Fantom-G

Fantom G production terminated?!

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 09:10
Ok here's the story......

Roland lost a lot of money on the Fantom G as noted in their stock report because basically the FG was a rushed out under developed version of the Fantom X. Not too many previous buyers and new buyers responded to the FG. Could have been lack of features and lack of NEW innovations like with other synth manufactures. Take Yamaha for example (Flash Mem) sparked great success in sales. Take FG nothing new and subtracted features? Nothing to get excited about.

Roland is back at the drawing board designing a new flagship, but it may take another 1-2 years for release. It's not that the synth market is shrinking, it's that the synth manufactures are trying to stretch their technology as long as it can go until they get a buyer decision that it's no longer selling. Roland now has their buyer statement and we will see something new in the future. Yamaha hasn't received a buyer statement yet from their motif lines and continue to add new, innovative and exciting features to the flagship keyboard.

It was a bad design decision from Roland on the FG, and they won't make that exact same design investment again when they decide to come out with a new hot seller. Hardware synths will always sell well, regardless of the soft synth that hits the market because people love, want, and still use innovative hardware synth overall.

Roland will be back with something wonderful and new, they better, they have no other choice. Either sink or swim, the music instrument game is not for wimps and crybabies.

Study the play by play text book of the other synth manufactures and learn how to score a damn touchdown sissies!

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 10:16
@KDAY-The way your speaking about this, you must work for roland or just making up a long story.
Please enlighten us clan members and tell us how you know all this info for a fact..
Thank You

Capital Skill
my way of feeling what music is......THOUGH MIND, BODY AND SPIRIT,FEELING MY WAY ACROSS THE PLAIN OF CREATION TILL I FEEL TOTAL Consciousness AND BECOME ONE WITH WHAT IM CREATING.(IF I DECIDE TO STOP AND MOVE ON TO THE NEXT.SO BE IT)

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 10:43
Well, I suppose all things come to an end... if this is in fact true. I can't say I'd be surprised although I think that a few things can/could still be improved on the G.
Anyother way I'm still happy. I still love the G and if by any change it becomes the "last" Fantom workstation from Roland I'm happy for keeping it. It will become a Roland "classic" in a few years ;-).

All the other talking is pure speculation. Korg and Yamaha also have reviewed their sales down - basically like anyother company with all this crisis going on. Still, there seems to be a lot of users that forget Roland is not just a hardware synthesiser manufacter and is increasing their presence in other areas, namely professional audio and video. And we are yet to see what Cakewalk will be.

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 10:56
I'm sorry to say this to the people who wish to see the Fantom-G continued to be supported ... but this could be good news ... I hope it means Roland is going ahead with another model instead of trying to sell the Fan-G as long it can ... (Although Fan-G sales could already be in the basement ... )

This is my advice to Roland as a Fantom-X owner who certainly had the means but not the desire to "upgrade" to Fantom-G ...

1) DROP ARX ... few champion it, and it seems almost worthless from an outsider's perspective as to what's needed/necessary in a workstation ... must have been quite expensive to develop ...

2) DROP the big screen ... waste of money, never seemed useful from my perspective ... go back to Fan-X size with higher resolution ... If people want to sequence using a giant screen, use a computer ...

3) INCLUDE Total computer integration ... Needs to function seamlessly with most DAWs (Logic, ProTools, Cubase as well as Sonar) ... After the soundset, that's probably the key right there ...

3) KEEP the LIVE SWITCHING ... (and a true v2.0 implementation at that) ... One of the few things I liked about Fan-G ... Although I could handle less live switching parts if that could reduce cost ... Does every instrument part need the ability to overlap between performances ... ??? Not really imo ...

