Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

28 May 2007, 10:43
Hey Clan,

I've been lurking for quite some time (since I picked up my X7 around Christmas time), and this group has been a very educational experience for me!

I've run into a problem I can't seem to find a solution to... I'm sure the wise folks here can show me the light... or at least tell me that I'm barking up the wrong tree.

I'd like to be able to record (real time) several different 'takes' of a single part in the sequencer. That way I can pick the best one, or edit together a 'best' from the various takes.

I've got a Yamaha AW2816 that uses 'virtual tracks' to accomplish this, but I'd like to do it in MIDI on the X7 rather than in audio on the AW2816.

The only thing I can come up with is to keep 1 track (track 1, for example) as my 'best takes' track and use tracks 2-16 as the 'takes'. I could then pick and choose the best take and 'Track Edit/Exchange' the best take onto track 1. Basically I'd build the song using the 16 channels in track 1, and use all of the other channels and tracks as 'scratch' tracks, ultimately to be muted later.

Thing is, this seems a bit overly complicated and counter-intuative for what shoud be a fairly straightforward task. I hope that I'm missing something and there is an easier/better way.

Thanks in advance for any input!
~Gary

Re: Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

28 May 2007, 11:27
Hi gspencer

I believe you have just awnsered your own question ;-) but I just don't see why you find it complicated. There are no "virtual tracks" in the sequencer so you're doing it right since you're limited to 16 tracks. Just use the Pads to mute/unmute the relevant tracks if you're not doing so :-)

Re: Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

28 May 2007, 17:53
The very reason we record stuff in MIDI is so that you DONT have to do this....
with Step/note editing and such you can change MINUTE parts of the sequence until it is just the way you want it...

Now the AUDIO TRACKS...that is something totally different!!!!

With those....you could, for instance, record 8 different takes of a guitar solo and THEN edit them into one FINAL take....
I am not sure how long it will take though

Keep Makin Music!!!!!
T.R.I.C.K.M.A. Entertainment 2007
http://www.myspace.com/trickmaseang
Keep Makin Music!!!!!
T.R.I.C.K.M.A. Entertainment 2007
http://www.myspace.com/trickmaseang

Re: Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

28 May 2007, 21:44
Thank you both for your reply!

V-CeeOh: I was afraid I was going to already know the answer... at least There is a workable solution. I guess it isnt THAT bad... but you know, always looking for a simpler way!

BigBrotherMotown: I would agree with you 100% if I was trying to 'nail' a particular riff or something... but that isn't quite the case. I guess I should have explained what I was trying to accomplish.

I've got a great rhythm going in this new track, and I'm playing around with the lead. I'm looping over the same 16 bars and tweaking the lead on each loop... Every once in a while, I hit something awesome and I'd love to be able to keep going to the end of the loop and know that I got that bit saved. Then switch to a new 'virtual track', and improv the lead again.

Once I had a few variations laid down, I could pick and choose the parts that worked best. More of a compositional tool than anything.

Hope that makes more sense now... and thanks again for the replies!!

~Gary

well in that case....

28 May 2007, 22:30
I suppose you could use LOOP recording in MIX mode to keep adding those guitar parts. You can do this on a MIDI track or an AUDIO track (I believe). Then when you wish to stop you just hit the stop button and switch to another MIDI or AUDIO track...You can compare what you have after the fact....

Be CAREFUL about loop recording though....It will AUTOMATICALLY add newly played MIDI data to the OLD midi data....unless you have assigned the parts to Different Channels you WON'T be able to separate them later....


Hope this helps

Keep Makin Music!!!!!
T.R.I.C.K.M.A. Entertainment 2007
http://www.myspace.com/trickmaseang
Keep Makin Music!!!!!
T.R.I.C.K.M.A. Entertainment 2007
http://www.myspace.com/trickmaseang

Re: Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

29 May 2007, 08:24
I've been sequencing (midi) for many years, and have had two workstations (now an X8 - love it). But I allways use software (Sonar) as the sequencer platform. I find the sequencers in the workstations to be too restrictive and tedius. And I think that's what you're finding. You probably know that with software sequencers you can set up to loop (with perhaps your bass and some rhythem going), then just close your eyes, get in the groove, and keep recording take after take to the track of interest - without touching a button. The sequencer will save each take. You'll know whrn you have it just right, or you can play all your loops if you like and pick the best one. Can a workstation sequencer even come close to that?

Good luck
kelsoz

PC 2.4 mHz / 768MB / XP SP3 / E-MU 1616 / Sonar PE 8.53 / Roland Fantom X8 / Event ASP6 monitors

Re: Sequencer - Recording multiple takes?

29 May 2007, 10:11
Kelsoz, I think you are right... the hardware sequencer just can't compare to the flexibility of software.

Thanks all for your suggestions and input!

~Gary

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X