Fantom-G

VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 16:43
I think the ARX format is flawed ...

Why only two slots? Too much heat, size or expense?

The cards themselves seem too expensive and narrow focused ...

If Roland can't put multiple instruments on one card, perhaps they shouldn't have bothered ... At $400 a pop, that's pretty damn pricey for a one-instrument enhancement ...

It's great the user has such control over the sound parameters ... but if you're playing live, is it really that paramount?

I'd rather have multiple GREAT-sounding instruments with a more normal level of programmability ...

..........

That said, I'd be looking for a VA board as well as an multitimbral orchestral board ... (however, all that really could be covered by great samples ... )

But honestly, I think the whole ARX concept as its being implemented is making me scratch my head ... none of it so far makes me want to embrace it in any way ...
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 16:43
Why in a world one would want more guitar sounds? Call your friend next door and he will play you guitar all day- no need to take a room on 3k$ keyboard. If some one needs guitar sounds that bad0- may be they should considering taking some lessons to play guitar.

4-part virtual analog synth, with an engine similar to the SH-201

• 1-part virtual analog synth, with an engine similar to the VA portion of the V-Synth

• 16-part/128-voice ROM depository with a wide variety of orchestral patches

• 16-part/128-voice ROM depository with a wide variety of electronica/urban patches and kits
• 16-part/128-voice ROM depository with a wide variety of vintage keys/synth patche
3-part TR-808, TR-909, and TB-303 emulation with authentic interface and TR-style step sequencer
• 4-part LA synthesis board, similar to the VC-1 card

• Voice modeling board, similar to the VC-2 card

I would also have the Choirs expansion the way they had it for JV series.

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 16:49
delete this please

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 17:05
ARX is wayyy too expensive to be consigned to single instrument modeling.

It promised much more.

the key elements that made it promising was

Extra poly
more mfx routing
eq etc...

however
to wrap all this up in a single instrument is a waist of a slot and a lot of money..
Roland is simply doing what it does best..

Milking the cow for all its worth and its working...

Stop dreaming

these wish lists are now a waist of time and simply give roland Idea`s and market research for the next features to include in the next product the make you buy more.

Im all for communication..
but its all one way..

Just like working for a big corporation...
Proposing lots of new ideas and methods so they get all the benefit you receive no return and pay for it in the process..

If you line up roland products synths to workstations on a time line and list every single feature of all of these..

As time goes on you will notice while on one end of the scale the next product gets new features, on the other end features that already existed are dropping off every time.

Im not interested in a card that is single instrument based, we can already achieve all this either with the X or the G
What we want is cards that advance the G not add what is already possible.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 17:22
Wow. I actually sorta agree with Quinnx.

Yeah, I don't personally see the advantage of a board that just adds one type of sound. But more to the point, I don't see a lot of people spending $400 on a board that just adds one type of sound.

A multitimbral VA board would not only add significant value to the G, but it'd be the type of feature that might convince others to buy a G in the first place.

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 17:26
Diametro:
Why only two slots? Too much heat, size or expense?
Heat, power, and most importantly, channel routing. The G has 64 parts. If it had four ARX boards, the thing would need 96 parts. Perhaps the engine is simply limited to 64 parts.

That makes me wonder how a G rack would work. If the engine is capable of 64 parts, would a G rack have three ARX slots (16 internal, 16 x 3 EXP)? There'd obviously be no need for external parts.

Of course, it'd also need four physical MIDI in jacks. Hmm...

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 17:34
I'd go for these:

• 4-part virtual analog synth, with an engine similar to the SH-201
• Voice modeling board, similar to the VC-2 card

...plus an option the get a "SRX (plus more) Sound Library" on DVD as mentioned earlier by CYCLOPS.

Sounds like a great idea! If Roland cannot (or don't want) to do it: [dream mode] make it an OPEN SOURCE PROJECT! [/dream mode]

Shrewd Salut!
srut, but...
shrewd-salut!
SRUT, BUT...

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 19:00
Here's what I'd like:

• Something else entirely? If so, what?
- 16-part SuperNatural Ethnic instruments. Accompanied with Non-Western scales and SMF rythms to go for inspiration I would love it.

I would buy it right away.

• Voice modeling board. VariOS/VC-2/VP-770 style.
It would have to be awesome and something I could actually use for background vocals and creating some new exciting sounds.


- - - then some wild ones - - -

• Something else entirely? If so, what?
- 16-part SuperNatural UNNATURAL. Take the modeling technology and make it possible to do the impossible. Glass violins, 30 meter guitars, piano made of brass, a wooden trombone. Make that be musical.

• 16-part virtual analog synth
I was kinda looking forward to something like this, but didn't want to wait so I got an Oberheim OB-12 (4-part) to work in conjunction with my Waldorf Blofeld (16-part). They make a wonderful trio with the G. I also have the JP-8000 which I love (2-part)

• Something else entirely? If so, what?
- SuperNatural Orchestra. Full 16-part orchestra, in 5-6 years when technology and the ARX tech reaches it's peak, a complete übercard with the whole symphony orchestra in SuperNatural mode.

In all I must say I rather see the OS developed than any new ARX cards.

Cheers! Gin & Juice.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 19:22
• 1-part SuperNatural B3 Organ with the G's sliders as drawbars

• 4-part virtual analog synth, with a new VA engine
Roland Fantom G6 (2), G7, VK-8M
Korg M50, CX3

The G has 64 parts.

23 Jan 2009, 20:54
Taw:

This is something i have been pondering recently regarding the limitation of midi standard and so on..

We have a limited external mixer which only give us another 16 channels..

but realistically external channels could be Unlimited across the entire MIDI standard..

I say this because every midi gear generally has an ID number which can be changed.

So why not tag this ID to every message be it note on/off CC pitch bend etc..

You can still use your standard multi track sequencer

Midi channels can still be 1 to 16 but utilizing Midi Thru etc..
all gear could conceivably use the same 16 channels but are separated by the ID number. (As far as im aware they already do this for SysEx)



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 22:08
I'd love to see an ARX devoting all of its DSP resources to effects processing for freely configurable, massively multiple instance effects -- a sort of Eventide H series plug-in, Roland style.

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 23:07
Quinnx, that is an really interesting thought.. We are having a big discussion about that here with my friends..
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 23:45
asynchro_nous , now thats one good idea- I was thinking about that too

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

23 Jan 2009, 23:49
Ludvig, I checked out the site.
yeah I hope not too but why not have a third party do the arx.. like them

Re: VOTING TIME: What Future ARX Boards Do You Want?

24 Jan 2009, 08:35
Quinnx
Midi is slow.
Adding an extra byte to a Midi message would increase most messages by a third.
The designers thought that speed was such an important issue, in particular for note timing, that they developed Running Status to reduce the messages by one byte, to 2 bytes in most cases.

Then Microsoft came in some 20 years later and killed off Running status in their driver spec, as they knew better.

I'm not sure that you can add an extra addressing byte without speeding up the transmission speed and the various attempts at this haven't got very far
Over the years Midi has been often criticized for changing the feel due to timing resolution. Adding the byte is possibly not the solution.
The XV5080 had 2 midi ports and 32 tracks as I recall.
How about an extra couple of Midi ports in the USB driver

← Back to Fantom-G