JUPITER-80

Physical Modeling (This is cool)

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

16 Feb 2013, 15:11
Dany wrote:
A) - If your opinion is based on a thorough 1:1 comparison-test under studio conditions, then I will accept and respect your own opinion.

B) - If you never did a thorough 1:1 comparison-test under studio conditions, then all your above comments are nothing but polemic nonsense without any serious fundament.!!!

Sorry man, but my answer is B).... ;)
I don't understand the reason of defending the thing with such a passion. If you want, you can hash the GT as much as you can. I just don't want to be the one making false statements that the JP-80 is a better synth than the GT (in terms of sound synthesis) when it isn't. Don't get me wrong, I really think the JP-80 is a great synth! If I didn't, I wouldn't follow this room... right?

Sorry man, but my answer is A. I've tested both GT and JP-80 under studio conditions (used the same amp and headphone that I use with the V). As for the Moog, I have it... I also have the V-Synth GT if you didn't get it. :)

Cheers!

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

16 Feb 2013, 15:19
Why are we even having this debate? They are different beasts with different strengths and weaknesses. By the way, this particular forum is supposed to be about the JP-80, not the V-Synth.

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

16 Feb 2013, 16:10
Dewdman, I think you have a point. I know it's not a V-Synth forum, but I thought the discussion would be nice.

I'll stop my comments... it isn't worth the debate. Unfortunately almost everyone will take it as a "personal" attack when it isn't... I don't understand the fanatism people have with their gear, but I'll respect that.

To all of you to know, I can say bad things about the V too... for the VA part, the Access Virus TI just kicks it's butt really hard. It is true... what can I do? Will I trade my GT for it? Maybe... I still don't know. Do I think the GT is great?? YES!!

Cheers!

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

16 Feb 2013, 16:33
I fully understood your comparisons and the gist of the thread did kind of lend itself to these discussions since it was about modeling, but sometimes it is the wording used that stirs up the hornets nest Igor. This thread was NOT only about VA!

Saying that the Virus "kicks the V's butt" was uncalled for. Saying that the extra oscillators and the VA modeling on the Virus "sound better" to your ears would have suited fine and perhaps not kicked up so much dust.

Can the Virus do Elastic Audio with a Time Trip and can it sound like a real violin or erhu as well with AP-S? So the Virus is a great VA synth. That is what it is designed for. The V-Synth strength's aren't just in the VA world.

And the same for the Jupiter-80.

Respectfully,
.:':.DH.:':.

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

16 Feb 2013, 19:06
IgorCristo wrote:
I don't understand the reason of defending the thing with such a passion.
I didn't defend anything and just meant, that your subjective opinion about the sound of the JP-80's and V-Synths oscillator, which you didn't compare 1:1, but just by memory, isn't objective and of any meaning.

I did play the GAIA, the GT and the JP-80 side by side for several hours and I would never state such things like you. I cannot understand how one can think that the GT's oscillators are better sounding than the JP's or vice versa. But to claim that the JP-80's oscillators are similar sounding to the GAIA's oscillators is really completely absurd...

But OK it's your own opinion. I just wanted to add my opinion as well...

Too much harmony and understanding is boring, so I don't think some arguing in this thread is hurtful... ;)

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

16 Feb 2013, 19:22
IgorCristo wrote:
Dewdman, I think you have a point. I know it's not a V-Synth forum, but I thought the discussion would be nice.

I'll stop my comments... it isn't worth the debate. Unfortunately almost everyone will take it as a "personal" attack when it isn't... I don't understand the fanatism people have with their gear, but I'll respect that.

To all of you to know, I can say bad things about the V too... for the VA part, the Access Virus TI just kicks it's butt really hard. It is true... what can I do? Will I trade my GT for it? Maybe... I still don't know. Do I think the GT is great?? YES!!

Cheers!
Hi Igor, long time no speak :-)
I don't think the comparison is totally fair, as they are completely different machines anyway.
I agree that the Virus is maybe a more elaborated VA than the V, but the V is one of it's kind, capable of doing things that no other can, like SW mentioned, the AP-S, the VariPhrase, the Time Trips, the Step Modulator and very good ARP section, and all of them together, infinite possibilities.

Maybe I'm a little biased by the fact I own a XT (not the GT...), but still the V is a super Synth with some features beyond the reach of other competitors.

abs,
paulo
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

17 Feb 2013, 11:03
This is my final statement in an explanatory way… I'll follow this post answers, so feel free to argue.

@Dany
I received your message… :)

I had the GAIA and played with it quite a lot. I never stated that the JP-80 sounds like the GAIA… what I said is that the JP-80 sound is closer to the GAIA than the V. If I said that it sounds like the GAIA it would be quite an absurd.

