Fantom-S and Fantom-X

About the aftertouch problem

Re: About the aftertouch problem

3 Apr 2009, 03:54
The aftertouch of the X8 (dunno bout the X6 & X7) is quite brutal.
Basically you need to snap of your finger and press it as hard as you can on the keys for it to work (even then it isn't sure it WILL work).
'daddio' found a nice solution for this problem but it is a user modification of the hardware and Roland doesn't support it.
The "aftertouch problem" is a hardware problem. Apparently, Roland had a mistake with the X causing the entire assembly line to have that problem.

and I'm not sure that the Xa has aftertouch but you better check your manual for it.
Carpe Diem,
Freifeld Royi

Re: About the aftertouch problem

3 Apr 2009, 08:50
The Xa has no aftertouch
F X6 SRX07, SRX98, SRX08 Guitarist\songwriter Trying to get to grips with Synths
Well I got a call from the guy in the store.
I think it is going to take some time there.
Apparently he can't "produce" aftertouch at all. He even asked me if I deactivated it in some way O_O !!!
I guess it could explain the 2 threads i posted way back:
http://forums.rolandclan.info/index.php?action=show_thread&thread=23272&fid=8&page=1
http://forums.rolandclan.info/index.php?action=show_thread&thread=20731&fid=1&page=1

Stay tuned, =)
Freifeld Royi
Carpe Diem,
Freifeld Royi
It's Alive!!
well... I talked with the engineer in the store. He said the aftertouch sensor strip needed to be replaced. (and apparently that was the "chip" or "wiring" the dealer was talking about)

For the first time since I bought the Fx I can use the aftertouch.. WOOHOO!! =).
Carpe Diem,
Freifeld Royi

Re: About the aftertouch problem

7 Apr 2009, 06:54
Cool SonicMan,

Let us know of the feel is much better.

I think I'm going to do the strip modification that was posted here when my current run of gigs has ended.

Enjoy!
Andy
Andy

Aftertouch Pressure Strip

7 Apr 2009, 11:12
Great, SonicMan!

I'm interested to know if the feel is more linear, and how the System Parameter number for Aftertouch Sens (0 - 100) affects the response.

Andy, even after the mod I did to increase the key pressure on the strip, the response range of aftertouch is still fairly narrow i.e., the progression from minimum effect to maximum effect occurs over a small range of pressure change.

I'm going to e-mail RolandUS support and see if they will send me a new aftertouch sensor strip.

Re: About the aftertouch problem

8 Apr 2009, 01:28
I can't really compare it to anything because until now I couldn't use the aftertouch at all (that's why I didn't "understand" art's and other user's posts for my questions about the AT and matrix control).
If I compare it to my friend's k2600X... well it is harder but since it has that "problem", the response is controllable (with basic factory patches).
Let me try it for a few weeks. experimenting with it, changing the range and I'll post the results in a few days.
Carpe Diem,
Freifeld Royi

Re: About the aftertouch problem

8 Apr 2009, 08:15
daddio57,

Does that mean the only real effect of your modification is that the key press is softer or more spongy than before?

I'd still be interested if so, as the current keypress is way too hard for me.

Is the part you mean #02455034: SK-976 AFTERTOUCH referred to in the Service manual? Let us know how you get on as well.

Cheers
Andy
Andy

Aftertouch Mods

8 Apr 2009, 13:47
Hi, Andy

AndyKeys Does that mean the only real effect of your modification is that the key press is softer or more spongy than before?

No, the effect of the modification was substantial - I can produce the aftertouch effect with substantially less pressure than before the mod (i.e., without breaking my fingers!). The feel of the key press is unaffected, but the aftertouch effect kicks in a lot sooner than it did previously. All my mod does is add a layer of build-up material (felt) on top of the pressure strip so that bottom of the key contacts the felt at the bottom of the key's travel and applies pressure through the felt to the strip.

AndyKeys Is the part you mean #02455034: SK-976 AFTERTOUCH referred to in the Service manual?

I have a partial pdf service manual (Mar 2004), and it lists the PA-5 Keyboard parts list. The aftertouch strip is part 10, part #03128178, part name PA-5 AFTERTOUCH 88P. Which service manual do you have, Andy?

My concern is that if Roland used the wrong model of strip in the first place, and they are now offering a replacement part or parts that fix the problem, I may be tempted to try their solution first. I am guessing that their solution is likely a more sensitive pressure strip combined with a thicker layer of build-up material (felt) on top of it....

Oh, BTW, I received an e-mail from Roland support saying that I had to call their non-800 (!) number for any parts queries. I suspect that they'll be reluctant to hand out any parts, and want us to take the X to a dealer (I bought mine online from Jim Laabs, so that is out of the question).

SonicMan, did you have to pay out-of-pocket for your repairs, or was your X still under warranty?

Thanks!
Gary.

Re: About the aftertouch problem

8 Apr 2009, 16:32
I think that it is out of warranty. And it cost me nothing.
You think that Roland are trying to cover up for their mistakes or something like that?
Carpe Diem,
Freifeld Royi

Re: About the aftertouch problem

9 Apr 2009, 05:38
daddio,

Just a thought. Is your Fantom an X-8? Mine's an X-7 and my Service Manual is also dated March 2004 and the keyboard assembly is called "SK-976-C" not PA-5. It's the reference to 88 that made me wonder.

Andy
Andy
Andy,

Yes, I have an X8. But the aftertouch 'was' brutal until I did my mod. I guess that the '76' in SK-976-C refers to 76 keys on the X7, eh?

Re: About the aftertouch problem

11 Apr 2009, 11:27
Daddio,

Sounds reasonable. I think the spongy strip replacement mod is the way to go for me. I'll let you know how it works out when I've done it, but it might not be anytime soon as I need to wait for a decent amount of time between gigs before I take the whole thing apart :o)

Cheers
Andy
Andy

Re: About the aftertouch problem

11 Oct 2010, 05:27
I did the spongy /velcro srtip thing on my x6.Did have NO affect. Called Roland (uk) and asked IF buying a new stensor strip would do the trick.They didn't know.They said that they sold hundreds of them and had no problems or complaints (yeah right) BUT if I had bought it from them,I could send it to them,they will fix it if it's under warranty.So it CAN BE FIXED THEN THIS NON-EXISTING PROBLEM !!!Curious.I think its a policy thing at our dear music making friends not to admit there is a problem.I'm going to buy a new strip (for my brand new x6) and fit it.Thats the way to go I think.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X