Other Roland gear

Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

29 Nov 2007, 21:39
I put in an order to American Musical for a set of these. They look solid, and they seem like they'll be powerful enough for me. But if anyone has experience with this particular model, let me know. I can return them if they absolutely suck, or I can cancel the order now before they ship if someone says "they suck."

- S
Yes we did.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

2 Dec 2007, 01:25
Well, they'll be here on Monday. I'll report on my findings.

- S
Yes we did.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

4 Dec 2007, 15:12
I got them today. They are very nice, and they sound like what I expected them to sound like. The midrange is a bit pronounced (maybe around the lower-mids -- say, in the 400 to 800 Hz range) but that is probably owed to my table. I plan to get the MoPads when I can.

The other thing is that they do have a S/PDIF connector, and I plan to use this with the M-Audio FireWire Solo, not to mention the Receptor when I get it. It will be good to hear what the Cubase stuff sounds through the digital out, because I know that this will improve the sound as well.

You may treat this as a positive review of these speakers -- so far, anyway.

- S
Yes we did.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

6 Dec 2007, 23:31
I bought these yesterday. They sound okay, for the price (120 Euros).
I choose them mainly because I can hook up two soundsources
at the same time.
I used to have a similar setup by Roland, it was a 2.1 system. The satelites
were smaller but the subwoofer made a big difference.
But the 2.1 system was more expensive.

So, for the money they are good value. As a temporary solution, or for
hooking up your fantom they are great. Great multi-media monitors.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

8 Dec 2007, 22:07
Agreed. I think that they sound pretty stellar, actually, for the money. I have them hooked up via digital coax to my FW Solo.

Just remember to leave the bass enhancer "off," or else you'll get this wacky compression/noise-floor-gain thing. I also put them on MoPads, which helps the sound a lot.

- S
Yes we did.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

30 Dec 2008, 17:08
Sammy just wondering if you are still happy with these monitors. I've just purchased a pair of these and they will be here in 3 weeks.

I use headphones at the moment and just wanted a pair of monitors I could afford to listen without headphones.

I realise these will not be completely accurate but they were in my price range.

Let me know how you positioned them.

thanks

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

12 Feb 2009, 00:02
Received mine about 2 weeks ago. They sound great for the price. Very similiar to my headphone monitoring.

Very pleased with these speakers!!

When I first got them they were distorting and I realised it was their placement on furniture. So I put them up on books and all was well.

I just cut some thin styrofoam and wrapped the outside in black duct tape and now these speakers sit on these acoustically treated(lol) pads.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

3 Apr 2009, 13:31
Hey man -- I'm really sorry that it took me so long to get back to you on this. First, yes -- I LOVE my MA-15D speakers. They have gotten better-sounding over time.

There are two things that I would like to add about these:

1. I have put them on speaker stands. Your solution may work for you, and if so, then that is fine. I hate kludgey things like that. (Refer to my above comments in this thread for more information about my stands and their positioning.)

2. I contacted Roland Tech Support. They were EXTREMELY helpful. They told me within 15 seconds of me asking my question that the cable connecting the two speakers is a SPEAKER CABLE (with RCA ends). That is a big deal if you plan to get a new connecting cable, which I want to do.

In case anyone here isn't aware of this, YOU MUST ALWAYS use speaker cables when specified! Some consumer-level speakers use regular 1/4" or RCA audio cables. The impedance on those things is inappropriate for amplified signals, and if you use such cables where speaker cables are called for, you can short out the amp, and end up with a nice "pop" sound and a wonderful acrid smell. Not to mention the possibiilty of a plume of smoke, and quite possibly a small fire. (I damaged a Fender Passport speaker system about ten years ago by using an audio cable to connect one speaker to the powered mixer unit. I was lucky; I could have started a fire. And although that didn't happen, I still had to send the unit in for repair. You live, you learn.)

Here is how to determine whether a cable is a speaker cable or an audio cable. In the case of 1/4", the audio cable typically has a red or blue rubber sleeve sticking out from the metal; RCA audio cables are red or white; yellow signifies that it is a video cable. If any cable is all-black, then it is almost definitely a speaker cable.

That's it! Enjoy your speakers. I love mine. I wouldn't trade these for Adam or M-Audio speakers. They sound great and the S/PDIF works very well.
Yes we did.

Sorry about the double-post...

9 Apr 2009, 20:46
...but I wanted to get a picture of my setup here. I couldn't do that with the Edit button.

Image

Enjoy.

- Sammy
Yes we did.

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

9 Apr 2009, 23:56
Thanks Sammy for all the detailed info. Your speaker stands look good. They look like they have some type of acoustic isolation block on top of the stands.

I'm happy with these speakers and for a small room I think they are adequate. I don't think they have quite the detail of a higher priced monitor but I really couldn't afford a higher end pair.

Hey I just noticed that mine are wood grained and yours are black.

What type of keyboard do you have?

Re: Edirol MA15D BK monitors -- anyone used these?

10 Apr 2009, 18:44
Yeah -- the "acoustic isolation blocks" are the MoPads of which I wrote. The keyboard is a Novation ReMOTE SL 61.

The flat-screen computer monitor is an HP w2007. The mouse is a Logitech SetPoint. The lamp is halogen, and I don't know what brand it is.

Finally, the table comprises three parts: The legs are really a Quiklok 500 WS workstation keyboard stand. The large wooden surface was designed by me, and built by me and my dad. The mouse is resting on a shelf that my dad whipped up about three weeks ago and bolted on to the table front.

The table was fun to create. I had the idea of just taking some wood and throwing it on top of the QL stand. My dad came up with the idea of building it to be light weight; he suggested using 1/8" plywood with 2x4 pieces around its perimeter. If you look at its underside, you'll see that there are some reinforcing 2x4 pieces, which also brace the top against the legs underneath.

It is solid, light-weight, and I can put almost anything on it without worrying about it breaking. And having a nice, large flat surface is useful. The computer keyboard will go, most likely, in front of the MIDI keyboard. And if I pick up another control surface, I'll have a place to put it.

I may or may not put my new computer (when I get it) on the table. I had the Spectral on the back for a bit, right behind the screen. The new machine I'm getting is a mid-tower, and it might just go on the floor. But I'm more interested in the long-term than the "right now" needs that I have. This table has proven itself in many ways. I hate not having a place to put things, so I'm glad that we created it.

- Sammy
Yes we did.

← Back to Other Roland gear