Fantom-G
DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
9 Mar 2010, 09:53It's really funny seeing how "united" Korg and Yamaha users seem when it comes to selecting a workstation.
It looks as if there is a secret "complex" towards the Fantom-G. If the Fantom-G is so weak as a workstation, why everyone hurries to state something like "No, absolutely not the Fantom-G. Only the Motif XS and the M3 are good enough".
And I discovered the next joke of the decade: "Motif has the best orchestral strings"! LOL!
Has any of them checked the real potential of real orchestral strings inside the Fantom-G? Has anyone tried to make real, punchy, string attacks, marcato and staccato strings with the Motif XS?
I have used Yamaha keyboards in the past, I have used the Motif XS and what I have to say is that Yamaha keyboards always have had the weakest strings sounds. String pads maybe, but not big string orchestras.
This is really funny, I have nothing else to add really.
It looks as if there is a secret "complex" towards the Fantom-G. If the Fantom-G is so weak as a workstation, why everyone hurries to state something like "No, absolutely not the Fantom-G. Only the Motif XS and the M3 are good enough".
And I discovered the next joke of the decade: "Motif has the best orchestral strings"! LOL!
Has any of them checked the real potential of real orchestral strings inside the Fantom-G? Has anyone tried to make real, punchy, string attacks, marcato and staccato strings with the Motif XS?
I have used Yamaha keyboards in the past, I have used the Motif XS and what I have to say is that Yamaha keyboards always have had the weakest strings sounds. String pads maybe, but not big string orchestras.
This is really funny, I have nothing else to add really.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
9 Mar 2010, 10:26It is pretty obvious that peoples on a Roland's forum would dismiss the Yamaha stuff and that peoples on a Yamaha forum would argue against Roland's.
Look at the FG vs. Kurz thread right here. Same scheme.
It's like discussing about monitoring speakers. First answer will say how good Mackie are, second one will respond "No way dude, Yamaha !", and so on... And none of those answering have acoustic treatments
Only a general consensus for (or against) a specific product will give you usable information. If there was one about workstations (or monitoring), we shall all know. So there isn't, and you only have to decide for yourself about what are the strengths you're looking for in a workstation product, and what you could more easily dismiss without having big regrets.
Most of us have solved this very issue by stacking gears and some even filling gaps between gears with VST's.
Good luck!
Look at the FG vs. Kurz thread right here. Same scheme.
It's like discussing about monitoring speakers. First answer will say how good Mackie are, second one will respond "No way dude, Yamaha !", and so on... And none of those answering have acoustic treatments
Only a general consensus for (or against) a specific product will give you usable information. If there was one about workstations (or monitoring), we shall all know. So there isn't, and you only have to decide for yourself about what are the strengths you're looking for in a workstation product, and what you could more easily dismiss without having big regrets.
Most of us have solved this very issue by stacking gears and some even filling gaps between gears with VST's.
Good luck!
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
9 Mar 2010, 12:08I'm pretty content with my Fantom-G, along with my laptop and VSTs. It eliminates carrying a second or third keyboard onstage.
In my home studio, nothing could compare to the killer combination of the computer and the Fantom-G, the latter being tone generator, controller, scratch pad and more.
The only thing I envy from the other two is the Motif's DAW control and the M3's Karma processor. Nothing else really.
In my home studio, nothing could compare to the killer combination of the computer and the Fantom-G, the latter being tone generator, controller, scratch pad and more.
The only thing I envy from the other two is the Motif's DAW control and the M3's Karma processor. Nothing else really.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
9 Mar 2010, 12:23cyclpos: "It's really funny seeing how > Korg and Yamaha users seem when it comes to selecting a workstation"
Funny... maybe-). But surprising - definitely not.
It's normal to be like that - after all, Yamaha owned Korg in the past. And it owns something now too - if I'm not mistaking I think it's something related to Karma (or generally speaking: simultaneous arpeggiators - even Dan Krisher pointed that some time ago).
And they both have that thin and overprocessed sound.
Funny... maybe-). But surprising - definitely not.
It's normal to be like that - after all, Yamaha owned Korg in the past. And it owns something now too - if I'm not mistaking I think it's something related to Karma (or generally speaking: simultaneous arpeggiators - even Dan Krisher pointed that some time ago).
And they both have that thin and overprocessed sound.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
9 Mar 2010, 13:31"And they both have that thin and overprocessed sound."
Sometimes this is the sound I need. The Fantom G does take up a lot of space in a mix, making it a great solo instrument.
I own the XS, M3, PC3 and the FG. I love them all and they all find ways into the music I produce. They all have piano sounds and they all sound different, but then again every real piano I've ever played sounds different. Sometime the thin and/or overprocessed sound is just the ticket.
Which workstation is better is a poorly stated question. Which one fits my application or has the appropriate sound for a certain song is the real question.
