Choosing a Fantom for Live Playing
16 Feb 2008, 13:14I am a 20 year gigging musician. Even though I've had extensive use of studio sequencers, I've always used old school gear for my live playing. Recently, I took the plung on an all-in-one-board for my live show. We play dance-hip-hop-disco-pop. I spent exhaustive time with the Rolands, Yamaha's, and Korgs. Money was not an issue but I wasn't going spend more than what was necessary. In other words, I'd of been happy with a Yamaha MO6 or Juno-G if they would do the job. Cut to the chase: I've got a shinny new Fantom X6 on stage now. I should also add that I am one of the lead singers so a board that is fast and stage friendly is critical for me.
I actually bought all the front leading keyboards and used them for the 30 day return period. I gigged with them as well. After month 1, I kept 4 and continued my eval for another 30 days. For a while, I toiled between the lower priced boards vs the pricier ones. Next, I pulled my hair out about the decision between the Yamaha ES and the Fantom x.
Let me say this, if you gig with only a handful of sounds, all bets are off for this evaluation. There are many choices to be had from the leading brands. I would suggest going with the brand who's sounds you like the best. (The more you spend within each brand, the better the sound quality despite the claims of the advertising for the lower price boards. Pricier sound patches which generally utilize more memory for greater detail blend better and are more usable live.) However, if you're going to make extensive use of voices, layers, sequences, automation, etc. it's a much tougher choice. The issues of organization and recall become just as important as sound. For example, if you've got 100 great presets but you can't get to them in a live show, then they do you no good. Based on navigation and sound, Yamaha and Roland became my early front runners. Yamaha has better classic sounds out of the box, the Fantom has better Hip Hop out of the box. I could really get either board sounding fantastic so sound wasn't a big determining factor. Both boards have robust navigation - just different. In the studio, I would take the Yamaha because you can get to so much stuff so fast and the sequencer controls are much more extensive with more buttons on the face panel. However, I would need to accompany the Yamaha with extensive notes and a good lighted area. And, I don't mean notes on how to use it, I mean notes on musical content and presets. Also with the Yamaha, you need to change your eye view a lot. For example, screen to buttons and back again. Or, take your eyes from the set list or screen to the group buttons, to the part buttons. That's a lot of eye movement on a dark stage with small unlit buttons.
On the other hand, the Roland thrives on the stage. With a little work, you can have a custom set by set screens with notes and the accompanying presets. That makes 1 nicely lit screen to lay your eyes the whole time. Plus, patterns and sequences can be easily mapped to keys and pads - all easily accessed - mid song even. Here is the myth or misunderstanding about the Fantoms: that you must do a lot of clicking - not true. From each set or bank window in Live Setting, my presets are 1 well lighted click away at any given time. (sometimes 2 if you're using 9-16). The mixer is 1 lighted click away. So, each patch can lead you to a full stage friendly mixer where you can change or adjust sounds. I regulary click between solo synths and keys on the fly mid song and mid solo - even if I have patterns playing! Yes, you use the 4 scroll arrows and value dial to get around the mixer. But, you can easily do it in the dark which is very convenient. Plus, a little forethought and you can arrange your mixer so that live sounds are just a click or 2 away in the mixer. Also, the Fantom lends itself to deeper automation and 'programming' so that extensive changes can be made mid song with sysex commands. If your a gigging player, the notes screen on the Fantom is an amazingly useful tool. Seeing as the Yamaha's and Rolands are both great, this feature along with the programmable soft function bottons are enough for me to choose the Fantom over other keyboards. (Soft buttons are buttons who label is presented on screen and can change with the 'scene', bank, or set.) It's not an obvious benefit at first.
To sum it up... in the studio give me the Yamaha ES for it's extensive navigation and sequencing controls (For non-commercial use the Roland sequencer is workable too.) On stage, give me the Fantom for extensive stage friendly features and automation power. Both of these decisions are absolutely clear cut for me.
I actually bought all the front leading keyboards and used them for the 30 day return period. I gigged with them as well. After month 1, I kept 4 and continued my eval for another 30 days. For a while, I toiled between the lower priced boards vs the pricier ones. Next, I pulled my hair out about the decision between the Yamaha ES and the Fantom x.
Let me say this, if you gig with only a handful of sounds, all bets are off for this evaluation. There are many choices to be had from the leading brands. I would suggest going with the brand who's sounds you like the best. (The more you spend within each brand, the better the sound quality despite the claims of the advertising for the lower price boards. Pricier sound patches which generally utilize more memory for greater detail blend better and are more usable live.) However, if you're going to make extensive use of voices, layers, sequences, automation, etc. it's a much tougher choice. The issues of organization and recall become just as important as sound. For example, if you've got 100 great presets but you can't get to them in a live show, then they do you no good. Based on navigation and sound, Yamaha and Roland became my early front runners. Yamaha has better classic sounds out of the box, the Fantom has better Hip Hop out of the box. I could really get either board sounding fantastic so sound wasn't a big determining factor. Both boards have robust navigation - just different. In the studio, I would take the Yamaha because you can get to so much stuff so fast and the sequencer controls are much more extensive with more buttons on the face panel. However, I would need to accompany the Yamaha with extensive notes and a good lighted area. And, I don't mean notes on how to use it, I mean notes on musical content and presets. Also with the Yamaha, you need to change your eye view a lot. For example, screen to buttons and back again. Or, take your eyes from the set list or screen to the group buttons, to the part buttons. That's a lot of eye movement on a dark stage with small unlit buttons.
On the other hand, the Roland thrives on the stage. With a little work, you can have a custom set by set screens with notes and the accompanying presets. That makes 1 nicely lit screen to lay your eyes the whole time. Plus, patterns and sequences can be easily mapped to keys and pads - all easily accessed - mid song even. Here is the myth or misunderstanding about the Fantoms: that you must do a lot of clicking - not true. From each set or bank window in Live Setting, my presets are 1 well lighted click away at any given time. (sometimes 2 if you're using 9-16). The mixer is 1 lighted click away. So, each patch can lead you to a full stage friendly mixer where you can change or adjust sounds. I regulary click between solo synths and keys on the fly mid song and mid solo - even if I have patterns playing! Yes, you use the 4 scroll arrows and value dial to get around the mixer. But, you can easily do it in the dark which is very convenient. Plus, a little forethought and you can arrange your mixer so that live sounds are just a click or 2 away in the mixer. Also, the Fantom lends itself to deeper automation and 'programming' so that extensive changes can be made mid song with sysex commands. If your a gigging player, the notes screen on the Fantom is an amazingly useful tool. Seeing as the Yamaha's and Rolands are both great, this feature along with the programmable soft function bottons are enough for me to choose the Fantom over other keyboards. (Soft buttons are buttons who label is presented on screen and can change with the 'scene', bank, or set.) It's not an obvious benefit at first.
To sum it up... in the studio give me the Yamaha ES for it's extensive navigation and sequencing controls (For non-commercial use the Roland sequencer is workable too.) On stage, give me the Fantom for extensive stage friendly features and automation power. Both of these decisions are absolutely clear cut for me.