Fantom-G

Fantom G Piano Sounds

Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 03:40
Howdy, folks.

Am I the only one who isn't too thrilled with the Fantom G piano sounds? I am a Fantom X7 owner with the SRX-11 piano expansion board. And I think the SRX-11 sounds better than any piano on the G.

Is there a way to import a better piano sample? I saw a post on here where someone was trying to import the Yamaha S90ES VST piano into the Fantom. Is that even possible? I'm a Mac user, so some of the utilities (YASE, Extreme Sample Converter) mentioned in this forum won't work for me.

I'm torn between buying a Fantom G and a Motif XS. The XS has great bread-and-butter sounds (piano, bass, guitar, drums), but the G is a far superior workstation. I just wish it had better piano and orchestral sounds. I'm sure Roland will come out with a fantastic Piano ARX expansion board someday. The synth sounds are rockin' on the G, but I also need real instrument sounds.

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 04:05
Hi there. Maybe the Fantom-G pianos aren't the best around, I don't know about it, I haven't worked with Fantom-X so that I could compare their piano sounds. What I know now is that the Fantom-G has double the sample RAM capacity, so that you can load the piano samples of your liking, that will overcome the quality of the Fantom-X pianos. ;-)

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 05:02
I am extremely disappointed of FG's pianos. The sound, the feel, the velocity.

Since I've downloaded "AC NY Grand 8" sound from user based Roland Fantom-G Sound Archive - I am using it. It's much better than the factory sounds, though not perfect...

Thank you - anonymous creator of "AC NY Grand 8"! :)


http://fantomg.navarin.de/index.php?cId=2

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 06:00
spybar: that's my favorite piano sound, too. For my taste, it's better than the piano that I've uploaded (Grand Piano - by cyclops). It's warm on low dynamics and bright on high dynamics. It uses very well the onboard piano multisamples. :-)

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 06:21
Just a newb question:

How can I use this mid into fantom?

Load as a song or have samples somewhere on this site...


Thank you!

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 06:36
lisandro: you can transfer any sounds in MID form with the help of the Fantom-G editor. Once you have connected your Fantom-G with the PC, you open the editor and perform a "File->import SMF" command. You choose which sound to import into the editor, and once it's been loaded, it's automatically transfered into the Fantom's temporary memory. It's not been saved yet. You can play it, decide if you like it, and then you can save it to any user location you like.

Piano / Organ Sounds (pressure)...

9 Nov 2008, 08:19
the piano sounds are bad quite bad at ALL:
Reason: the basses are ok (left two actaves, middles are all bad, high tones are well too)
Somebody sad to me before buying: choose another brand for playing live - the sounds of these new rolands are not that pressureful as you may expect; like JV880,JV1080,JV2080...
He´s right! no chance to tell me something else.
When you play alone or you are recording something; maybe ok after modifying in sequencer; BUT playing live its over all a bad feeling to play in a group with other musicians.
Also really BAD is the organ section! since 20 or more years the act is to rebuild a B3 or Vox Continental or or or. But what has happend? the sounds are that bad as from beginning of reproducing these in the 80s. 20years late! Shame!

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 10:10
The Piano sounds Roland uses have a well known midrange problem especially in band context, which is clearly audible in the Fantom X, the otherwise nice SRX 11, and now in the G. But it is not "that" hard to get it under control in band context. Use a tweaked New York Grand 8 from the G (like that from the online user banks) and use a typical "british" midrange eq like you find it on Mackie and other mixers for basic midrange tuning, and you should get by in band context.

As for B3 organs, the task seems more complex than you think. I just heard an old B3 'lady' from 1955 with it's Leslie in Big Band context (WDR radio big band, one of the top big bands worldwide), and it sounded as gorgeous as one can imagine. One hour earlier David Sanborn's keyboarder (with the Paris horns as brass section, so in similar context) used the Nord organ, which is able to produce some more grit and bite than other clones. But in direct comparison it still was worlds apart from the real thing.

The sampled B3s in the G now at least offer some basic useable sounds (which was not the case with the Fantom X and still hard with the help of SRX 07). Some Fantom solutions offered and offer nice pseudo-drawbar-funcionality with the G sliders, but their weakness is the basic wave material used, which just is not up to the real B3 sound, and the result sounds quite artificial despite good programming.

So the G is a small step forward with some of its organ sounds, but the only real answer to the problem can be a dedicated clone, the better of them capturing around 90% of the real B3 sound (Leslie, vibrato and overdrive modelling are still not close to 1:1 on *any* of them). There you have plenty of choices, like external gear (I use the Creamware B4000 in the Plugiator) or in a possible future ARX card which I guess will come sooner or later.

