Fantom-G

JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 07:30
Certainly better than the one with that Hanna bloke... ;) Or the countless ones, where's a lot of talk but not a single note played.

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 08:15
Well, even though I am not buying the G, I am VERY impressed by these demos! It seems to me that Korg and Yamaha better watch out.

Since I have sampling covered on my X8, and I just acquired mint condition XV-88 (I know, it's 8 years old but STILL kicks ass) and I own two other Roland products as well a Kurzweil K2000, Wavestation EX, and a Yamaha module, my next purchase - once the OS is straightened out - is the Kurz PC3X. I need to retire my K2000 and the synthesis capabilities of the PC3X are pretty damned stunning. My plan is to MIDI the PC3X to the XV-88. The two together should make some serious patches together.

Back to the G: it seems that if Roland can properly exploit ARX, then they could have an OASYS killer on their hands at half the price. To be honest, I DO find the OASYS impressive, but not enough so to justify the ridiculous price tag. Open Labs Meko/Neko is FAR more open architecture than the OASYS again at half the price - unless you go for the frivolous gold model :)

So, I am VERY happy for all of you new G users! Here's hoping Roland continues to expand this beast and finally silence the Korg heads.

Best,
Vlad
"Turn off your mind, relax and float downstream" - John Lennon "Tomorrow Never Knows"

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 09:44
Arjan:
If only Roland would have the key range for a part apply even if you play it through an external MIDI keyboard I would agree.


From the System MIDI page, turn Remote Keyboard Switch on. Any external controller will act exactly like the built-in one. This feature's existed in Roland keyboards for many years.

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 10:01
From the System MIDI page, turn Remote Keyboard Switch on. Any external controller will act exactly like the built-in one. This feature's existed in Roland keyboards for many years.
The problem here is the word exactly. From the manual:
Remote Keyboard Sw
(Remote Keyboard Switch)
Set this parameter “ON” when you want to use an external MIDI keyboard instead of the Fantom-G’s keyboard. In this case, the MIDI transmit channel of the external MIDI keyboard can be set to any channel. Normally you will leave this parameter “OFF.”
I want to use the external keyboard in addition to the internal keyboard, not instead. For example playing strings on internal Fantom G keyboard on part 1 while playing piano on part 2 through the external keyboard in the same key range. You can't do that with the Remote Switch, ie it doesn't add any keys.

More complex setups could involve some bass sound on lower halve of the Fantom (part 1), piano on upper halve of the Fantom (part2), string/vox on lower halve of the external MIDI keyboard (part 3+4), Hammon on upper halve of the external MIDI keyboard.

I realize that with the new glitchless live mode switching I can probably replace some splits/multiple keyboards setups with pedal based switching so that's what I will try as soon as my dealer receives the FC-300 that they ordered from Roland for me to try. But it still is a shame that the Fantom G does not properly support using it as a multi-part module when played from external MIDI keyboards. All it would take is a simple switch: part key range applies to incoming MIDI, either global or (perhaps better) per part. Could by right next to the KBD switch.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 10:42
It is indeed in addition to, but you're right; you can't differentiate between what the internal and external keyboard control (aside from transposing both in opposite extremes).

Back in the day, splits and layers were always done in the controller. Unfortunately, almost all the new controllers are cheeseball and don't support more than one split. If one had, say, an A-70 or A-90, they could send PC messages from the Fantom (along with a Live Set) to switch the A-series setup (instantly setting up new splits and layer zones), but some random M-Audio controller won't help much.

It's so weird—The market for a professional-level controller is greater now than it's ever been, yet no one makes one.

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 10:47
Hmm, this is interesting..

Vlad_77 wrote:

"it seems that if Roland can properly exploit ARX, then they could have an OASYS killer on their hands at half the price."

Here are the ARX cards that Roland would have to release:

-A virtual analog synth with 72 voices of polyphony and extreme anti-aliasing.

-A tonewheel modeling organ with full polyphony.

-An ultra realistic plucked string modeling synth.

-An FM synth with 52 notes polyphony that can read DX7 patches.

-A stereo wavetable synth with vector synthesis.

The Fantom-G has two (2) expansion slots...

(And oh, I forgot: approx. 2 Gb of sample ROM to match the Oasys.)

What is my point here? I believe the Fantom-G is an excellent instrument, I'm picking my up tomorrow. (I can't wait actually!!) And I believe it will complement my Oasys and V-Synth GT quite nicely. It's always good to have different tastes to offer in the studio, right?

It verges onto the moronic to keep hoping that an instrument will beat another one just to "finally silence the Korg heads."

The Oasys is a beast.

