Fantom-G

Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 01:35
Customer service starts with, "Yeah right ... " ??? OK ...

EDIT: When somebody signs their note with "X from Roland" that sounds fairly official and on-the-job to me ...

....................

Not that I'm looking for kudos — I'm not at all — but I've been saying all this from the get-go. Somehow, though, many, many people here believed Roland was somehow going to manage to get this right right out of the box ... Wrongo ... But I guess somebody had to buy these things to test for Roland ... (I still believe y'all should be getting free t-shirts or something from Roland for all the work you've been doing for them ... )

I still am very, very happy with my Fan-X and am still waiting patiently to see how this Fan-G scenario plays out ...

If anything dooms Fantom-G from this point it will be lack of desirable ARX cards and its "un-reloaded" soundset ...

Roland should also really consider getting its V2 OS out the door before Kurzweil releases its K-series successor because they're already making quite a splash it seems with their old and ugly looking PC3x ... However, the new PC3le is already showing signs of improvement in that realm (and adding pads which is a great sign for the K-series successor ... )
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 04:16
@Dan:

Yeah, for sure the two machines are different, different manufacturers, different OS Systems, different Power, different (release)times....

But still both ar workstations and so it's ok to do a comparison of both! And I really wanted the G to bust the Triton because thats the reason I bought a new synth but it didn't (til now)!

And as I said, I left the hardware advantages besides! And the Triton's got Switches/pitchwheel (with -y position)/Pedal inputs/4Knobs as well!
And as I already mentioned in the thread "Sliders in LiveMode" I already tried to reach the same control capability the triton offers with the G! But I failed! And til now nobody is able to help me!

And even if the G is able to do all what I want, why the hell do I have to ask forums, Roland support and the manual all the time? That's a sign for unnecessary complex handling!
I'm not a synth specialist (my first contact with synths is just 5 years ago) but I'm not a beginner and so I'm confused cause I dunno if the G can't do what I want or if I'm just too silly to check it out (or if the Roland-way-of-handling is just too complex for my brain ;) )...

greets
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 06:53
Diametro wrote:
>Customer service starts with, "Yeah right ... " ??? OK ...

Hey! I'm going to be defending Dan here. He's just a fellow Clan user just like all of us. This is not the customer service forum/line.

@Lukeofkeys: If the G can't do more for you than your Triton, then I think you haven't learned to use your G.

I will quote my favourite Youtube synth video poster, jexus:
"It's not what a synthesizer can do, but what a man can do with a synthesizer. "
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 07:10
That is true..
However.. as one start to get comfortable with what one has and decides to move on and get on with making music and you think you have this thing figured out..

You then come to do something only to find the OS has restricted you from doing what seemed logical and now you have to go in to rolands undocumented WORKAROUND MODE.

I suppose you could say..
The one who becomes master of Workarounds is the MAN!

However not to defend roland in anyway..
If i was to pick something i like about the G it would be the USB audio.

Now there are a few other things to like about it but there are alot of things that get in the way too which dulls the experience.
Its like taking one step forward and then having to stop! and think before you can put the next foot forward.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 08:02
Just for defending me here :D..I never said something against Dan, he's a great guy and I appreciate his help and his work (tutorials etc) and I respect his person..!!!

All I wanted to say is, that I really try to use my G, I really do, but even with all the help of Support, forum and manual I didn't get the clue yet!!

The comparison with my Triton was supposed to show how suprised I am that the G lacks at some points!!

Anyways can we leave my Triton out of sight please and can we concentrate on the problems of the G that are, and I thing most of us will agree, existant!

Well it is true that the man behind the synth defines sometimes what you can make and what you can't! But you will agree that the synth defines how complicated and complex it is!
And many of us already said that some things of the G are made unnecessary unlogical in comparison with other manufactorers!

greets
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

The G is fantastic so far, can only get better/best!

27 Jan 2009, 08:08
I am not dissapponted with the G at all (I was with the fantom X, that sucked bigtime!); the sounds of the G are great and the possibilities are unlimited, though: it has some things that annoys us, that's true. But i can tell you that if you would by a Triton or something else you would end up with a big list of issues too, thats just the way it is concerning synths and keys.

I can tell you that I've had/played a lot of synths and keyboards over the years from different brands, but the ones that pleased me most were those from Roland.

