Fantom-G

Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

8 Feb 2009, 18:26
When I bought the G, I had the X and the G side by side for several weeks and used both side by side in many practical situations: comparing their sound in mixes, rehearsals etc.

The X had neither the brillance (richness of overtones or whatever it may have been) and punch nor dynamic range of the G. this was especially obvious in loud live play with a band, and the subjective impresseion of literally EVERYONE hearing both side by side, whomever I could ask.

But since even extensive side by side testing was subjective and only "earsay", perhaps a technician could prove something else by carefully measured comparison. I'm only interested in plain truth and would accept any outcome. But I don't think it helps much to compare such a trashy, nondynamic sound as in this expample. Maybe it would sound just as well on a Casio keyboard.

The comparison is even harder to do because I mistrust the resampling quality of the G: it seems to loose too much dynamic range (forcing normalization afterwards) to show the true quality of the G sound engine when playing quaility ROM sounds.

So with all due respct, Quinnx, as long as no techician with waterproof measured comparisons shows me that the sound engines are of equal quailty, I will stick to my subjective, but carefully checked comparison while I still had the X.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

8 Feb 2009, 20:00
I think you maybe missing the point..
the point is that as far as being able to produce quality sound and as to weather the end result is any less on the X than on the G.

The X is just as capable to producing same results.
the experiment was controled and methodical to rule out any kind of sound degradation due to resampling...

All sound starts off with a basic wav the one use was uncolored and un processed to make the experiment pure..

I have also taken wavs from other sources
imported them in to both the G and the X and built the same patch using the same parts that each system shares.

the results are the same
Since this is true then anyone with an X can produce the same production level as the G.
they are sonicaly the same until you use the extra plugins like PFX per patch, this is simply another extra filter in the chain that gives an extra kick to the overall sound.

The point being that the X is no less capable than the G when it comes to producing patches or sound.

The differences are in the extras on the G like

Live mode (seamless live changes) + Pfx
Single mode(seamless patch changes)+pfx

there are other performance and technical differences that are advanced on the G too..

But when producing music the end result will be just the same, the only difference will be how much more work one may or may not have to do on the other.

Out of the box there is a noticeable difference, but if your already producing music with the X it dont really matter that much to go to the G.
Knowing what i know now about the G If i could go back to when it was released, I would be in no big rush to get one.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

8 Feb 2009, 20:13
+1 Quinnx...

Your point is missed.

That's exactly what stopped me from getting one. I figured, "Hell, I already have one..."
Septimo ,'^)
X6
XT
MV-8800!!!!!!!

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 05:08
+1 Quinnx
Also my thoughts and impressions.
The reason why I am waiting with the G and also the ARX expansion aren't now that attractive, the SRX in the X are enough till now.
I am still observing the development of the G.......

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 14:51
I agree Quinnx, it will all be mixed down to 16bit 44khz (for CD) in the end and at that point they will sound very close to the same. But you also have to give credit where it’s due. The Fantom-G is first a live performance synth (as marketed by Roland) and in that filed it stands above the X. It has been said by Art and others that the G uses a new sound chip and 24/96 converters.

Artemiy-
The sound quality is also improved quite a bit, as you might expect with a new chip and 24/96 converters.
See here

Now if this is true (maybe Dan can confirm this for us) than the G does in fact have an edge when it comes to live play and what you will hear straight from the Amps.

Will your audience notice? I don’t know, maybe some will but most will just care about the music and if it sucks or not. The only way they will notice is if the sound quality is just bad. And that will never be the case with the G.

But I do care and I want my audience to have the best.

It’s kind of like owning a Bugatti Veyron (Super car) and knowing if you wanted to (said in a cool commercial guy voice) you could hit speeds of 253 mph, hold your head back and laugh at all the average people with there average cars living there average life Hahahahahah!! ;-)

With the Fantom-G you are hitting sonic speeds of 24/96 and even if your audience does not notice all of that speed and power you know it’s there and you like it don’t you Quinnx? admit it! ;-)

It makes me feel good knowing I’m providing my audience whit top quality sound when many other’s use synths with much lower quality. I think the fact that Roland cares about this kind of thing shows they are a company that cares about excellence and there customers.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 15:11
For me the deal is this.

