Fantom-G

Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 11:58
Hey there!

I wanted to know how many Users we've got here that are disapointed by the G and why you think so?

Well, I wouldn't say that I'm really disapointed but I'm not really happy with the G! I originaly bought the G because the only key I owned til now was a Korg Triton 61, and I wanted an 88 note keyboard which should have had more controllers, a more contemporary sound, more effects, more timbres to be played together in "LiveMode", more sampleRom/Ram, more connectivity-options etc.!

Some of these requirements are pleased by the G eg. 88note kbd., more modern sound, connectivity, sampleRom/Ram;

I'm disapointed by the Controllers because it has got more hardware controllers but the usage is so limited that my Triton is able to control more and versatile parameters with its 4 Knobs!
For my share I can use the effect-section of the Triton more efficient as the PFX thing of the G! I never had problems to do anything on my Triton because of lack of power, with the G I'm not able to create a simple liveset that contains a distorted organ with rotary effect because I've only one PFX and no MFX!
Til now I haven't found anything on the G that the Triton couldn't do! (leaving the hardware advantages of the G (eg. DBeam, more controllers etc) besides!)

Well I just wanted to say that and I'd like to know if I'm alone with my thoughts?!

greets
Luke
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 12:14
The only two diappointments for G users from my view are:

- a half-baked soundset with VERY uneven quality from patch to patch and from wav to wav (some amazing good, some mediocre, not few hopelessly outdated). Many patches were obviously written in a hurry (for understandable reasons when pushing the G release), without using full G possibilities (fine tuning of layers, use of controllers, bad adjusted effects etc.): that needs intensive fixing both of wav material and patch design quality.

- a "two third-baked" OS (bugs, shortcomings, whole areas like sequencer and effect routing etc.), which needs some serious update soon as well.

But these are two things that can be cured, if only Roland would put some recognizeable priority here. The first half year only showed some bug or feature fixing with recovering to the state of things long available on the X, like Multisampling and SMF export, and some more minor updates. We've not seen a major update (or a consequent row of ongoing minor updates including Namm) yet.
Still all chances are with Roland, as soon as they really develop their own design to where it should be.

And frankly, I would not exchange two Tritons with my one G. I understand your point of facing shortcoming in the G, which are limiting its true power in a somewhat idiotic way. But despite its weak points the G still plays in a completely other league than the Triton does (which was great then) from my view! So I'm not really disappointed about the G, but expect Roland to give considerably more priority to its development.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 12:17
I've counted only three bugs in the 1.20 OS, and they're all minor.

The only major issues I have with the G:

1. No way to access more than 16 channels (one port) via USB.

2. Current small selection of ARX boards. The ones that exist are great; I just don't personally care about horns, EPs, or better acoustic drums. Would much rather have a VA, VC-2, or multitimbral orchestral board—You know, stuff that would make others buy a G just for access to ARX.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 12:18
I'm happy with my Fantom G7. I think it's a great synth.
I mean for me it's good enough. All I want can be done, sometime with a workaround but that happens most of the time with a new synth.

I had the classic Yamaha Motif, the very early one, with OS 1.0. There was the same story going on. It take some time to get bugs out of the OS design.

I know I should be good the first time but that is not the real world I think. There are always things to improve. It's now up to Roland to do their job.

In the meantime have fun with it and make music!

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 12:29
@Jimknopf: But even because the G plays in a totally different league it should bust the Triton easily, but it doesn't! The Gs hardware is state of the art while the Triton is 10 years old and though it is able to do everything the G does (Sure not everything but at least concerning applications I use!)!

But the main point came through, the G could be so powerful but its just too limited!

I will wait til the next major OS update and if then the main problems like effects, controllers aren't fixed, I have to think about a solution! I want to keep the G the next 5-7 years and I don't want to anger myself everytime I use the G!

greets
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 12:43
I don't know what you do with a Triton, but there's lots of thing the G delivers and the Triton doesn't.

The most obvious are:
- live switching
- sequencing with midi AND audio material
- controller variety. Yes, their possibilities are unfinished in the present OS, but on the Triton I can't controll a B3 clone sound or a synth patch with 8 sliders plus 4 knobs, and without being sure, I imagine you have not yet explored even the present potential fully, because it's more powerful, yet complicated (SYS and TEMP-Settings, access to external settings etc.), than on the Triton.
- big (multi)sampling space (1 Gb!) for up-to date sample material in RAM (no disk streaming once its there)
- MUCH better half-weigthed and weighted keyboards (for my taste the Triton keyboard action is dreadful)
- extremly useful big, multifunctional colour display
- many better sounds, translated crisp and clear and punchy with a much better overall sound immediately positively present in band and mix
...