There's a second thing that I think it's really lame in JP-80: it's not exacly possible to create a single tone using filters in parallel. In the other hand, you have a lot of great extras too, like UNISON and WAVESHAPE. What I don't understand, in comparison with the GT, it's the static tone structure. Wouldn't it be great to use the filters in a more freely way?? The same goes to envelopes. This static structure, makes you stack something like 3 complete polysynths with a single OSC in one tone… I think that a 3 OSC polysynth tone would be better.

Soundwise, all this isn't really a problem, since the JP-80 can sound HUGE! My point was to exalt this structure problem, so as the weak oscillator basic waveforms. It sounds thin…… this was not my opinion before going analog. I'm not saying that analog synths rock and digital ones doesn't. What I'm saying is that in comparison with Nord Lead 2x and Virus TI, the Roland's oscillators sound thin, being the V the best sounding one.

I think you have a valid point when you commented about my test. I'll stick with my opinion, but it's a smart observation.

PS: It's really a shame that the JP-80 lacks with some oscillators parameters that the V has, like FAT and the Feedback OSC sound (wich is GREAT!).

@ Soundworld
I understand what you said about "wording". It's true… this is why I'm explaining my points. This thread was NOT only about VA but I posted only about it. The other thing that must be said is that I don't use the V mainly as a VA, but more the Elastic Audio side of it, wich is irreplaceble and can't be done with any software.

At the VA side, the Virus really shines in comparison… it was not a smart choice of words but the point is that it really is a more capable and better sounding VA. The OSC are better, so as filters, modulation routings, and a lot of other things. The problem with the V is the aliasing of oscillators and stepping of the filters, wich can be annoying sometimes, and are less noticeable in the Virus family. They're two different beasts and my objetive is to compare only one small side of the V, since it's also able to make the most amazing vocoder sounds, incredible sample handling and a lot of other things like processing external signal in a very special way.

The V-Synth family is a very special and unique kind of synthesizer and so is the JP-80. I was comparing a small portion of them with other gear that recreate better an analog circuitry.

"Can the Virus do Elastic Audio with a Time Trip and can it sound like a real violin or erhu as well with AP-S? So the Virus is a great VA synth. That is what it is designed for. The V-Synth strength's aren't just in the VA world." :)

@ PauloF
Hi Paulo!
My answer to your thoughts are explained above. The Virus is programmed better than the V in the VA department, and that was my only point. Quoting myself, "for the VA part, the Access Virus TI just kicks […]". They are indeed different machines, that would compliment each other in a very special way.

As for live usage, the V it's amazing. The real-time controls are the best I've ever used in a synth, and that's a special thing about it. The Virus on the other side is a full knobbed synth with some great possibilities to tweak on the fly.

In conclusion, if I could, I'd have them all! Since I can't (because I'm planning on getting a Prophet 08 and am now buying a Moog Minitaur), I'll stick with the V.

Cheers!
Last edited by IgorCristo on 17 Feb 2013, 20:24, edited 1 time in total.

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

17 Feb 2013, 11:54
I prefer to think of the JP-80 as a Rompler+, rather than a VA synth-. hehe. I don't think Roland was setting out at all to compete with a Prophet or Virus. Perhaps they were trying to bring back some of the Jupiter-8 legacy, but clearly they were building a stack meister more than anything.

The main advantage of the JP-80 is that is has all the organs, rompler sounds and everything else you'd want, plus a pretty freaking decent synth section. Do the OSC's sound as good as real analog? Of course not. You should buy a Prophet or Moog if you want that. But compared to other romplers that are loaded with such a wide variety of PCM based sounds, the synth on the JP-80 is lightyears ahead.

It also has the ability to stack sound like nothing else I have ever encountered before. Back in the 80's and 90's I used to do that with an expensive rack full of synth modules and midi spaghetti everywhere. If the VA OSC's on the JP-80 are a bit thinner sounding, and I'm not saying they are because I haven't tested it against anything and I don't plan to, but if they are...its a moot point. You can stack up so many layers of sound that any thinness may even be an advantage rather than a disadvantage for that kind of purpose.

The only wish list I have for the JP-80 synth section is that they would open up some modulation routing possibilities a little more then is there right now. They have put in the ability for many OSC's to make sound at once...each with its own control section, but each control section is a bit simplistic by today's standards in terms of modulation routing. You get 3 partials in a "tone" and the ability to use them to modulate each other seems a bit limited to me. You can only layer final tones to get complexity. Its a bit like having a rack full of Jupiter-8 modules that you can layer together, but keeping the basic synthesizer tone capabilities of the JP-8 simple with 3 partials and simple control section. It does actually do some things more than the old Jupiter, but I feel they could have done even more and it really would have opened up a lot of sonic possibilities with this keyboard.