I tend to prefer the M3 most of the time, but that because I using Karma, and I've had more experience with the Korg OS. But of course I can almost complete a song on the Fantom while the M3 is booting up.
The one thing the Fantom has the others dont is good looks, with that way hugh screen.
Sometimes this is the sound I need. The Fantom G does take up a lot of space in a mix, making it a great solo instrument.
I own the XS, M3, PC3 and the FG. I love them all and they all find ways into the music I produce. They all have piano sounds and they all sound different, but then again every real piano I've ever played sounds different. Sometime the thin and/or overprocessed sound is just the ticket.
Which workstation is better is a poorly stated question. Which one fits my application or has the appropriate sound for a certain song is the real question.
I tend to prefer the M3 most of the time, but that because I using Karma, and I've had more experience with the Korg OS. But of course I can almost complete a song on the Fantom while the M3 is booting up.
The one thing the Fantom has the others dont is good looks, with that way hugh screen.
Fantom G & X7, Motif XS6, M3, V-synth, JP8000, M1, Wavestation, Radias, Nord Lead 2X, Karma, Snow, electribes and other groove boxes.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
9 Mar 2010, 19:50I really really wish I knew alot about sound creation. When I hear people talk about have you done this... and have you created this type of sound... I really really wish I knew what I was doing rather than just changing numbers, guessing, and hoping it sounds right.
speaking of creating sounds... so we can only have 512 created sounds at a time on the FG?
speaking of creating sounds... so we can only have 512 created sounds at a time on the FG?
Can You Touch The Apex
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 00:15only?
512 are a lot of sounds.
512 are a lot of sounds.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 00:20really? would you buy the keyboard if it only had 512 presets?
come to think of it... i wonder how many people would buy a keyboard that had no presets, but an unlimited amount of user slots and hm... let's say the same wave rom as the FG.
i wonder how many people would buy that board.
come to think of it... i wonder how many people would buy a keyboard that had no presets, but an unlimited amount of user slots and hm... let's say the same wave rom as the FG.
i wonder how many people would buy that board.
Can You Touch The Apex
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 05:14I think that 512 user slots for Single and Live modes are more than enough. Those of you that complain about that, how many user patches do you have in your projects?
I think that the presets are so many that you can usually find most bread and butter sounds for everyday needs quite easily. If not, then you can edit some of them and bring them to your liking, or make some new sounds from scratch.
My only gripe is that there are some preset patches that have some issues, like that grand piano with wrongly set key range for one of the tones, plus so many badly programmed patches. I wish that I could fix some or all of them and save them back to those preset slots.
I think that the presets are so many that you can usually find most bread and butter sounds for everyday needs quite easily. If not, then you can edit some of them and bring them to your liking, or make some new sounds from scratch.
My only gripe is that there are some preset patches that have some issues, like that grand piano with wrongly set key range for one of the tones, plus so many badly programmed patches. I wish that I could fix some or all of them and save them back to those preset slots.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 05:59well...
then why Roland have made a new bank ( the I ) from the user bank of the first Fantom-X?
I have 9x 128 preset and 4x 128 user.
the user patches are NOT enough.
I had to make "split" patches with some samplings, to get more...
then why Roland have made a new bank ( the I ) from the user bank of the first Fantom-X?
I have 9x 128 preset and 4x 128 user.
the user patches are NOT enough.
I had to make "split" patches with some samplings, to get more...
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 08:19I don't think that the number of user patches could change.
The patch memory is given and fixed to a number of 512 slots for each of Single and Live modes.
That is something that everybody can be informed about when they are interested in buying the Fantom-G. So it's really annoying to see people complaining about stuff like that. It's like complaining about the number of MIDI or Audio tracks. This has NOTHING to do with things that are not known unless you buy the machine and work with it, like various bugs and issues.
The Fantom-G's technical data is open to everyone and clearly posted at Roland's website.
The patch memory is given and fixed to a number of 512 slots for each of Single and Live modes.
That is something that everybody can be informed about when they are interested in buying the Fantom-G. So it's really annoying to see people complaining about stuff like that. It's like complaining about the number of MIDI or Audio tracks. This has NOTHING to do with things that are not known unless you buy the machine and work with it, like various bugs and issues.
The Fantom-G's technical data is open to everyone and clearly posted at Roland's website.
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 11:30totally agree!
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 11:39no one is complaining at all!... at least I wasn't. You've not heard me really complain about much of anything on the FG.
I was just saying... I with it had more... Cause once I get good at making sounds I'd love to just make em... and just keep pumping them out.
I was just saying... I with it had more... Cause once I get good at making sounds I'd love to just make em... and just keep pumping them out.
Can You Touch The Apex
Re: DOES THE MOTIF XS SOUND BETTER THAN THE FANTOM G .
10 Mar 2010, 14:10I also wish that we could have some more user patch memories, like 1024 slots. But this can't change, so all we can do when we run out of user memories is start a new project. That's what I'll do when this time arrives.