And I believe the Fantom-G will be one in it's own right.
V-Synth GT (2.0)

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 11:07
I watched the first part (sounds) and the effect part and I'm clearly not impressed. I don't consider this a good presentation. Too many adjectives (terrific, outstanding, etc.) and too little proof of that. I don't want someone else to draw conclusions for me, I want to reach my own conclusions! Instead I want sounds and a keyboardist performance. There are only 4 sounds demoed on the first part: an acoustic piano (which isn't really my type, it sounds very much a la Gloria Gaynor "I will survive"), a distortion guitar (which sounded kinda cool, but hey that's not something I'd want to hear in such a short demo - at least an organ would do), a lead synth and - finally - a good choir sound! How can someone jump to such assumptions by browsing only through 4 sounds??? The ADHD afflicted guy from Yamaha does a much better job at it, although I really hate his extatic style...

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 11:36
I agree that 'the G sound' was demoed **much** too short, just scratching a tiny bit of the surface. From my view it would require at least four more 3-4-minute-videos, divided in groups of sounds, to give users just a basic impression of the G sounds.

But concerning the overall impression of what you can do with a Fantom G, Jem's demoing was **much** better suited for interested keyboarders, than the unimpressive, superficial, disappointing and totally lame Namm08 shows have been from my view.

P.S. I heard that Roland announced a very exciting Namm booth demo, appearing on a site called "Fantom G experience": soooon!!! So keep your eyes wide shut over the next years - or you could suddenly be blinded by all the demo light ;-)

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 11:44
I heard that Roland announced a very exciting Namm booth demo, appearing on a site called "Fantom G experience": soooon!!!
I heard that too! It must be true!! =)

PiaKnowGuy
Listen to - Pirates Done entirely on the X8!

PiaKnow
PiaKnowGuy
Please feel free to listen to Pirates
[img]http://www.piaknow.com/1goldpiaknowlogonew-thumbnail-thumbnail.jpg[/img]
PiaKnow

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 12:18
I also didn't like GEM's presentation that much, it's like he's just showing what we all already know from looking at the specifications of the Synth... No value added...

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 12:28
I like the seqencer section,it seems real easy to work with.i never thought i would use song mode that much because i like working in pattern mode.With Jem showing how to lay down a track then copying the tracks you want made me want to use song mode in the Fantom G.I wonder can you select a
group of tracks and copy them instead of one track at a time.
especially with drum tracks.

That was "Jem with brakes on"

28 Apr 2008, 14:02
Considering Jem's other online videos (blog etc) I have to say that these demos showed only 50% of his video presence, enthusiasm, capability to entertain or educate.

We have to remember that these videos were ordered, paid, authorized and used by ROLAND.

I bet, he was given a very strict storyboard of "what to show" and "what to focus on". I know he can do differently and I am confident to see some of that in his own blog videos. I for one also had the impression he had to watch (a bit) his (sometimes very) quick mouth. ;-)

Anyway, his way of presenting this beast is much more informative than the other stuff we have seen so far, well except for Art's video demo, of course...! :-)
shrewd-salut!
SRUT, BUT...

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 14:05
I can't believe this even needs to be said, but there is no possible way to judge the sonic character of a keyboard from compressed online videos, much less make an empirical statement regarding such.

Re: JEM GODFREY DEMOS THE FANTOM G!

28 Apr 2008, 15:48
can't believe this even needs to be said, but there is no possible way to judge the sonic character of a keyboard from compressed online videos, much less make an empirical statement regarding such.
Absolutely correct! It does help if one's PC speakers and sound card are up to snuff though. ;) If so, it will at least give people a 'semblance' of how the sounds will sound, or better yet, an 'inkling' of an idea of how it will sound; at least in broad general terms anyway. If the sounds that JEM played or any of the other sounds from the other demos of the G are listened to in context, there is built up over time a consensus on how the sounds will hopefully muster when playing the thing (in this case the G ;) in person.

I thought JEM gave a good presentation, albeit, it was short on sounds; and, needless to say, more geared toward some of the new features on the G. As far as the new features, being able to lay down tracks in the Sequencer song mode with such relative ease is really exciting to me and JEM was able to showcase that and the other new features that he demonstrated with finesse and style. I too though would have liked to see him showcase more of the sounds. It's also a real bummer that the sliders can NOT be used in conjunction with the Organs as drawbars. I hope Roland will set their nose to the grindstone and get busy to make it a reality in a future OS update. It would be possible I would think. Even though there are only eight sliders on the G it should be possible to toggle an extra 'virtual' slider in the OS menu that would work in conjunction with the other real sliders. Or if that is too difficult for Roland engineers ;) - an alternative method would be to provide nine 'virtual' sliders in a separate OS sub menu.

← Back to Fantom-G