JUNO-G

Just about to buy a Juno G

Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 12:00
Hi everybody,
I am in the market for a new synth, and need your advice.

Right now i have a 88 key m-audio prokeys. Not the top of the line but a decent keyboard. It has weighted (to some extend) keys, but the inbuilt sounds are very limited. Also very hard to take to studios and gigs.

My new instrument should have good sounds, lightweight, and allow me to record my songs without touching the computer. My budget is limited to 1000$.

Today, i lost a killer deal for a mint condition fantom S and i am very frustrated right now!

So the big questions are :

1)Will a juno G allow me to record my songs without using any computer. I also play guitar and i should be able to record guitar tracks on this machine too.

2)I am mostly interested in acoustic sounds, because i play blues and smooth jazz kind of stuff. I know that the sounds in this machine is good into some extend, but does adding a SRX card improve the sound quality in a higher degree?

3)We are in a roland forum, and i am sure that most of the people here will say that juno g is a good buy for the money, but please tell me about the limitations in the long run. Especially for songwriting, and recording area.

Thank you for reading this, and i am waiting for your input.

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 13:08
Hi,
I think the juno g is a great buy. IF you want portability, great compliment of sounds, 4 audio tracks, sequencer etc, oh and it's very light so if you gig then it's definately worth a look.
Soundwise the juno g is geared towards synth type sounds for dance, techno, hip hop etc but you can add 1 expansion board which would have to be SRX07 ultimate keys IMO.
If you goto to www.rolandus.com you can watch a demo of someone recording via the audio inputs and also shows you other aspects of the juno g.
The downside of the juno g as apposed to the FANtom X anyway, it only has 1 expansion bay, the keys are shorter, you can't multi sample.
The sequencer is only linear which means you can't record patterns, which is what put me off the juno g so I got a Fantom X. But saying that it does have a great sequencer and you would not have to go near a P.C to aid your song writing process unless you wanted to up load all your songs to the P.C for storage.

The top and bottom is the juno g is a great synth. the sounds are awesome, has a great sequencer with 4 audio tracks.
Make sure you check out the demo on the roland website I think it will make up your mind one way or the other.

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 14:10
If you're into acoustic sounds ... you might be disappointed by the G ... there just aren't as many as you'll find on the Fantom X ...

If you do get the G ... then SRX-06 is your must-have SRX card because it contains better/different samples of all the orchestral instruments/grouping.

The solo strings is good, too, but its more focused and doesn't include things like woodwinds, vocals, percussion, etc.

Personally, if you can swing it, get a Fantom X. If you're planning on having this for awhile, eventually you'll regret not having the pattern sequencing (trust me, it's useful on so many levels; you WILL use it eventually) or multisampling capability ...

But if you have to move your board around ALOTt (the X7 and up are beasts in a hard case) or on a tight budget and can't wait, the Juno-G is a Fantom X all the way in the most essential areas (sound engine, effects section, basic functions of sequencer/audio tracks).

However, I think you may come to regret getting the G when you start realizing all the little things the G can't/won't do: MIDI THRU, 1/4th SRX expansion, no aftertouch, no pads (one of my favorite Fantom features ... 1/2 the audio tracks ... smaller monochrome screen ... ) ... no digital in/out ... average keybed vs. class-leading on Fantom ... and last but not least, the Fantom's great piano.

Many people have sold their Gs to get an X ... I've found the other way to be more rare ... However, it's not inconceivable either to go X-->G as they are mostly compatible (aside from some diferent waveforms) and the G is seriously more portable.

However, I find 61 keys terribly limiting for a solo performance where multiple splits and layers are required ... In a band setting, 61 keys probably works a little better.

The G also wouldn't be a bad second board eventually ... Or you can save the money and use it to buy a Virtual Analog like a Korg R3.

However, really, all you need is an X.

I'm finding that out more and more ... it's really the only board I use all the time ... I'm actually thinking of putting my other keys away (or even selling).


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Roland Fantom X7, Alesis Fusion 6HD, Novation X/A-Station 25, Alesis Micron
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 16:30
1)Will a juno G allow me to record my songs without using any computer. I also play guitar and i should be able to record guitar tracks on this machine too.

