Fantom-G

The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 03:51
shakil:

Shame on you for such a low blow..

Dan:
Telling people what they can and cannot use in discussion only serves to raise the bear we dont need someone waving the corporate flag. (all due respect)

Art:
Our frustrations come from our passion and love of the G
The more we like it more passionate we get :)
We are essential defending it in our own way..

Peace:



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 04:12
Hi Dan,

I see two big issues with Roland Japan responsibilities

1. Support data for the Fantom G are scattered all over the net. Instead Roland Japan with the “Fantom G Experience” should be the central source for all available material. If they don’t provide a user forum (which Artemiy does very well, despite things where we disagree), it should nevertheless contain all available other stuff:

- all tutorial videos, in a well ordered way (general introduction, single topics), perhaps including user tutorials, if those users agree, or at least links to all of them. And it should certainly include yours and not just stuff from Gem Godfrey etc. from very early Fantom G times.
- all workshop pdfs
- a well organized FAQ list, where constantly recurring questions from the clan and their answers are provided
- a workaround list addressing some of the present problems and the way power users try to deal with them until the problems are fixed
- a patch base containing Roland patch updates like the German Fantom G Reloaded or complete packages like your great Fantom G Connects projects. It would be nice if this central patch base also contained user patches.
- a regularly updated news page.

2. The OS updates are “too little and too late” from my view. The Fantom G should at least since Frankfurt have an updated editor/librarian (I can’t even address my very expensive ARX-03 with the librarian!, not speaking of editing in software) and at least a small OS update fixing basic things like not being able to define external key ranges with the G etc.. The sequencer limitations causing trouble in practical use are also well known since many months and not addressed. Yes, I have to admit that I am extremely dissatisfied with Roland Japan’s update politics.

So I see you personally and Roland US, just like my Roland Germany, are doing a great job (I never was dissatisfied with my local German support: it always was good and helped me even with very competent emails in earlier Fantom X and Juno G support cases!), while I don’t see that either of you could address the issues above in any way.

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 05:00
If Roland's working on a 2.0 version, it will obviously take them longer to come up with than it took for a minor release such as 1.20.

Dan, I think we all understand your company policy but perhaps to calm things down around here you may ask permission to your hierarchy/Japan/God to just drop a single line that states if engineers are indeed working on an OS update... or not.

Thanks!

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 05:04
vox:
Dan, I think we all understand your company policy but perhaps to calm things down around here you may ask permission to your hierarchy/Japan/God to just drop a single line that states if engineers are indeed working on an OS update... or not.
LOL LOL LOL
Man, are you serious? Roland to reveal anything from their future plans??? Come on, they've keeping them as if they were the planet's top secret...

or maybe there are not really any plans...

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 05:16
Veecee I have found you to be prejudice too in your action on the forum.. (i wont go into detail but it reveled itself early today too)
Quinnx
Sorry, I know this is off-topic but I would like to make it clear: If you're refering to the fact that I moved your thread from the Fantom-G to the Free Zone forum, I'm sorry I have nothing to say about it. The thread itself says it all. If your refering to anyother thing, please, feel free to talk about it here (in the Free Zone please) or email me. Thank you.

There ARE Issues....

2 Apr 2009, 05:53
Hello Art,

I disagree with You in one point. There exist big Issues for me!
I don´t demand new features like new FX or new functions. I just want the existing functions work properly.

The 3 ISSUES from my Point of view:

The Sounds are not fully playable after selecting them! Never had that before in a workstation!

1) Controllers (D-Beam and Switch) doesn´t work in Live mode, until you activate manually the right part. To use my ARX03 in Live-Mode i have to push 8 times the "Down-Button" to use it with controllers.

2) Tempo can´t be stored in Live-Set. So delays and organics sound are not in the right tempo. I have to adjust it manually each time when playing live. It´s not acceptable to use Songmode for that because you can´t copy the sounds from Livemode and when live-mode is not good for liveplaying what else is it good for.

3) No Load and Save-Function for own things like "Multisamples" and "Live-Sets". So you cant´ really load Multisamples from other Persons into Your project.

I can live with a lot of Workarounds, when doing them at home. But Seemless switching is a JOKE, when you have to adjust a lot of things after selecting a sound. When doing this live this is frustrating, because I always have to look on my Setlist and read things like "Activate Part 4 and adjust Tempo to 135BPM"

I am talking about this ISSUES more than a Year and nothings happen!

