JUNO-G

Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

11 May 2007, 19:14
I am planning to buy a synth, Thinking of the Juno G w/o any SRX card, I found a used Fantom S61 w/ an SRX card installed.

Which one would you buy if they go for the same price?

A brand new Juno G or S w/ 1 SRX card installed from the owner?

The only thing I know about the differences is S supports up to 4 SRX cards where G only one

Re: Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

11 May 2007, 22:00
S vs. G


S: has the trigger pads, more SRX expansion but less sample memory expansion if you have more than 2 cards installed, I believe, multisample capability, pattern sequencing, bigger screen, better keybed (with aftertouch), skip-back sampling

G: has audio tracks and 128 polyphony vs. the S's 64, a few new samples the S doesn't have but essentially the same soundset, no MIDI thru, supposedly sounds better than the S ...

It's kind of a tough call ... what's the SRX card that comes with the S?

The polyphony advantage of the G could be important ... for instance, doing what I do, I'm not sure I could manage with 64 ... the audio tracks are also nice ...

There was a time when I would have said ... used S all the way ... now I'm not so sure ... if you can do without creating your own multisaples and the pattern sequencing, you might just be better off with the G ...

the Fantom-S might be better constructed (and heavier) but depending on how time has treated it, it could be a wash or even advantage new Juno-G.

HOW WILL YOU BE USING THIS KEYBOARD?



. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Roland Fantom X7, Alesis Fusion 6HD, Novation X/A-Station 25, Alesis Micron
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

G Does it all

12 May 2007, 12:47
As per Diametro ... Also:

I *believe* the G does "it all" ... but not as indepth as some of the Fantoms. I honestly think its nearly impossible to go wrong with the Juno-G if you're willing to work at some creative workaround solutions while composing symphonies.

For example: I don't think I enjoy my "SRX Analog Essentials" as much as "SRX Orchestra" and G only has one slot for SRX ...

So I might duplicate/create necessary SRX patches into my 1GB flash card (which you must buy separately). Then I'll swap for the venerable SRX Orchestra card.

Based on my 'beginner' observations it works at least moderately well as a *recording studio* for 4 audio tracks (hence no need for my old Tascam 224 r.s.).

Also, G prevents you from having to buy anything else; it is a fully operational DAW (workstation) (with or without Cakewalk Sonar LE). I think Diametro might agree I'd be 'wasteful' to expect a better DAW until I've understood the G or Fantom more fully.

Be prepared for a long journey (e.g., 4 months / an hour per day) to understand Juno-G or Fantom more fully.

Re: Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

12 May 2007, 14:19
It comes with an SRX-07 Card, ultimate keys I believe that is.

And I am just a beginner with SYNTHs.. I have been playing arranger keyboards and now want to spent some time with the SYNTHs

One thing I forgot to mention was that Juno G also has a 512MB RAM and 1GB CF card installed.


The Fantom S has 128MB smart media and 128 Mb ram installed in addition to SRX-07

I can have these two keyboards more or less the same price..

Re: Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

12 May 2007, 15:36
Well here's my 2 cents. Looking at this from a simple perspective if you are going to need or rely on the workstation as a all one solution, the Fantom S is probably a better choice. Since your just beginning with synths, I think the Juno G working with a computer based DAW is the way to go, and since your going to have a learning curve, this would be the way to go IMO. You said the Juno G has a 512MB RAM and 1GB CF card installed. I think this is a plus for the Juno G. To me the polyphony issue between the two would be a big deal as it favors the Juno G. Lastly the only drawback is the one SRX slot on the Juno G. But I think in your case the Juno G is way to go.

Re: Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

12 May 2007, 17:17
Yeah, just get the Juno G and if you need more sounds, hook the Juno to your computer and get some real high quality sounds. Then you can play through your computer with something like "EastWest" or other software programs that blow most SRX sounds out of the water anyway. (At least for the Orchestral stuff).

Re: Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

12 May 2007, 17:24
philip,
just read your post and I get the impression that you think you can put a srx board into the juno g save all your favourite patches to CF card uninstall that card put another srx board and then do the same again. this is not the case you can only use patches, waveforms on an srx board if it is installed. once you take it out all those patches, waveforms are lost.
If I have got you wrong then I apologize. 8-)

Re: Brand new Juno G or Used Fantom S w/SRX card

12 May 2007, 17:45
Solitary man is correct.
You can't copy patches from an SRX card. The necessary waveforms reside on the SRX board and can only be accessed with the board installed.

Bassman
Bassman

← Back to JUNO-G