Yes, you will able to record up to 4 audio tracks directly with the juno. You will also be able to use onboard effects (up to three inserts, shared by all tracks).
You will have to buy a 512 MB SIMM to expand the RAM, and a card (up to 1 gig) to save the samples/audio tracks.

2)I am mostly interested in acoustic sounds, because i play blues and smooth jazz kind of stuff.

Sounds are very nice, but do not expect the realism of a higher-class workstation. You can buy a SRX card: I never listened to them, but opinions are generally quite good. Anyway, they are expensive AFAIK.

3)We are in a roland forum, and i am sure that most of the people here will say that juno g is a good buy for the money, but please tell me about the limitations in the long run. Especially for songwriting, and recording area.

While the sequencer is perfectly usable, it is of course very boring to do fine editing (for example, change single notes and so on) on such a small screen and without a mouse. If your main target is songwriting and hd recording, I can't understand why you don't want to use a computer.

I find that the Juno-G is wonderful to sketch ideas, because you can easily do quick multitrack midi and audio recordings, and to prepare material for live performances, because you can assign samples to the keys or add audio snippets to songs, but if serious hd recordin is your main target you'll have to do a lot of fine editing... both audio and midi, and believe me, that requires a bigger screen, a graphical user interface and a mouse, in other words: a computer.

What's more, a Juno-G plus 512MB of RAM plus an SRX card is almost the price of, say, an Alesis Fusion 6HD... with 8-track hard disk recording and 40GB hard disk!

You say that you don't want to use a computer, but what will you do when your 1GB card is full? Ok, you can buy another card... :) But 1 GB is not that much... it is very much if you just have to include audio loops or sounds in your song, but not that much once you have to record one or more complete audio tracks (voice, a couple of stereo guitars...), so you will have to switch cards frequently, then you'll have to wait several minutes to load the audio tracks from the card to the memory every time you load a song...

I like the Juno-G a lot, it's a nice synth, but if HD recording is what you need, in my opinion you can't use a Juno... use a PC, or, if you really don't want to use the computer, get a workstation with real hard disk recording, like the Fusion 6HD (I have never tried it, so be sure to check before you buy, don't just rely on my poor advice!).

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 19:04
With all due respect to the previous posters suggestion ...

DO NOT get the Fusion for its HD recording ... believe me .. I have one ... especially if you want to use small bits of audio ...

It's really just a mess ...

Even though the Fantom is slower to load, it handles audio much more elegantly (as long as you can handle the paradigm that ALL samples must be loaded upon startup ... Takes about 10 minutes ... no big thing.)

The Fusion definitely has its strengths ... but even though it has HD audio recording, it's fairly clear the audio track portion was added late in the development process and hence not implemented well ...


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Roland Fantom X7, Alesis Fusion 6HD, Novation X/A-Station 25, Alesis Micron
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 19:20
Listen to Diametro! DO NOT GET THE FUSION for the the HD recording. What a mess it can be. I used to own the 6HD, and that emphasis is on "used to".

Squeak

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

26 Apr 2007, 19:34
Thank you for all the valuable input, and as i am new to the roland clan, this has been a warm welcome for me :)

Just want to clear some points:

I won't use the sampling function so lack of multi sampling is not an issue for me.
Having only one SRX slot is limiting for sure, but it seems that i won't be able to afford multiple SRX boards either :(
4 audio tracks is more than enough for me, (one for acoustic, one for electric guitar and one for vocals)

And here are my concerns:
Lack of pattern editing
Average keybed
not so great piano and acoustic instruments

i am not an audiophile or a gear freak. i really like to use a clean and easy user interface, and i should be able to take this board with me to the bedroom or to somewhere quite and be able to record or play in seconds. i don't like to use a computer because i find the sequencer applications etc. too complicated. (don't ask me my job, i am a software engineer with an engineering of electronics degree)

Anyway, i watched the videos from the roland site while the guy records his song, but i have a question about that. The guy is recording only one section of the song. What happens if i want to write a song like with 3 different sections, plus intro and ending like this :
intro A A B A ending? is the sequencer flexible enough for me to build the whole song from beginning to the end?

