Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorder

Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorder

16 May 2007, 13:17
I am thinking of buying a Boss BR600 multitrack recorder. I have a Fantom X6 with the audio tracks and was just wondering if buying a seperate recorder is nessecary?
Is it possible to record reverb onto a audio track and change level, depth of reverb, time etc and have the changes recorded to a track?
I want to record maybe 3 guitar parts and 3 or 4 vocal parts plus using the midi tracks. Will this make writing songs a long process?
Can you bounce tracks 1-6 onto 7 and 8 and re record onto tracks 1 to 6 again?
Thanks.

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

16 May 2007, 14:45
Whatever you asked is possible in the X. The only difference I think is that the sequencer will get a bit slow while working with audio tracks.
What I meant is that , when playing back multiple audio tracks, and you press STOP, it'll take a bit of time for it to stop becuase of the vast amount of data in the sequence, whereas I think this wont happen with a Stand Alone Multitrack Recorder.

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

16 May 2007, 16:25
Physically, you'll get far more flexibiity with a stand alone recorder - the X doesn't have XLR or phantom power connectors for pluging in condensor mics or a high-z input for electric guitars. Clean guitar sounds work well enough but if you like a little or a lot of drive, then it sounds terrible due to the high signal/noise ratio.

Steve
agreed. The audio tracks,to me, are more for capturing ideas. Say you have a smoking bass groove burning a hole in your head.....plug in your bass guitar and lay it down with some drums. Using ONE box/machine/keyboard to do EVERYTHING is retarded. I strongly recommend buying a muli-track recorder. Sequence all your tracks on the X, THEN set the X to slave, and recorder to master, and record your X's tracks in 1 by 1 into the recorder. Everything stays in sync, each track now has EQ and comp, and you'll have more options for FX....not to mention XLR ins and hi-z ins ;)

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

17 May 2007, 13:19
The main difference is that Fantom needs to load the tracks from RAM and this takes some time. BR-600 plays directly from flash memory which doesn't require to pre-load anything when you need it.

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

17 May 2007, 13:26
Artemio ftw!

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

17 May 2007, 15:14
Thanks for the advice.
I have been looking at theBoss BR-600, Zoom mrs-802 etc. My budget isn't big as you can tell by the models I'm looking at, but these two have pretty good write ups for budget mutli trackers.
I do want something with digital in outs and USB so I can upload everything to my P.C.
If this the case I may even sell my FX6 and get a Xa or, dare I say it a yamaha MO6, which I think have some great patches on them. I'm not really into sampling, don't have the time, so this could be the next avenue. I really do love my FX6 though and I can't think of anything substantial that annoys me about it. Ah the agony of choice what do you think I should do?
I need your advice clan.

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

17 May 2007, 15:40
Keep the X, and get a motif es rack, and control it with the X. It's cheaper that way;-) Upload to pc?...for storage, or more editing? The only bad thing about the br600 is it DOES NOT come with a DC adapter($20 more)....that and only 8 tracks. It could still do the job though :-}

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

17 May 2007, 15:47
Hello Solitary man,

I'll throw in my two cents here. . . . .

The pairing of the X6 and a multitrack is is a good one. I have a Tascam 2488 and it complements the X6 well. The questions you asked in your initial post are really functions of a multitrack and I wouldn't expect a hardware based sequencer to do those things well, if at all. I have used the Fantom's Audio Tracks for laying down grooves/ideas with my bass or guitar, and in some cases have completely produced songs using the Midi and Audio tracks together.

My advice is not to sell the Fantom. The forum is littered with posts of folks who have sold gear and regret it. Assess what you primarily wish to do and cross refrence those desires with the capabilities of the Fantom/Multitrack combo. (By the way, I'm not a big sampler, either). There really isn't anything that comes to mind that you wouldn't be able to do, given the limited info you've stated so far.

Another option that you may want to consider if you have a decent computer setup is to purchase a software DAW. They allow you to manipulate audio, bounce tracks, etc..

Just a thought and perhaps another avenue for you to look at.......

Bassman
Bassman

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

17 May 2007, 16:15
I used to own a korg D8 multi tracker, but again had to sell it to get the FX6. I sold it cos I thought the FX6 would be the ideal all in one package. But reading varying posts on this site I'm having doubts wether I should have sold or kept the D8. I'm quite impatient and thinking the loading time of the Fantom might start to grate a bit over time.
The D8 was basic but had a great sound and it had digital co-axail and spdif in outs. Anyway I do think midi in and out is essential for syncing start/stops of songs etc and also I'm going to use my RM1x for drums and bass and then layer the FX6 over the top then my electro acoustic and vocals to finish. I have listened to the motif es rack and I was impressed with the sound quality. So maybe again another road to go down.
Thanks again for everyones input, it's much appreciated. ;-)

BTW Bassman, one of my old bandmates had a Tascam 2488 which was used to record the band I was in, I have to say that is a really great bit of kit. Now if I had the cash I would definately get one.