Last but not least: Every G-owner must understand that he/she has bought a beta-product/prototype of future Fantom Types (just as the jv-series were the beta's for the later Xp-series). In some years from now a Fantom B or C will be released where the B stands for Bugfree and the C for Completed. Untill that time we'll keep on praying!

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 09:21
Im not saying the G sucks
If one was willing to do all the work required to achieve ones goal..
you would get there.
The G is capable of allow you to produce a fully professional track.

Where it fails is OS and Workflow

breaking it down..

The biggest part of the OS that has been neglected is the Sequencer
Next is multisampling and the assignment of samples to keys
these things where much easier on the X.

roland went backwards here which is unforgivable, forcing people to use 3rd party software to complete the task.

The fact that the latest firmware gave us SMF export and multisampling does not give roland any credit since this is not a development or an advance on the G, these are things that where missing.
I have yet to see the G develop beyond the X because at the moment its playing catchup



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 09:31
I think the G SUCKS !!!! In Fact... if one of you will kindly give me yours I will PROVE IT....lol... and well.... If I cant prove it... you just wont be getting it back ...hehehe

I love my Fantom G

27 Jan 2009, 09:45
I have no complaints about the Fantom G.

Excellent workstation, has a good feature set.

It is easier to operate than my other workstations.

I would suggest the issues raised here are based on intended applications and expectations to other workstations.

I've worked (and owned) with the M1, 01/Wfd, Triton, Karma, M3, Motif MO & XS, Fantom X & G.

I find the Fantom G to be a leap forward in most areas. I expect Roland to continue the development of the instrument for a few more years.

I've been working with some friend who have compiled 30 songs in the Motif XS. The limitation and problems have taken us to the manual, the forums and has cost us many hours of detication to get it done, While the same issues presented the Fantom G seem easy and straight forward to solve. The reason we've stopped working the XS at 30 songs, it ran out of notes.

I would say the workflow is more suited to my production style.

Of course my Mac (Digital Performer & Cubase) have larger feature sets and more functions than the Fantom G. But the Mac is NOT a musical Instrument to me.

Keep on keyboarding Roland.

PS. I do have a complaint about money....Roland stuff is a little more $ than the others. Guess I'll have to save my pennys.
Fantom G & X7, Motif XS6, M3, V-synth, JP8000, M1, Wavestation, Radias, Nord Lead 2X, Karma, Snow, electribes and other groove boxes.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 09:48
Yeah. I'm so tired of waiting for updates and improvement from Roland that I'm considering of giving up using the Fantom-G. In fact, I'm not even gonna sale it. I'm just gonna give it away for free.

Anyone that wants my Fantom-G for free? I guess not. Since it sucks big time, I think that nobody would want it, even without paying for it. :-P LOL LOL LOL

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 09:54
I am just disappointed with the onboard sample/sample editing. It nearly identical to the Fantom X and MV-8800 when it comes to sample editing....but they short changed us.
Weapons of Mass Destruction: Nuendo 4, MPC 5K, Fantom G

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 10:02
Something about the FG's price: Is there anyone here that got his/her brand-new Fantom-G6 for less than 1700 Euros? (it's about 2200$US). I believe that there isn't a smaller price in Europe. The catalog price is 1999€ (about 2600$US) but they always give it for much less. So another "thank you" goes to our Roland/Boss distributor in Greece (Stollas S.A.) for maybe having the lowest prices around. :-)

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 10:34
G works and plays good...not only that, when I sample other keyboards into the G, the G ends up sounding better than the original...Awesome!

Updates by Music Messe?
www.songsforthemaster.com
Hey Luke, Im dissappointed with certain little aspects of the G but I'm actually liking it more and more. Dont forget to download updates to your board.

Remember, there's 22 effects all at once, counting the mastering, the audio input effect, the chorus/reverb, and the two multi-effects, and the 16 patch ones.

So far, I havent found a way to chain the two muti-effects together like you could on the S. Do you know of a way?

What I recommed though for you, is to use both keyboards for one. You'll have twice the power and control. I like the G as a controller but not as my stand alone create board. I use my fantom S for that.

Try converting your songs to midi files and upload them into your G, man, I love it like that.

Hope those things help.

Greets,
Chuck

← Back to Fantom-G