I listened to the SRX card demos, and for my taste, and musical styles SRX 7 (ultimate keys) and SRX 3 (studio for especially acoustic guitar sound) seems to be better choice

So, in the end with all these preferences and limitations should i continue searching an alternative or buy a juno already? I sure want to buy a real fantom, but i am afraid i won't be able to afford one.

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

27 Apr 2007, 05:19
Thank you for all the valuable input, and as i am new to the roland clan, this has been a warm welcome for me :)

Just want to clear some points:

I won't use the sampling function so lack of multi sampling is not an issue for me.
Having only one SRX slot is limiting for sure, but it seems that i won't be able to afford multiple SRX boards either :(
4 audio tracks is more than enough for me, (one for acoustic, one for electric guitar and one for vocals)
Those 4 audio tracks can be stereo what is a very big plus.
And they timestretch to a tempo among other things. :)
And here are my concerns:
Lack of pattern editing
Yes... it's unfortunate but you will be able to make phrase repeats via copy function. Slower but it works.
(but still having patterns would be fantastic...)
Average keybed
Action is pretty decent actually but size is smaller.
You can use an external midi keyboard of course. I'm using Roland A33 at home which is great.
not so great piano and acoustic instruments
Piano is passable especially in an arrangement. I like electric (especially distorted) guitars much better than those ones in MotifES.
i am not an audiophile or a gear freak. i really like to use a clean and easy user interface, and i should be able to take this board with me to the bedroom or to somewhere quite and be able to record or play in seconds.
Quality wise Juno-G is on the same level as full Fantoms are. J-G's interface in some ways is more straightforward than in F-X (keyboard split funtions, faders for audio tracks, faster undo, GUI doesn't have graphical bloat thankfully)
i don't like to use a computer because i find the sequencer applications etc. too complicated. (don't ask me my job, i am a software engineer with an engineering of electronics degree)
It's perfectly ok to consider software sequencers to be too complicated. What are worth all those possibilities which are soft DAWs are offering when someone wish only just to record songs/ideas?
Anyway, i watched the videos from the roland site while the guy records his song, but i have a question about that. The guy is recording only one section of the song. What happens if i want to write a song like with 3 different sections, plus intro and ending like this :
intro A A B A ending? is the sequencer flexible enough for me to build the whole song from beginning to the end?
Yes as it's a fully capable linear sequencer and it has things like markers, insert/delete/copy measures functions, alternate time sig/tempos change capability, loop functionality, manual/auto/punch/step recording, grid editor for arps and drum patterns.

The real one omission is lack of pattern sequencing which can be substituted by copying measures thought it will not be as fast nor convenient.
I listened to the SRX card demos, and for my taste, and musical styles SRX 7 (ultimate keys) and SRX 3 (studio for especially acoustic guitar sound) seems to be better choice

So, in the end with all these preferences and limitations should i continue searching an alternative or buy a juno already? I sure want to buy a real fantom, but i am afraid i won't be able to afford one.
What are other choices?

Korg Triton TR is nice sound wise and has great arp but in other aspects it's way behind Juno-G. Doing audio in TR will be very limited when compared to the J-G.
(not talking about antique EDO ram for it and need to buy custom sampler expansion module from Korg)

Yamaha Mo6 doesn't have any audio/sampling capability thought has the same 175MB PCM waveset as MotifES.
Hard On!

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

27 Apr 2007, 06:18
Well, if the Fusion is so bad and you don't want to use a PC, then I agree that the Juno is the only choice...

The sequencer is complete, you can do whatever you want with it. No other workstation under $1000 will give you the functions of the Juno. The user interface is easy and well done, the instrument is light and portable.

I still think that, once you learn even the basic function of a sequencing software, the time you will save will be 1000 times the time you will spend to edit songs and audio on the Juno (and on every other workstation).

But if you really want a keyboard that you can carry anywhere, and where you can plug an instrument and record, well, that's the Juno-G.

Anyway, Sonar LE is included with the Juno.

