Fantom-G

OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

23 Dec 2009, 12:38
MadaHorn, don't compare a kit car to a Mercedes, please ;-) You just don't know the difference because it's not in the numbers and names, it's in the sensation and experience. Maybe one day you'll understand. Five years ago I would tell the same as you just said. Glad my destiny put me right ;-)

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

23 Dec 2009, 12:51
Artemiy that's not fair...:-) lol

I still have lots of Roland gear and still love Roland products, alway will.

The Open Labs experience is very real! Imagine if you could run Native instruments Komplete 6 or Omnisphere on a Fantom -G...

That's what a product like Sound Slate brings to the table, the best of both worlds.
Jim Stout
www.jimstout.tv

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

23 Dec 2009, 13:22
Art: I almost decided to get a Mercedes not long ago...

Parts, repairs and Oil Changes TOO Expensive! ;-)

I do respect your opinion on the computer subject, none the less.

Mac's are Pretty! I'll tell you that...
www.songsforthemaster.com

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

23 Dec 2009, 13:28
Maybe not a good comparison then, so Mac is an Acura ;-)

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

27 Dec 2009, 20:38
Caution!! Before you invest your money in Open Labs, take some time to read about my horror story as an Open Labs endorsed Artist. I may be just one guy that had such an experience, but if they treated me like this, it's possible that they would do this again.

Truly,
Justin

http://blogs.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.view...

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

27 Dec 2009, 21:27
Oh no...Don't give Artimey any more ammo please... ;-)

Just kidding, of course...

But, it is too bad that you had this experience...

I am sure that is one difficult, complicated machine to support anyway.. (not to help Art out here)

I for one hope hardware synths do not go to the wayside!
But, the hardware companies are going to have to increase their support level as well.
www.songsforthemaster.com

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

29 Dec 2009, 00:20
In my opinion the problem has more to do with their proprietary software and hardware. I never had so many issues simply hooking up a midi keyboard to a fast computer.

But I invested in the technology because it was a much easier setup at my gigs then assembling all of the various components of my own set up. I'm actually considering just gutting my machine, ridding the OL hardware and software and making a fast computer and midi keyboard. It would be better than what I have.

You live and you learn. In this case I learned not to believe in the promises of Open Labs to send a new machine to me in order to make things right! The joke was on me I guess.

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

29 Dec 2009, 12:32
Hi justinstewartstl and welcome to Roland Clan!

I read about your ordeal with Open Labs, that is completely ridiculous and unacceptable behavior. I have to say, it looks really bad when one of the founders of a company gives his word to a customer and then breaks it in that way. I was actually considering trying out an Open Labs product in the near future. But, I have had bad experiences in the past with companies that felt like it was ok to sale me garbage and then treat me like crap.

Character, trust and knowing that I can depend on the word of the people I do business with is something I strongly take into consideration before I buy a product now.

Normally, I would take into account the possibility that your problems could just be user error. And I know a lot about computers so I would assume I could handle any problems myself and keep the machine running smoothly. I would also consider that this is your first post here on Roland Clan. And I don’t know enough about your character or how technically competent you are concerning music hardware and software.

But I have to say, just the fact that Victor Wong (Co-Founder of Open Labs) behaved in this ridiculous manner, is enough to strongly make me reconsider buying their products. It is possible that he gave the order to send you the new Neko and then his staff messed things up. Have you received any more info from him personally? I would like to think that they treat all their customers the same, no matter how famous or unknown. But this kind of thing gives me doubts.

Hey Jim, care to shed some light on this matter? A misunderstanding maybe? Though, given the info so far it’s kind of hard to believe it could be. But, I like to hear the story from all the parties involved before I decide what to believe.

Anyway....I feel your pain Justin.

Thinking about buying a Fantom-G maybe? If you are use to working with computers exclusively, it might seem a little restricted at first. But some of the restrictions help prevent a lot of the problems we have with computers (especially when playing live). However, if you used your Neko mainly to play the VST instruments live, I think the G will be great for you. Definitely one of the best live workstations out at the moment and extremely reliable. Just make sure you check it out at a store personally before you buy it. Take your favorite headphones and try to go when it’s quiet, maybe when they first open.