So you should really be able to solve that problem as well, and even a better sounding Korg workstation B3 sound is no comparable solution to one of the better clones.

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 12:55
"Use a tweaked New York Grand 8 from the G (like that from the online user banks) and use a typical "british" midrange eq like you find it on Mackie and other mixers for basic midrange tuning, and you should get by in band context.


Jimknopf - I would like to learn a little bit more about these settings. Are you talking about using a Mackie console witha preset or are suggesting to emulate using like-wise settings? What makes British eq?

TIA,
John

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 13:43
understand Jimknopf words! sure, youre right.
But: wouldn´t it be nice to provide such a softwaresolution as Native Instruments B4 for example? sampling/software/display/sliders/knobs would provide a lot of room at fantom G´s!? the basics are there I say... that´s what i mean too. perhaps there will be an B(6-8)?;-) as ARX...
perhaps later, as a internal IC, which let us play such a sound as used in NI B4 in Rolands structure "from beginning"...

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 14:02
NTulsa,

on many mixers you found and find the classical 3 band 10k, 1k and 100hz EQ knobs or the like. The term „British EQ“ goes back to a certain sound design in the 70s (Rupert Neve and others). Neve consoles and later Mackies focus on certain frequencies which are regarded by many as “more musical”. Technically this just means that some lower mids and mids are influenced more/other than usually. I don’t know the technical details, but I know I get fast results with any simple 3 band VLZ line Mackie mixer in non-expensive everyday use.

A more sophisticated approach offering much more control is using a parametric EQ. But you have to know what you do using it: more skill and more time. That’s not so easy because you have more parameters in dynamic relation to each other (shifting through different basic frequency spectrums while adjusting EQ amounts *carefully*).
So if I have the impression that lower piano mids are too resonant and muddy in band con-text I just try to use the simple three EQs on my Mackie mixer (especially taking down the middle one in this case a bit, but also having a view on the other two in relation) to get better results. I was always surprised how well that worked, despite being such a minimal tool. You could route your G Pianos to Output B for such a purpose, not to influence the other sounds.

P.S.
No need for others now to tell me everything about twenty band EQs or proper use of parametric EQs ;-)

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 14:05
VintageOrganPlayer,

"But: wouldn´t it be nice to provide such a softwaresolution as Native Instruments B4 for example?"

Yes, sure, but that can't be done within the G concept: you need an ARX-board or an external module for that.

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 16:34
>P.S.No need for others now to tell me everything about twenty band EQs or proper use of parametric EQs ;-)

Heheh, ok but... actually, John Oram (Trident desks) claims to be the father of the British EQ, not Rupert Neve, who is a genius nonetheless.

I've got myself an 'British EQ' in form of an Toft audio ATC-2 (design by Malcom Toft) back at the studio. It is very nice and useful.

Anyone interested in this topic could google these. Here's a pic of me trying the ATC-2 out for the first time. We ended up getting that unit + and Joemeek TwinQ (it has a nice Iron mode).

Image

Now back to the pianos and the leslies. I hooked up the G to my (real) Roland JC-120 front panel today, in mono, and ran some Rhodes trough the JC-120 famous Jazz Chorus. It was a bliss. Simply nothing like running the G trough your regular monitors.

No-one is stopping anyone from getting a real Leslie and hook it up to the B outs of the Fantom G and have a real leslie going on on those patches that need it.

I must say thou, I am not either that impressed by the Fantom Gs organ/hammond sounds. I think it has mostly to do to the COSM effects than the sounds themselves, but I haven't really dwelled into the organ sounds yet, as there has been no ska/reggae type of projects where I could find use to them personally.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: Fantom G Piano Sounds

9 Nov 2008, 17:40
Yes, the Tridents are famous, but I never had the pleasure to see or use any, and even Neves only from one or two studio glimpses. I could hardly afford such stuff.

The main thing is that you can do a lot with what is already there on the G, at least concering piano and B3 sounds (with brass I have my doubts). And my example just points to totally affordable everyday gear helping you to get a suitable live sound.

Concerning B3 sounds, I can't imagine anyone relying on the very narrow choice of useable ones on the G while carrying a Leslie around: that would really be funny :-)

But what works *much* better than the two not convincing Roland Leslie sims in the Fanton X and the Fantom G, is a device which does the Leslie job better than any other purely electric sim: a Hugh & Kettner Rotosphere II with a built-in tube preamp.

Or if you prefer a half mechanic solution, the German Reussenzehn Birdie Cabinet is something nice.

Concerning Rhodes sounds, my Fender Blues Deluxe Reissue did the trick of coming close to classical Twin sound in a more transportable tube amp unit.

All in all: plenty of choices to make the best of the G sounds.
Still, the soundset should be improved in a future major upgrade...

← Back to Fantom-G