I don't agree with people that say that sound quality is the same of a Fantom. It has the same synthesis capabilities, and it has very good sounds, but it has "only" 64 MB of samples, so for example the piano is not the same piano of the Fantom at all. Anyway, the sounds are good, very nice and usable. Competitors are not better: the MO sounds thin even if it has the same wavetable of the Motif (low quality converters?), the MM6, well... people say it sounds good, but it lacks any advanced feature. The Triton LE is BAD (IMHO), the TR is not so bad but still lacks audio tracks. So I think that the Juno would be the best (if not the only) choice.

If you play blues, you'll appreciate the B4Real emulator (look in this forum), which is not bad at all. It is a series of patches that emulates the drawbars, so you can achieve better hammonds than what you can do with the presets.

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

27 Apr 2007, 08:28
For the record, the Stereo Piano patch from SRX-07 is really good, so buy a Juno-G + SRX-07 and be happy.

______________
Juno-G + SRX-07
Sao Paulo - Brazil
______________
Juno-G + SRX-07
Sao Paulo - Brazil

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

27 Apr 2007, 12:34
Hello kaanengin, and welcome to the Roland Clan.

I'll pipe in concerning lack of Pattern recording. .

“Anyway, i watched the videos from the roland site while the guy records his song, but i have a question about that. The guy is recording only one section of the song. What happens if i want to write a song like with 3 different sections, plus intro and ending like this :
intro A A B A ending? is the sequencer flexible enough for me to build the whole song from beginning to the end?”


I come from an Ensoniq background. Ensoniq probably had the absolute best Pattern recording capabilities of any workstation out there; far ahead of its time. So I was a die-hard Pattern guy when it came to putting songs together. I've given mini-tutorials in a couple of threads here at the Clan to assist in Pattern recording on the Fantom X.

All of that being said, after becoming quite familiar with my X6 now, I don't use Patterns at all. I simply use the linear sequencer and 'Copy/Paste' sections as I create them and go. It is by no means slower. . . . as a matter of fact, I can do this quite quickly now. The real advantage that I've found with this method is that it gives me the opportunity to hear the 'flow' of the song better as it transitions from one section to another. My application of drum fills and my arrangements have benefited from this.

I agree with others hear. . . . ffrom the choices available to you in your given price range, the Juno G is going to be your best choice by far. This is both a subjective and objective opinion. . . . . .

Bassman
Bassman

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

27 Apr 2007, 14:42
I can not tell how much i appreciate your help, you answered all my questions, and left me no choice but to buy a juno g as soon as possible :)

after all these discussions, it really seems that juno g is a perfect match for me. i know this is not the top of the line product, but right now i know that i can live with it's limitations.

i'll plug my 88 weighted key controller to juno, buy a ultimate keys srx card as soon as possible, and try to come up with some workarounds about lack of pattern programming.

again thank you all for the valuable afford you put here.

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

29 Apr 2007, 15:15
Have been reading this thread as I'm also considering a Juno G, much for the same reasons as the poster. I actually had a Fantom X6 when they first came out but for some reason I just didn't get on with it. I did plug away at it for a few months but ended up selling and bought a Korg Triton.

Anyway...got on really well with the Triton but eventually a house move forced a sale. Now I'm looking around for a decent keyboard under a £1000 and the Juno G caught my interest.

Just want to ask...can I definitly plug in my CME UF8 controller and use it with the Juno G....controlling patch changes etc? I had a look at the Yamaha MM6 but apparently Yamaha in their infinite wisdom decided to make it a real pain in the ass to control from an external device of any sorts.

Would apprecitate any feedback.

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

29 Apr 2007, 21:25
The Juno-G may lack a dedicated "pattern sequencer", but you have to keep in mind that it does have a "rhythm pattern sequencer". That alone sure as hell beats pecking out an entire drum track, or copying and pasting till the sun comes up. It's not so bad creating rhythm patterns and chaining those. Sure makes things a little easier.

Squeak

Re: Just about to buy a Juno G

30 Apr 2007, 05:19
Just want to ask...can I definitly plug in my CME UF8 controller and use it with the Juno G....controlling patch changes etc? I had a look at the Yamaha MM6 but apparently Yamaha in their infinite wisdom decided to make it a real pain in the ass to control from an external device of any sorts.


Absolutely! I'm using my Juno-G exactly in such configuration with Roland A33 keyboard controller.
Hard On!

← Back to JUNO-G