4) INCLUDE flexible insert effects a la Fantom X ... How many? As many as possible ... (A bad misstep with Fan-G)

5) RETHINK the drum pads ... For me, the pads were a big reason why I was inititally attracted to Fan-X ... They certainly took a step back with Fan-G compared with X (smaller, even less responsive velocity-wise ... ) Roland either needs to really go to the next level or drop them ... If they stay, make them super-useful and flexible (for instance, any function can be mapped to any pad SIMULTANEOUSLY ... I was terribly disappointed when learned you have to switch modes to access different functions of Fan-G via pads...) and make them actualy playable with velocity ... For a comparison, see NI's Maschine controller or Korg's PadControl ...Different color leds for different functions would also be hot ...

However, with a myriad of better-responding drum controllers on the market and in users' possession, it might make more sense to offer integration with those instead ... Whatever, you do, Roland, don't just skip the pads and call it a day ... That would be another mistake ...

5) KEEP the sliders ... but add more knobs and make them sturdier ... and maybe a little smaller ... (I always liked the small knobs on the original V-Synth)

6) DROP "Best of SRX" and just go for "ALL of SRX" ... This should go hand-in-hand with a new memory scheme ... I don't trust Roland anymore to sift through the SRX ... So just include them all -- yeah, that IS a lot ... and that's the point (lead the category on ROM size for once, Roland; why do they always seem to lag in this here?) --- and include an excellent internal/external librarian feature to organize them in multiple ways ... OK ... maybe not 100 percent of the SRX ... but somewhere between 75-90 percent ... (there is some overlap, but honestly, I'd rather deal with that myself ... ) I can't state this enough ... The Fantom-G's paltry/uninspired soundset was the single biggest reason I never "upgraded" ... A joke really when compared with fully-expanded Fantom X ...

6) DON'T release this workstation until it's ready ... I will not pay Roland to be a beta-tester as I wait and pray for key functions (like an arpeggiator that's still lacking) to be added ... And I don't mind paying current prices ... But it's got to be something I really want ... Something the Fantom-G really never inspired in me ...

7) Sequencer ... This is probably the trickiest area ... How far do you go here ... ??? How much development ... ??? Should the next Fantom be a "studio in the box" like Fan-X and even moreso G ... Or should these functions be relegated to the computer with the capacity to play back backing tracks, etc. live ... When playing live, I don't really need all that functionality in the workstation itself ... Some people don't always want to turn on a computer -- including myself -- when making music ... But when you really want to do it right, I don't see any better alternatives than a DAW like Logic ... Embrace the future ... Or if the G's sequencer is going to be carried over, at least make sure basic DAW functions like panning and some automation of key features are available on audio tracks ... (Another G disapointment ... )

8) Make it black ... It's time ...

9) INCLUDE a really terrific piano ... None of these "does this sound good?" pianos from Fantom-G ...

10) Keep the Fantom name and the spirit ... i.e. Awesome selection of sounds, highest degee of sequencing power (either on-board or through computer integration), high quality and formidable-looking physical appearance, unique features and performance controllers that set Fantom apart ... (Drop D-Beam If you can't find a place to put it where it can actually be used with a keyboard on top ... If you can, make it dual D-Beams like on V-Synth ... Simply awesome ... )

Good luck, Roland ... You still have a chance to get my next workstation dollars ...
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 11:44
OK...let's say this is true and they are finished producing the Fantom G....

how long do you guys think it could be before we see the next generation (or even get ANY info on it...?)
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 12:38
never roland stuff anymore. Yes, mainly due to non communication ! Roland, you certainly don't rock!

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 12:59
"1) DROP ARX ... few champion it, and it seems almost worthless from an outsider's perspective as to what's needed/necessary in a workstation ... must have been quite expensive to develop ...

2) DROP the big screen ... waste of money, never seemed useful from my perspective ... go back to Fan-X size with higher resolution ... If people want to sequence using a giant screen, use a computer ... "


No and no. Two of the reasons that drew me to the G. Especially the screen. The large screen makes it easier to work, especially for extended sessions. If they are going to drop the screen, they better have external monitor support with the ability to adjust resolution.

