Fantom-G

How the Fantom-G sequencer works

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 11:43
I would say it's more necessary on the G, because since the parts/channels/tracks don't line up and there's no way to extract channels from within tracks/phrases, people are gonna be messing up a lot at first.

"Okay, I recorded part 1, now let me record part two. WTF? They're on the same track? Okay, let me undo that. Huh, I cant? Okay, let me extract the channel to a different track. Wait, I can't do that either? Sigh... Okay, let me rerecord these two parts..."

But once people learn it, it (hopefully) will be easier to avoid mistakes.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 11:52
That's it...I'm just going to play perfect from now on.

I have a feeling it will still be easy to erase data at least by using the mouse.

Or maybe something like a backspace key.
www.songsforthemaster.com

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 13:30
Audacity seems to be spot on with the way the sequencer works as well as the advantages and problems. I think Roland is trying to add flexibility and wound up reinventing the wheel. This new design brings the issues Audacity has brought up and trades flexibility and buzz whiz power features for simplicity and ease of use. As we can clearly see the need for undo is crucial. For all the supposed time we save on the power features we loose time on the front end during the creative process where it counts the most.

It does seem however that it can be fixed to work like a traditional pattern sequencer while still allowing the new flexibility. The phrase can already act as a pattern or possibly a whole linear song. You just have to insert it into the song when you are done.

Along with a quick one or two button press undo, we need a quick way of muting phrase sequencer channels without abruptly cutting off the sound. The track mute button should act as a channel mute when working in "phrase mode". The mixer is obviously the place that we select the channel for recording. Channels here can be thought of as tracks. If we hit record I hope the sequencer remembers the last selected phrase by default and records there instead of always reseting to phrase one or selecting a new phrase. This will be crucial in sticking with the "I am working on this phrase/pattern/song right now" concept. Otherwise it will be a mess. Also, the track select mode should act as channel select when working with phrase recording and editing. This way we can keep track of things more easily.

I think that RPS should work differently when recording to and editing phrases. It should only be a next phrase cue up instead of a phrase trigger. This way we can Quickly audition and select different phrases and see how they flow into each other. I never liked the old RPS and patterns how the pads where used as transports. I also hate the way tempo bar and loop were set in song mode for patterns. What I am saying is phrase edit should be like pattern mode on the MV with its own recording set-up. Song mode should be the same as it is.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 13:36
Also hoping for songs that each channel of a track is recorded to the same phrase.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 15:08
Roland needs to stop playin around and make 32 parts and 64 tracks, (the other 32 going either audio or midi) in the same fasion as always instead of trying some off the wall aproach just to impress us with 128 midi.... not being able to undo a mistake. Hopefuly the mouse is as quick... Not that Fantom X's undo was quick with that 3 part fingerobics move, but you got used to it.

But what's done is done, let's see what comes out of this.
Septimo ,'^)
X6
XT
MV-8800!!!!!!!

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 15:36
In regard to the track to same phrase it seems as long as that phrase is in the current time line it will record new data to that phrase. Otherwise it creates a new phrase. Each "chunk" of data in the song screen represents a phrase.

There seems to be a couple workarounds for undo.
The track clear that Art mentioned will work to clear any new recorded phrase material that has not been saved to the project with the save command. If you did not save between takes (normal behavior) this will erase your previous take/channel.

You can go into overdub recording and select erase and press erase all in real time. I think this will only erase the currently selected channel/part. Of course if you are already in overdub record and realized your mistake this is the easiest way to undo your last recording. Unfortunately you have to wait until the sequencer plays through the whole phrase to finish erasing. If you just recorded a long phrase this will take much longer than a dedicated undo button.

Last, you can press edit to go into phrase edit. Then select modify. Then select erase. Then select the channel you want to erase. Then press enter-yes. As you can see, this takes much longer and more button presses than undo.

Undo should be quick because it allows you to discard a bad take quickly and get back to recording before you loose your idea. Really, it should have a dedicated button on the front panel because of its often need and dependence on speed. Since the hardware is fixed Roland should at least implement a 2 button press undo.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 16:01
I did not see anything in the manual that suggest that the mouse could be used for undo. Remember in the song screen you are working on entire phrases at a time and not the individual contents of the phrase.