The G has better Piano and EP's that cut though the mix wonderfully and my audience has sad repeatedly how much better my overall sound is from the X and how it all cut's thought the mix clearly.

I love the Fantom X and still own it (mainly for missing SRX sounds) But the G is better for me live, since I play mostly Piano and EP sounds.
www.songsforthemaster.com

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 15:51
Edit the "X" in the first setence to "G", or you will get a "LOL" from Quinnx. ;-))

Else exactly the same experience here, and everybody I asked agreed on this: the G just sounds a whole class better than the X in live play, and my impression is that the same counts for recording. I can't prove it, but I also can't but stay with my impression.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 16:03
Although I don't really like the idea of a "Fantom-G vs Fantom-X" thread, it would be very good idea to have te same thing Quinnx has done but with simple other sounds, like pianos, basses, drums etc. Anyone that owns both synths can do this.

But here I must declare my freedom, because I never onwned Fantom-X, so there is just not much of a dilemma for me.

I would be happier if some progress could be done for the Fantom-G itself, though.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 16:09
I own the Fantom X6 and I love its sound quality. Recently I've discovered that it also uses a HQ AD/DA converter that meets the 24/96 resolution, besides other HQ chips, so this is the key of good sound quality.

See the history here:

http://forums.rolandclan.info/?action=show_thread&thread=27995&fid=1&page=1

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 16:50
Really interesting technical thread, Cesarsound, thanks for the info!

I'm still searching for a logical explanation for the impression that the G has definitely more punch and clarity and cuts through significantly better in band conext. You can be sure that I never base my impressions on manufacturer advertisemnt hype or on the mere fact to use a newer device.
I have used both synths with the same band in the same rehearsal room, and asked musicians and non-musicians alike.
All agreed about the superiority of the overall G sound.

Have you meanwhile found out comparable basic information for the G like for the X? I'm really puzzled meanwhile. Perhaps Dan Krisher knows more?

Dan, at this point some clarification from someone closer to the resources would be helpful.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 17:05
Hi Jimknopf, thanks.

A simple way to do an A/B comparison between X and G is playing a GM MIDI file.

Someone that have both keyboards (X/G), could please download the attached file (it is a GM MIDI file with a nice instrumental and arrangement), plays it in both keyboards and record the mix, then post the audio here for us to listen.

See the attached MIDI File.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 17:15
The G does sound improved and I don’t think Quinnx is denying that. His point is that even if the bit rate was 64bit/192 when you mix it down to 16bit/44 it will still sound close (I know the tech behind it but it will be close) to the same.

While that maybe true I just think it’s good if we give the G the credit it’s due as a live synth. Having superior sound quality when being played live.

That is interesting info Cesarsound.

But you well need to do a G comparison as well. And it’s not that I don’t trust you but I would still need to hear an official word from Dan. Because unless Roland or Art (I know he’s not) is lying to us then new Chip (
The sound quality is also improved quite a bit, as you might expect with a new chip and 24/96 converters
) means the sound has been improved.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 18:06
Cesarsound, do you have some G specs comparable to the X specs you mentioned?

Concerning GM comparison. Isn't a GM-set with its cheap sample material rather hiding possible differences than revealing them?

I noticed the biggest differences with instruments covering wide frequency ranges and dynamics, like well sampled piano, Rhodes and other instruments. For example what stunned me, was that the SRX-12, which had an extensive sample base, sounded less dynamic than the (probably based on fewer samples) Vintage Rhodes in the G.

Perhaps the G samples have higher quality than those on the X (like the difference between the Nord Elektro 2 and 3 sample quality)?

Once again: Dan, could you provide any info keeping us from stumbling through the dark? ;-)

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

9 Feb 2009, 19:33
The G has the upper hand when it comes out of the box
and live performances etc..

And remember it suppose to have the best of the best samples so that makes it a plus to..

now imagine Putting the same best of the best samples in the X

Creating patches and the end results would be the same.

but on the performance side Live especially the G wins..



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

← Back to Fantom-G