches you listed being noisy..... the noise is part of the sounds. And they are specifically 'gritty', look at the names... they are either distorted or durty.... the samples themselves are not 'noisy', the noise is added to design that sound.

look at the wave number being used, and start a new patch, and select that wave to 'listen' the raw sample itself.

For example: PR-C 92, dirty voltage. The wave is INT-A 455, unison saw A. the unison wave itself produces edgy sound, then the wave is processed by special synth structure (2).

If you listen to the sound just by changing the structure to 1. it will sound very close the the default program of Triton Classic, Noisy stabber. Actually, that one is even more noisy!

Also, when you play the sounds out of the range... too low or too high.. you hear digital artifacts on any synth...

If you don't like these sounds, and think they are noisy... get ready to be disappointed with other workstations too.. every workstation has sounds like these which have the noise as part of the wave.



--------------------
Remember that there are only 3 MFX + 1 Reverb + 1 Chorus in Fantom-S/X and you have to share them across 16 parts (patches) in a song.

live a musical life
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 22:37
..
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

27 Jun 2004, 23:23
Well, your right. There is some(not a lot) new features in X:

Double polyphony(the same az ES and Extreme)
Double Wave Rom (but ES has 175 and Extreme has 160mb)
Great piano (great for a keyboard)
Some new patches

and extended memory + SP/DIF In. (I really don't use the sampling function or the memory of Fantom. Why use that while I can easly use my PC?)

and what I really like in Fantom:

Great action (ES has a terrible and Extreme has a moderate keyboard action). Great OS and Interface.

-" You can use the pads as numeric buttons for most of the functions."

I think they should add much more functionality to the pads. I really feel the lack of that.

and about the noise:

"In my opinion" (that can be wrong), that hiss or fiss! sound is absolutely an unwanted and unprogrammed sound that even my previous and old G-600 didn't have.

These are Ac. sounds, aren't they?

1. PR-F:086 Darmstrat X (turn off the effects and listen again)

2. PR-F:108 Doubled Bass

and still the delay between switching patches and tight 3 multi effects is unacceptable for a pro keyboard.

Again, I agree with you and apologize that I didn't mention good features of X, but want to say that X is not really what Roland says. A flagship keyboard should be almost complete and bug free!

Sam

March 14th 1984
Music student at Dalhousie
Gears:
Fantom-X 7
M-Audio Firewire AudioPhile
Steinberg's full pack
Native Instruments' full pack
+20 gigabytes of other VSTi and samples

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

28 Jun 2004, 00:13
Hey sam_vafaei...

"1. PR-F:086 Darmstrat X" is a distorted guitar, it's not acoustic. The raw sample itself is of a guitar processed by distrotion effect.

2. PR-F 106.. doubled bass ... this one has noise of the real bass string rattle.

You won't find these details in the G-800.

The Fantom-X is a a far more varestrile sound pallette than the G-800. So, you do get plain raw acoustic samples as well as weired processed synth waves.



--------------------
Remember that there are only 3 MFX + 1 Reverb + 1 Chorus in Fantom-S/X and you have to share them across 16 parts (patches) in a song.

live a musical life
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

28 Jun 2004, 00:26
Have you listened the patches with headphones?

If yes, I think we have complete different ideas of what distortion is, what string rattle is, and what a hiss noise is.

by the way, G-600 not G-800 ;)

March 14th 1984
Music student at Dalhousie
Gears:
Fantom-X 7
M-Audio Firewire AudioPhile
Steinberg's full pack
Native Instruments' full pack
+20 gigabytes of other VSTi and samples

French Canadian content

28 Jun 2004, 18:52
...no offense intended to my Francophone compatriots!

Re: Fantom X in Canada?

28 Jun 2004, 19:04
I'm looking forward to listening to those patches to find out how I hear them (the Sam way or the Shakil way)...

I'm used to noise problems, as I dealt with my XP-80's infamous "decay noise" problem for years - but I never noticed it in a mix, so it wasn't really a problem for me. My Motif ES's drum samples are fraught with "noise" as the amplitude fades out, but they still sound superb in a song.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X