ARX, I own two of them. If they drop support for ARX(or whatever they call the next generation of it) they better include on board modeling support for each patch or for one patch out of every category. It would allow users to make the best out of the patches they have and eliminate the need for external cards.

I agree about computer integration, they need full support for Pro Tools and every popular DAW software. I guess that, in itself, would eliminate the need for a large screen. As long as it is complete integration and what you record also shows up in Pro Tools as you record it.

Insert effect is a must have. Being able to use external effects would allow for more flexibility within the unit. Then again, with full DAW support, you probably wouldnt need it... as you would have access to all the effects you would ever need with DAW plugins.

Drum pads are about useless on the G. So much so, that I bought a Maschine to take up the slack. I also have an 18 piece ROland TD-20 set, which is the best for recording. The Maschine I use for mobile recording, when I dont have access to the TD-20.

The pianos are also a must have. They need to dedicate 1GB alone for a sample of the Steinway D. The piano is the sound that has to be perfect in any synth. The G has some acceptable sounds, but they somehow never come out sounding right. After playing some real pianos and some dedicated digital pianos I realized just how bad the G's were. I dont believe in tweaking sounds, they should be pitch perfect out of the box. I have messed around with it and have got some decent results, but the pianos still end up sounding thin and almost casio-like. It is such a problem, that I have gone to a software solution that has a GB of samples and sounds phenomenal and it was only $70.

I am not sure that they should keep the Fantom name. While the X was a flagship for the brand, the G kind of ran it through the mud... with support that rivaled that of the Alesis Fusion. The Fusion had a huge, bright future. It has 8 inputs that can record simultaneously! Great sounding pianos, great arps and arp creation... It is loaded and could still be huge today....

What went wrong? No support out of the gate. It was rushed to market and some of its flagship features werent enabled out of the box and never were via software updates. There was an external hard drive port for SATA hard drives, that still sits unused on the unit. It has a built in 40GB hard drive that is great and a built in Compact Flash port that is functional, also. Great ideas not fully realized. Which is the same way I feel about the G.

I'll have to check the Fusion community again, as they were headstrong on getting the firmware listed as open source, so features could be enabled by the community. I am not sure if Alesis did that or not. If they did... and these features were enabled... It may be more powerful than the G. I never, for some reason, thoguht about sampling some of the Pianos from the Fusion over to the G. If someone wants to give me a heads up on how to do so, as I never sampled anything before, I would be more than happy to do it for the community here.

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 13:19
I believe there are posts a while back that whenever anyone asked if more ARX cards would come out, the response was - of course! They always come out with a full line of cards- like the jV or SRX.

Now it sounds like the naysayers were correct.

If this is true - I would not buy anothe Roland product - unless I buy it USED.

And I agree with the post above - their communcation is horrendous.

Meanwhile, Roland bought Cakewalk. I visit their forum often. The Cakewalk folks are always posting on the website, helping to answer questions and taling about new products. A totally different world.

I wonder how long before this thread is locked up because the free speech is not going Roland;s way?

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 13:40
Art said it best in his early comment.. Even today, the hardware of the Fantom G is competitive.. and i completely agree.

Personally I think it would be totally foolish for Roland simply to think that the answer is to release another workstation, when for 10% of that engineering money they could transform the views of the customer base and breathe new life into FG sales.

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 14:14
"Art said it best in his early comment."

I thought Ronan Keating said it best when he said nothing at all... ;)

Anyway, let's leave it in the capable hands of Frank.....
and now.... the end is
Whine whine everywhere and not a drop to drink ;)

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 14:38
"Personally I think it would be totally foolish for Roland simply to think that the answer is to release another workstation, when for 10% of that engineering money they could transform the views of the customer base and breathe new life into FG sales. "

I totally agree... but you know how these corporations work. They have this huge overflow of education, but no street smarts. They dont get that you can take what you have and make the best out of it, especially when you have the option of updating firmware and software. IT is easy enough for them to make ARX cards to tie together any loose ends as far as patches are concerned(Piano) and software could make the sequencer the best out there, by taking suggestions from the community and implementing them.