Ask Audacity, and he will easily double my list... ;-)

@TAW: If you name the three bugs, we could check the list and add if necessary. This not to make the list as long as possible, but perhaps to mirror it to Roland, in a separate thread: known bugs are easier to fix than those named by users AFTER an update.

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 12:55
As I said before, I left the hardware advantages besides! So things like:

- controller variety (yes, their possibilities are unfinished in the present OS, but on the Triton I can't controll a B3 clone sound or a synth patch with 8 sliders plus 4 knobs
* I've to add that you can't controll a B3 with the faders in use as drawbars (but the triton can't as well :D)

- big (multi)sampling space (1 Gb!) for up-to date sample material in RAM (no disk streaming once its there)
- extremly useful big, multifunctional colour display

are'nt fair :D...

Well the live switch thing is good, but not essential for me, If I could choos betw. controllers that are useful and seamless switching I would choose the controller thing immediately!

And by the way, I really like the Tritons keyboard! But that'ts subjective rating!

I'm sure that I haven't checked the complete potential yet because I didn't get the clue til now! Not with using the manual and not with asking the Support/Forum (yes!)!

There are many things I tried on the G and on the Triton simultaniously just to test the functionality of the G, and everything I tried on it was possible an the Triton and many things I tested on the Triton weren't possible on the G!^^

greets
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 13:17
I can't imagine that. All you can do with the Triton can be done with the Fantom G. Really, give it a try. If you don't know, ask you questions here, over and over untill you understand. There are lot's of kind forummembers who are willing to help you.
Of course there is a learning curve but once you get the hang of it.....So switch off your Triton and go on with the Fantom G. ;)

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 13:28
Anton:"So switch off your Triton and go on with the Fantom G. ;) "
nice sentence :D....

Ok, this is gonna be a long thread and I'm to tired now to go on with this...so stay tuned for a very long, hard to understand thread!
Think I'm goin to write it tomorrow!

One thing is described in that thread:
http://forums.rolandclan.info/index.php?action=show_thread&thread=25068&fid=8&page=1

nobody answered, is it hard to understand or isn't there a solution?!

greets
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

Time to sell

26 Jan 2009, 19:13
Now,it´s time to sell the G

I have wait long time for an update,but Namm brings nothing to me.
JimKnopf say my words:

- a half-baked soundset
- a "two third-baked" OS

This FantomG is a Prototyp and we are the betatesters.
Sorry Guys,that was it to me.
I have reading the whole forum every Day to this Maschine,really good forum!I learned more that i want.

Thanks to ALL!!

You can buy my FG6 at thomann.de for 1600 Euro
(Now i have really tears in my eyes,no joke)

greets

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 20:02
Ok, so here's a short little post. :)

I think the Fantom G is at 70% right now featurewise. But I also think I have now, after owning it for 8 months, only just mastered to use those 70%. It's a fairly complex machine and one can get almost all tasks done with it, albeit sometimes slowly.

I am now positive that there will be an extensive update 'soon', before the summer, and I have an album worth of songs (70 compositions, not arranged) on my Fantom G so I can not sell it (and I don't want/need to). Therefore I have decided it is no use for me to be frustrated at the lacks of the G because by the time the album is finished the new update will be here.

I have heard, from "trusted sources", that Roland Japan now has an extensive list of things that need to be addressed, gathered from all continents. I will not discuss that one more than that as I have nothing to say.

I'm not disappointed at the Fantom G itself, but I am disappointed at Roland Japan for keeping me waiting and selling an unfinished product.

I do not think I would have noticed the lacks even if I would have researched even more before buying, the lacks only surfaced slowly after using it for some months, when getting deeper and deeper into the G.

Getting Dan Krisher & co from Roland US to come down here to the Clan was a good start and I hope Roland Japan sees us users as a resource in the future, more than.. well I don't know what they think, since they still play mute.

I don't prioritize the onboard presets that much, but I can see the presets are not at all amazing, but I do not care much, since I usually make my own ones. I have been using strings and orchestra a lot thou, and an Orchestra ARX board, like TAW mentioned, would be great. I'd also liked to see an VA, but I bought an Oberheim because Roland didn't release anything for me at NAMM09 so I don't need a VA board anymore.

The effects routing could be amazing, but now it more or less makes me sad and angry. The effects are soundwise great, but the lack of saving and patching really gets me down.

The sequencer is very basic and I guess it gets the work done since I have 70 songs recorded, but I think I would have 300 songs recorded if the coders would have dedicated some time to make the sequencer work as expected in 2008/2009..