Also, keep in mind that the preset sounds are not the end of the story. Artemiy is an excellent sound designer and he sales awesome, unique expansion packs for the G. We also have a user community consisting of a number of talented Roland Clan members who designs sounds and upload them for free. You can also use your own samples and multi samples (if you have the time and knowledge). And Roland also sales ARX expansion cards, they add polyphony and new forms of synthesis. And the sound quality of the G is amazing! But, in any case, it might be a good idea to wait until after Namm before you buy a new board.

Enjoy the forum Justin.

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

29 Dec 2009, 18:21
Thanks for the response Z!

You are correct about the possibility of user error, especially with a machine that is basically a computer. I even questioned myself and wondered if there was something that I could be doing wrong. But the nature of what was happening that just didn't make sense.

It had nothing to do with to many vst's open at the same time. One was enough to cause it to lock up. It had nothing to do with to many different programs at the same time, one was also enough.

This last time they sent my Neko back after promising the new one was the final. There was a brand new problem. I would be playing one vst and the next thing I knew, it had gone completely out of tune by a half step!
I then restarted the machine and it was fine for about ten minutes, then did it again. That was using a piano vst in their software KARSYN. I brought it home and the next day I opened up Cubase and via midi connected it to my Fantom X6 that I still love so much, and it was causing the Fantom's sounds to go out of tune as well! And this is only ONE of the problems.

And as I stated in my summary blog on my Myspace page, it came down to them finally recognizing that there was something inherently wrong with my machine, and promising to replace it with a "brand new LX5", cause that was just the right thing to do. And then no further explanation to me whatsoever as to why they changed their minds. Trust me, from where I'm sitting it's like the freakin twilight zone!

I have worked with Open Labs for such a long time and have always been extremely patient as they tried to solve these problems, how could they just dump me and leave me hanging AFTER they made such a promise to me? It would have made more sense if they had done that before the offer of a new Neko, but not after.

And Victor has always been someone that I could contact. That was one of the great things that attracted me to them. I don't know what could have changed but I can tell you that they know that they messed up. And even after all of this if they came to me and just said hey, we're sorry you got lost in the shuffle or something, let us make this right, I would be cool with it. I'm not perfect, and I know people can make mistakes much bigger than this one here. The harm is not recognizing the wrong and making it right.

When I wrote to Victor and suggested that maybe I'm no longer getting the attention on this manner so I asked him to let me know how much they could give me for mine towards the purchase of a new one, that should have been an indication of how desperate I was to have a working machine. Looking back its easy to see that was foolish of me, but if they would've said that they would only give me a thousand dollars I was prepared to do it. Because I love so much the concept of what Open Labs had created. And for Victor to not even respond to me just makes no sense. But it was something that finally made me realize that they have written me off. Sad.

I am seriously considering gutting my Neko, and inserting a hardware synth, laptop computer and analog mixer. I may as well find a way to make the shell at least work for me. After investing thousands of dollars in this machine, imagine how tough thats going to be for me to take it apart!

But I know that I could create a much more stable set up in the new "FrankeNeko" with a good computer, interface, and hardware synth. Again, I honestly believe the ghost in my machine has to to with their proprietary hardware and software, and maybe even the touch screen!

And I will state for the record, I cannot imagine that this is happening to many people. I would be shocked if it were. If Prince's, or Maroon 5's Keyboardist had a problem, you could bet it would get solved. But the rest of us Open Labs customers are like me, regular guys trying to make a living with music. We are the most important people, but in my case they seem to have forgotten about that.

It's all like a bad dream that I can't wake up from. If I was a rich man that could afford to drop $7,000 and forget about it, it might not affect me this way. Instead I'm a brand new Father at 43, with a new house and responsibilities on my shoulders like never before. And instead of smoothly moving from one gig to the next, I'm spending much time trying to figure out what rig I can piece together today. Trust me it sucks. But at least I'm working more than ever!

Thanks again for the response.
Justin

By the way watching this video of how someone else customized their Neko gives me some hope. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRrhHgmyjLE

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

29 Dec 2009, 18:36
First child at 41, second and last (I hope) at 43 on Dec 7th. Little Ella (a singer I hope ;-))
So, I know how you feel.

Was your Neko, by chance, totally not taken care of...dirty, dinged up or abused?
Hey, that sounds like a bad date doesn't it? ;-)

Anyway, did they feel you abused your machine in anyway?