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

18 May 2007, 05:35
Hello everybody,

this is my first message on this good forum (even if I'm a long time roland's fan,..since 1986 with my old baby S-50).

Well
,...I've just bought a fantom X8 after selling my yamaha motif es 8 fully expanded,...yes,..I did this!
why?,...
first at all,..
the piano sucks!,..even if you have the PLG 150 AP,...

so solitary man,...if you want a multitrack recorder with a keyboard like the motif,..ok,...you will have plenty of good effects, the possibility to layer sound with their own effect,...ok,...but listen to the samples, without effect,...mm,...not very different from your x6,..check it,: yammi says 175 Mb of rom,...??? ok??? why so short loops? what about the violins??? unusable, megavoices?...unsusable in a mix,...sound, too,.."preset",..the synthesiser,...as good as roland,..well,..yes distorsion effet is beautifull,..ok,..and than?

secondly,...have you noticed how easy it was to work with you fantom? how good was the ergonomy? how good clear is the manual?
compare it with the motif,...you will cry .

so man,...if you just want to use cool preset,..ok,..go for it,...but if you have the habits to program your own sound deeply ,...I think you will be upset with
this,..hum,.." beautifull keyboard".

I used to record my midi/audio track with the motif es ,..it was really good,..but it tooks long time ,...and I was unable to overview my whole song within the tiny screen,..yes I know, the fantom is not as large as a 20" computer,..ok,...but it's better than alpha-numeric .

after 1 year of hard working with this anti-ergonomic things,..I gave up,...

My advice should be this : keep your fantom,...the sounds are as good as the motif es,it has just to be tweaked a bit to avoid them to sound like the xp80,... and but can go further if you like synthesis.believe me

buy a motu MKII, it is small and good quality sound card,..it doesn't cost a lot,...than open a multitrack recorder onto your computer,...and use the capabilities of your fantom to go further than the yammi's,...

it will be as good

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

18 May 2007, 09:22
Hi Mister ludo,
The only reason I don't get a soundcard is because my P.C isn't that good. It's a 2.6 celeron with 512mb ram and only a 40 gig hard drive. Music eats up lots and lots of hard drive space and the celeron is a slow processor so this is why I don't want to go down that route. About 6 months ago I did toy with the idea of getting a E-mu 0404 soundcard but when I told the sales assitant in the music store I had a celeron he adviced me against buying it as I would need to up grade my P.C first to get the best out of a soundcard.

In the cold light of day I have come to the conclusion to keep my FX6 because it is a fantastic synth, sampler workstation and the fact it took me ages to save up for it, I had to sell some nice modules, grooveboxes as well to come up with the dough to pay for it. I remember when I sold my Moog prodigy in the early nineties for next to nothing cos I wanted a new guitar, I REALLY regret that one, so I will definately keep the FX6.
I did think about getting a Motif ES6 when I was looking at the Fantom but was really pissed off that the Motif has to be upgraded so you can just use digital in/outs how tight is that of yamaha not to include it on the basic model?

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

18 May 2007, 10:12
what's wrong with 8 audio track recorder on FantomX ,
I don't get it. Why to buy another recorder, isn't that duplicating hardware?
So, is the fantom X recorder quality much worse then BOSS?
just curious

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

18 May 2007, 10:30
While I can imagine better arrangements, for now, the Fantom X's audio tracks are serving me quite well ...

Don't even notice the loading times ... eight minutes for EVERYTHING? I just turn the Fantom on eight minutes or so before I'm going to use it.

At some point I will move beyond the Fantom's audio tracks ... but for starting songs or songs that emphasize live playing rather than overdubbing, it works just great, IMO.

The thing I like about having everything in ram is that once everything is loaded, you never have to wait again no matter how often you change songs. I think this is more a consideration for live use. I rather have to boot it up and wiat and have instaneous song changes than the other way around.

Sure, Roland can improve the audio tracks with the next gen ... but I think they are highly useful now (and no other sub-8k workstation has them ... sorry Fusion's are mostly a bust, IMO.)

But there does come a point when the Fantom won't be able to handle a super-complex project ...



. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Roland Fantom X7, Alesis Fusion 6HD, Novation X/A-Station 25, Alesis Micron
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: Comparing audio tracks to stand alone multitrack recorde

18 May 2007, 10:44
Instead of buying a Boss BR600 why not get a good used Roland VS1880 or VS1824 online from a reputable Ebayer instead?

The Roland VS series recorders will give you way more flexibility and longer term satisfaction than a Boss BR600, not to mention better quality sound (slightly).

Even though you can bounce tracks to free up more tracks on a standalone recorder it really sucks after a while with just an 8 track recorder. It's MUCH MUCH nicer having 16 or more tracks available at once.

Always get something that you can grow into. It may cost more upfront but will save you in the long run.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X