It is just a shame that Roland and most other synth companies are run by suits and not musicians, because if they were... we would have the best synths that would never need to be replaced by a newer model... just updated via software.

The bitch of it, also... is that, I and others, would probably be willing to pay for the software upgrades... if they added the functions we were looking for. Charge users $100/year and give them 12 months of updates and new patches, etc... That way, you are still making money and pleasing your community... by continuing support for that instrument they just paid thousands of dollars for.

It is ignorant as hell to leave your community in the dark, not knowing where they stand. It is a great way to destroy future customer relations with those that supported you in the first place. It reminds me of the Fusion all over again.

I just dont want to experience the Fusion disappointment all over again. You know, a bunch of unrealized potential that goes to the wayside.

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 15:31
I absolutely agree with any single argument/advice posted by Diametro with one small exception.
Roland will surely not get my next workstation money.
They failed with the FG on so many aspects, I can't imagine that they could change it to a so much better workstation next time.

I don't need much better sounds. I would like to, but I can make my own.
I don't need ARX. I have one. It's expensive as hell and it offers a fraction of what a software based vst is able to do. Besides that, if someone doesn't like the sound of the FG, the ARX certainly wouldn't help him out.

If Roland isn't eager to remove the design flaws on the software side, I certainly wont spend my money on another hardware from them with more effects and gigabytes. I will not be the idiot to sell the FG, loose money, just to get another model when they get it right.

As a live player, I have spend hours and weeks to program my own multisamples and samples for my live shows. Since there is no a file format, all my hard work is most probably useless data junk for a potential new model. If I have to buy a new workstation, I'll rather spend it on a company which cares about users and at least knows how to make the most basic things right. Roland, as I see it, doesn't belong to them.

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 19:14
After all we don't know anything for sure yet. I was just thinking... the Fantom G is more than just a new workstation with effects for each part and a new sequencer. It introduced a new concept: SuperNatural technology. This is what FG is about after all (besides those mentioned above). I can hardly believe that everything ends with Drums, EP and Brass. Really, it can't be that way.
P.S. I read a post here some time ago (but I can't remember in wich topic) - some guy claiming that he spoked to someone at Roland Brazil or something, and that person from Roland was saying that in the future a massive library of ARX will be released making those who sold their Fantoms to regret that. Now someone else says the other way. Rumors...rumors...rumors...

Re: Fantom G production terminated?!

13 Nov 2010, 19:41
I hardly believe that Roland is working on a massive ARX release. If that was the case, they would have talked it up to the community to build hype and Dan wouldnt have disappeared. I think they tired of throwing money at updates, which werent bringing in any new sales. What is the point, business-wise, of spending money on a released product that isnt still selling? Wouldnt you want to throw money into research of something that will? Its ass backwards, because you would figure it would be cheaper to update the existing hardware with new firmware and software and rebuild the hype... but it obviously didnt work from the last few updates, so I am guessing they gave up.

Which doesnt bode well for us, because we are left with a great keyboard that is steps away from perfection. Once again, it is the same thing that happened to the Alesis Fusion. Just a couple of firmware updates that would have enabled the features that would have put it over the top, as far as workstations were concerned... and I never would have bought the Fantom G.

Now, I bought the Fantom G... and the same thing is happening with it. I dont get the mentality of these manufacturers... but maybe there is more to it, behind the scenes, than we know.

I am close to buying a Motif XF... at least I know support is going to be there for it and the Piano sounds are unbelievable. There are features from the Fantom G I would love to see on the XF and features from the XF I'd like to see on the G... You would think there would be one keyboard manufacturer who would combine all of the best of the keyboards out there and have one unit that does everything. :) Of course, there is the Neko... but I really dont feel like spending $7,000 on a workstation. :)

← Back to Fantom-G