It would be nice to right click on the phrase and select undo if not already possible. The only problem maybe that I suspect the G does not keep track of the last edit or recording take separately. It seems to only deal with the entire unsaved phrase in the temporary memory. Thus deleting all phrase data on the track since the last save to project the way the clear track works.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

24 Apr 2008, 21:46
Provided we get an Undo feature, the new sequencer is going to be WAY easier to use than previous versions. I have a really bad habit of over-explaining things.

I remember sequencing on keyboards, and... how you guys still put up with it... The whole 30 button presses (or whatever) just to move a two-bar section... Damn.

Just move the region with a mouse or value dial. It makes perfect sense.

Here's the non-Audacity Works version—

TO RECORD A TRACK:
Select the part, select the track, record.

TO RECORD A PATTERN:
Select the part, select the phrase, record.



Aaaand... Cake.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 04:18
Thank you, The Audacity Works, for your detailed commentary on this! You seem to know so very much about the new G. You surely already have a G infront of you sitting as you can explain the procedure in so very detail! Lucky you! And all these detailed comparisons X/G! Rich info this is! How can you know all that? Or are you a product manager of Roland for the G? ;-)

I think I understood now better how the seq functions, but I still can not say what would be the better way to record: with tracks or phrases.

I worked with Cubase (long ago) and this was easy to "vary" the different parts of a song: refrain, bridge etc. by simply "muting" several parts on a track. or by copying one instance of a part and editing it into something different. How these operations will work on a G? I think I have to wait for a real live test to really understand! ;-)

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 04:53
How does MIDI sequencing on the Fantom-G compare with MIDI sequencing using Sonar (now another Roland product)?

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 06:00
How does MIDI sequencing on the Fantom-G compare with MIDI sequencing using Sonar (now another Roland product)?
Probably it's very similar since Fantom-G has a reworked GUI, bigger screen, proper midi clips (aliases to phrases). But it has its differences too - "clips" may contain multichannel data, RPS, you have an instant control surface at your disposition (knobs, faders, pads), automation is still CC/sysex based.

The only way to answer such question is to use Fantom-G anyway.
Hard On!

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 11:18
kroll:
You seem to know so very much about the new G. You surely already have a G infront of you sitting as you can explain the procedure in so very detail! Lucky you! And all these detailed comparisons X/G! Rich info this is! How can you know all that?
I've been designing studios and consulting for ten years. My niche has been building TDM ProTools rigs with Logic as the front end (it's a pretty complicated process), but I also build live rigs for touring acts (big enough to tour, not big enough to hire me as a backline tech). The Fantom-X has been pretty important in this regard, as its MIDI engine, audio tracks, and RPS functionality are perfect as a hardware solution for backing tracks, automated program changes, etc.

My dad owns a Fantom-S88 and every time I visit the folks in AZ, he has a new slew of questions. As his G8 is coming in sometime next week, I'm just getting ready.

And I did spend a lot of time with the G6 at NAMM. Shared my notes with everyone here and at HC. Aaand... The manual's been up on the Japanese site for over a month.

Note that I could be completely wrong about a lot of this, as Roland have most likely made a lot of changes since NAMM. But the manual's pretty clear about a lot of things.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 11:44
so i wonder if the sequencer will be same/similar to the mv-8000/8800 sequencer? Many think the mv units are very easy and quick to sequence on.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 12:33
No, it is very different than the MV. The MV will certainly be faster and easier to get your ideas down, however the G seems to be more flexible in some ways. The MV has a one button press undo on the front panel and you can punch in from play without stopping. You can also right click edit directly in the main screen without a bunch of button pushes and menus. I have gone through the G manual and most editing operations seem to be a couple extra button presses or ckicks versus doing the same thing on the MV. On the other hand there are a couple of things faster on the G but mostly not. The alias thing on the G is cool though.

Re: How the Fantom-G sequencer works

25 Apr 2008, 15:08
The MV-8x00's sequencer is track-based (like Logic, Cubase, ProTools, MPCs); the Fantom G's is part based (like other Fantom and XP sequencers, only without the Auto-track select shortcut). An explanation of what this means can be found earlier in this thread.

They're vastly different. The MV's sequencer precludes recording more than one part at a time, which isn't very workstation-like.

← Back to Fantom-G