If not, that is a real shame. They should at least fix the problem for you.


Hey...that ultra customized Neko looks pretty cool! I wonder if that voided the warranty? LOL
Art should be happy also since that made it a MAC!!!
www.songsforthemaster.com

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

29 Dec 2009, 19:46
After having read all posts I must say that I don't really understand why people are spending more than $ 4000.- for a keyboard or (electronic instrument).

I personally would never spend more than this ($ 4000), because it's just not worth. Have a look at KORG Oasys the same thing, too expensive for what it is at the end (a bunch of electronic components :-).

For the $ 7000.- you have spend you could have the Fantom G, a Laptop, Cubase5 and more if you want and you would be more productive.

Please don't kill me here, these are my opinions and I have put my limits for my own sake. This was so far good for me and my wallet :-)

OPENLABS products are PC's on which they have added a keyboard (simplistic I know but true). Now just think about how these products will be old in some years! Today duocore and tomorrow optocore! Nobody will pay you anything for an old "PC" with keys, won't you?
But a Fantom G will still have value on the market. Even the old MC 303 is around $ 200.- in the second hand market. But what will be the price of a Openlab single core, 1 GB Ram, etc "Keyboard" without any synths (VST) on it?

I have just some time ago replaced my PC (Musicworkstation) with the latest components for around $ 1500.-.

Personally Openlabs don't make sense to me anyway and I would never buy anything then I don't like it for the reason I said above.

An advatage with a laptop is that you can play Tetris during your journey to your next gig. LOL Has any body played Tetris or Solitaire on a NEKO and this in a plane? You will have a lot of new friends if you are unpacking your NEKO in the plane, won't you? ............

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

29 Dec 2009, 23:07
No, the condition of my Neko was never in question. They wee able to see all three times that I had to ship it back to them.

And I can also understand how some folks could think that they cost a lot, but for me the "convenience factor" is huge. I can put together the same kind of system, but to be able to just unplug and pack away is a great thing. I don't want my band to be able to set up their instruments and our PA while still waiting on me to secure firewire and usb cables!

If I didn't also DJ between my sets it wouldn't be as necessary to have a computer, but that's also what I get paid to do. I've also become quite fond of using soft synths like Omnisphere and Real Guitar and wanted to use them live.

And lastly the thought of working on a project at home on cubase, and then being able to transfer that easily to stage was another reason for such an expense. Ultimately If I didn't do this for a living there's no way to justify it, but whatever I buy is just a tool of the trade.

But also remember, OL markets their products as ones that will actually do what it says it will do. And others are working just fine. I got a lemon, or a wooden nickel. This really isn't reinventing some grand technology. If a six year old Dell in my studio can do all of these things without locking up, I think it is a reasonable expectation that their products should be able to do the same.

The new Fantom is quite a beast of a synth, and I will never have to worry about it flaking out on me either. That's why the thought of gutting my machine and installing some sort of hardware synth i sounding better to me. But it's more money and much more work of course. We'll see.

Madahorn, MUCH respect to you! My Olivia is nine months old and is quite a handful. I can't imagine two. But I can imagine double the joy that they must bring you. Though I still thank GOD for Granny. ; )

C'ya
Justin

One of the latest, most recent weird issues.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsPc6Prsacg

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

30 Dec 2009, 06:13
@ Justin

yes, I understand your needs and thoughts but here an idea :

Why wouldn't you just sample the Onmisphere sound into the Fantom G?

I am pretty shure you won't program in the dept your sounds live. For me in live situation I need a finished patch/sound, so there is no reason for me to have Omnisphere or other VST on stage. I only need the sound that's it.

As for your DJ situation (for your info I am also a DJ) just this:

I would prepare the set and play it traditionally (vinly) or with MP3. You can also use Ableton LIVE for this and integrate/record your own performance. This way you don't really need Omnisphere live. If you feel the music ready for a solo part so why not using a sampled omnisphere patch on the Fantom G. After your solo you can switch back to LIVE and let the track continue on your laptop/PC.

This is my way and convenient for me, so just my thoughts and why doing it complicated if you can do it more easily. So, just an idea nothing more.......

Cheers

Re: OPen Labs SoundSlate..Shown With Fantom G..Sweet

30 Dec 2009, 06:19
Atziluth, that's exactly the way I'd do myself.

← Back to Fantom-G