The Arpeggiator. Well. I don't use it that much, since it's not something I would use in the music I do right now, but I've used it a couple of times and it comes loaded with nice presets, but in all, I think it is a bit unexciting. I don't know why. Maybe I just got bummed because it didn't allow USER arpeggios. Maybe I should give it another chance, maybe someone that has arpeggiator skills makes an Youtube video that gives me an raging arpeggi-on.

RPS. I want those on the keys.

Chord memory. It needs a bit of artificial intelligence and fuzzy logic. I want it to know what modes mean. Some might call that arranger functions, but my goddamn browser know spelling eventhou it's not a word processor, I think that's the same thing.

File Management. Well.. It gets really messy after a while. There's this thing called folders. Someone ought to google "folders" at Roland japan. lol..

Sampling. it got better in 1.20 but it's still a bit bulky, I think I would probably want to do the sampling stuff on my computer screen with the VSTi. Dragging and dropping and renaming stuff with the good old qwerty. I think importing other sample formats and presets should be an out-of-the box feature.

Filters. I think they are nice. But I would like them to be dirty. So more filter algorithms.

Controllers. They should be in control more. and the user should be in control of the controls more. like assignable where ever we want, adjustable range, not 1-128 all the time, sometimes 40-80 range is what I want, like with filters and resonance. once slider controls a group of fucntions. one function can be inverse. save controller settings as presets for later recall.

Mouse. It is nice to see the arrow move, but functionality is important too. Specially when it really is needed, like in the microscope and in the sequencer.

Screensaver. How about turning the screen OFF after a while? Ecological and actually saves the screen if it's going to be working for 10 years. We still have tons of leds that show the power is on.

Tempo. Yeah, you know.. not 120 all the time.

Recording and keeping the flow going. On the Akai MPC, one can record a whole song, all parts, everything without exiting record at all.. the music is playing all the time, you will be dancing and in the groove. And speaking of groove, input quantize should be heard when playing.

Inputs, instead of choosing one input with the input selector (shift+mix in), an input mixer would be nice. In the sequencer while recording, one could choose between each single input or 'mix'.

USB functionality. Ability to browse and preview for samples from your mac/pc via USB before importing, same with stuff on USB sticks, inside folders. Multiple MIDI I/O via USB MIDI (access to external and ARX boards from DAW)

That's basically my list.

But in all I am happy. It is better than anything else on the market.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

26 Jan 2009, 22:55
Are`nt we just repeating ourselves??
Its seems since the G was released it has drawn out the worse in critical comments which of course is directly a result of its half finished OS and the lack of communication from Roland..
They just do not inspire confidence in its customer base.

I have said it so many times before that the G has too much missing that we will only see advances in the NEXT workstation around 2010.

Roland have missed the boat at this stage..
the G was HOT!! when it was released and roland needed to strike while the iron was still red..
Its getting cold now and their market has reached its peak now it will taper off.

No update will get that back..

Lets move on..



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 00:26
Oh Quinnx, say it isn't so. I'm still saving my coins to get a G and you're telling me it's already over the hill?

Re: Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?

27 Jan 2009, 01:08
Who of you G-users is disapointed/galled and why?
Hey there!

I wanted to know how many Users we've got here that are disapointed by the G and why you think so?

Well, I wouldn't say that I'm really disapointed but I'm not really happy with the G! I originaly bought the G because the only key I owned til now was a Korg Triton 61, and I wanted an 88 note keyboard which should have had more controllers, a more contemporary sound, more effects, more timbres to be played together in "LiveMode", more sampleRom/Ram, more connectivity-options etc.!

Some of these requirements are pleased by the G eg. 88note kbd., more modern sound, connectivity, sampleRom/Ram;

I'm disapointed by the Controllers because it has got more hardware controllers but the usage is so limited that my Triton is able to control more and versatile parameters with its 4 Knobs!
For my share I can use the effect-section of the Triton more efficient as the PFX thing of the G! I never had problems to do anything on my Triton because of lack of power, with the G I'm not able to create a simple liveset that contains a distorted organ with rotary effect because I've only one PFX and no MFX!
Til now I haven't found anything on the G that the Triton couldn't do! (leaving the hardware advantages of the G (eg. DBeam, more controllers etc) besides!)

Well I just wanted to say that and I'd like to know if I'm alone with my thoughts?!

greets
Luke



Yeah right. I've got a Triton and it doesn't compare at all with the G effects wise or"controller" wise. They are different systems. Different machines. It might help if you study your "G" a little more, then make the snap judgment:

You've got way more control capability on the "G":

Switches S1 and S2
D-Beam
Mod/Pitch Wheel
8 sliders
4 knobs
16 pads

Plus assignments to the two external pedals and aftertouch.

You'd do well to read up on this:

http://www.rolandus.com/uploads/CMS/Downloads/2334/FGWS09.pdf

Peace out.


Image

← Back to Fantom-G