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 06:10
Same for me, all fismoll says apply to me, more I cant organize my sounds without multisample based patch copy, the librarian its incomplete and buggy. Filesystem from Fantom its a bad joke, manage songs thru projects its difficult, sample management incomplete, slow load. Really a half baked engine...

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 06:13
How come every single user finds at least 2-3 SERIOUS niggles to be annoyed about, and at the same time, everything is PERFECT for some people.
So perfect that they need they have to defend Roland people for everything they do and don't. And insult Clan users for that.

A coincidence???? I don't believe in coincidences....

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 07:13
In fact the issue list is considerably longer, as Roland could easily see from just reading the issue and wishlist threads in this forum.

And the issues fismoll referred to are no minimal asides, but a constant pain for live play, just like not being able to adjust external keyzones from the G.

I can't use ARX-03 live, because the controller settings I programmed in the expansion(Control/ControlAssign1) and in my LiveSet Control settings (for S1/S2 etc.) are simply not working when choosing the LiveSet! I have to go into the Expansion, F7 Control, Control Assign1 and USE the controller settings once before they are activated. If this issue isn't a FAT BUG, I don't know what to call a bug. And for home sequencing I can't reach ARX-03 in the librarian and the editor for organizing sounds (which is urgent because most presets they provided are lame). ARX-03 has been released at NAMM09, and I paid 400€ for it, and even these urgent issues are neither adressed not does any Roland Japan representative find it worth mentioning that they should be and are adressed.

Roland Japan is one ongoing support desaster. And that drives me nuts, because I prefer their basic G concept over that of any other workstation.

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 07:39
"Roland Japan is one ongoing support desaster. And that drives me nuts, because I prefer their basic G concept over that of any other workstation."

Very well said, I totally agree. It's sad to have such potentials and you just don't fix some main problems to make it one of the best workstations ever.

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 07:55
>How come every single user finds at least 2-3 SERIOUS niggles to be annoyed about, and at the same time, everything is PERFECT for some people.

There's always those people who do that. Even when you look at dictatorships, there's always people who blindly trust and lean towards the state and government even if they would be doing atrocities before their eyes.

It is indeed a very strange and fascinating psycological phenomena. It is called denial. Denial is a defense mechanism postulated by Sigmund Freud, in which a person is faced with a fact that is too uncomfortable to accept and rejects it instead, insisting that it is not true despite what may be overwhelming evidence. The subject may deny the reality of the unpleasant fact altogether (simple denial), admit the fact but deny its seriousness (minimisation) or admit both the fact and seriousness but deny responsibility (transference).

I think it is almost funny to see it happen here at a daily basis, and that the people in denial even have created their own vocabulary and phrases, or even mantra they keep repeating. It is a well known fact that the general existence of denial is fairly easy to verify, even for non-specialists.


So everybody in denial, please. It is totally ok to feel uncomfortable. It is ok to be an unhappy customer. You may express your true feelings. Roland will not sue you for being unhappy with their customer support.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 08:32
jessej
I didn't know you were into such a philosophical..... rubbish ;-)

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 08:34
We will organize a protest in front of Roland Japan, with the Press and asks for our customer rights... Or our money back...

We will set fire on some "broken fantoms" (not in mine of course), and shout order words...

Man, Roland knows how make their customers nervous...

Joke aside, some more youtube videos alerting people its a good protest.

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 08:38
hey Lisandro its your move! CHECKMAETE IN 1034 MOVES ;-)

but hey Jess: its all the samo samo....
People in power feel the need to exercise it even when there is no need..

But decline to do so when it is required..



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: The Roland Japan G NOTHING experience

2 Apr 2009, 09:35
no one is in denial and no one thinks the G is perfect... that is oversimplifying the argument...

1. The G, right this second, is a great board... albeit incomplete

2. Roland's lack of support is atrocious and appalling and will lead to a loss of valued customers (including myself) in the future.

no denial here, just taking it as is as my complaints have already been documented through the OFFICIAL channels. we will look at a situation differently so calling the admins here fanboys or making up conspiracy theorys is plain childish...

← Back to Fantom-G