However, it still is capable of making some very huge sounding pads, strings, brassy synth sounds, etc...just by layering things up, and you can layer percussive sounds with string attacks and VA synth filling in all the goo and make some actually very amazing sounds through layering....so this is what the JP-80 is designed to do and does it well.

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

17 Feb 2013, 12:02
IgorCristo wrote:
This is my final statement in a explanatory way… I'll follow this post answers, so feel free to argue.

@Dany
I received your message… :)

I had the GAIA and played with it quite a lot. I never stated that the JP-80 sounds like the GAIA… what I said is that the JP-80 sound is closer to the GAIA than the V. If I said that it sounds like the GAIA it would be quite an absurd.

There's a second thing that I think it's really lame in JP-80: it's not exacly possible to create a single tone using filters in parallel. In the other hand, you have a lot of great extras too, like UNISON and WAVESHAPE. What I don't understand, in comparison with the GT, it's the static tone structure. Wouldn't it be great to use the filters in a more freely way?? The same goes to envelopes. This static structure, makes you stack something like 3 complete polysynths with a single OSC in one tone… I think that a 3 OSC polysynth tone would be better.

Soundwise, all this isn't really a problem, since the JP-80 can sound HUGE! My point was to exalt this structure problem, so as the weak oscillator basic waveforms. It sounds thin…… this was not my opinion before going analog. I'm not saying that analog synths rock and digital ones doesn't. What I'm saying is that in comparison with Nord Lead 2x and Virus TI, the Roland's oscillators sound thin, being the V the best sounding one.

I think you have a valid point when you commented about my test. I'll stick with my opinion, but it's a smart observation.

PS: It's really a shame that the JP-80 lacks with some oscillators parameters that the V has, like FAT and the Feedback OSC sound (wich is GREAT!).

@ Soundworld
I understand what you said about "wording". It's true… this is why I'm explaining my points. This thread was NOT only about VA but I posted only about it. The other thing that must be said is that I don't use the V mainly as a VA, but more the Elastic Audio side of it, wich is irreplaceble and can't be done with any software.

At the VA side, the Virus really shines in comparison… it was not a smart choice of words but the point is that it really is a more capable and better sounding VA. The OSC are better, so as filters, modulation routings, and a lot of other things. The problem with the V is the aliasing of oscillators and stepping of the filters, wich can be annoying sometimes, and are less noticeable in the Virus family. They're two different beasts and my objetive is to compare only one small side of the V, since it's also able to make the most amazing vocoder sounds, incredible sample handling and a lot of other things like processing external signal in a very special way.

The V-Synth family is a very special and unique kind of synthesizer and so is the JP-80. I was comparing a small portion of them with other gear that recreate better an analog circuitry.

"Can the Virus do Elastic Audio with a Time Trip and can it sound like a real violin or erhu as well with AP-S? So the Virus is a great VA synth. That is what it is designed for. The V-Synth strength's aren't just in the VA world." :)

@ PauloF
Hi Paulo!
My answer to your thoughts are explained above. The Virus is programmed better than the V in the VA department, and that was my only point. Quoting myself, "for the VA part, the Access Virus TI just kicks […]". They are indeed different machines, that would compliment each other in a very special way.

As for live usage, the V it's amazing. The real-time controls are the best I've ever used in a synth, and that's a special thing about it. The Virus on the other side is a full knobbed synth with some great possibilities to tweak on the fly.

In conclusion, if I could, I'd have them all! Since I can't (because I'm planning on getting a Prophet 08 and am now buying a Moog Minitaur), I'll stick with the V.

Cheers!
Hi Igor,
Thanks for the very comprehensive and detailed answer :-)
fully understand your thoughts and so both V's (V-Synth and Virus) are amazing then, each one on it's department ;-D
take care
Paulo
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

17 Feb 2013, 19:21
IgorCristo wrote:
This is my final statement in a explanatory way… I'll follow this post answers, so feel free to argue.

@Dany
I received your message… :).
...
...
...
Cheers!
What should I say, after such fair and balanced comments? I guess here at the clan, we will always end up in harmony and understanding... ;)

-

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

17 Feb 2013, 22:20
Blimey mates! We goes from this...[attachment: DC2.jpeg]

To this![attachment: DC10.jpeg]

Ain't it grand!![attachment: Awesome.jpeg]
Attachments
DC2.jpeg (8 KB, 1977 downloads) · file not available
DC10.jpeg (11 KB, 1977 downloads) · file not available
Awesome.jpeg (7 KB, 1977 downloads) · file not available

Re: Physical Modeling (This is cool)

17 Feb 2013, 23:05
SoundworldA.D. wrote:

Blimey mates! We goes from this...

To this!

Ain't it grand!!
ImageImage

← Back to JUPITER-80