Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Fantom XA Comparison Question!

Fantom XA Comparison Question!

19 Jan 2007, 01:30
Hello,

I am thinking seriously of getting a Fantom Xa or Fantom X6 and had a couple quick questions.

1-Does the Fantom Xa have as good of a keyboard "feel" as my old Roland XP-60 did? (I just don't want to get a keyboard that has a real springy plasticy feel). Is the Fantom X6 much better in this regard?

2-Does the Fantom Xa have as good of piano sounds as the X6?


I would love to get the Fantom X6 but it's price is a little out of my range for now, and that's why I'm asking about the Xa. I don't need the audio tracks of the X6 as I already have a Roland VS2400 recorder. I also don't care about the sample pads that much either.

All I really care about is if the Xa has as good of a feeling keyboard as my old Roland XP-60 and if it has the same piano sounds as the X6!

Oh, I already have the new Korg TR61 keyboard and while it's great and all, it has just a bit too much of that light springy keyboard feeling I don't like as much as my old XP-60.

Thanks for any help!
Of course, the question of "good Feel" and "Good Sounds" are a subjective one. I personally think the keyboard action is quite poor, it does feel a bit plastic, but then again it all depends on your style. As for the Piano's, they are usable but you don't have the 88note Grand Piano that's in the X6,7,8 and Rack Version.

I like the synth and it's got some great pad/electronic sounds, but I control it from another keyboard and only use it as sound module...in fact I'm thinking of getting rid to get an XR...

Roland V-Synth
Roland Fantom Xa
Roland SH201
Roland D10
Alesis Fusion 6HD
Yamaha EX5
Yamaha An1x
Behringer DDX 3216
Roland VS880
Tannoy Ellipse 8 Monitors
Yamaha NS10 Monitors
Sony VAIO P4 3GHZ x2 19 Inch TFT
Roland V-Synth
Roland Fantom Xa
Roland SH01
Roland D10
Alesis Fusion 8HD
Access Virus TI Polar
Korg M3
Korg R3
Waldorf Blofeld
Yamaha An1x
Behringer DDX 3216
Roland VS880
Tannoy Ellipse 8 Monitors
Yamaha NS10 Monitors
Sony VAIO P4 3GHZ x2 19 Inch TFT

Re: Fantom XA Comparison Question!

19 Jan 2007, 11:37
Thanks magikroom!

I think I'd better save more pennies in my jar to get the X6 then.

Re: Fantom XA Comparison Question!

19 Jan 2007, 20:05
Buy a Juno G before you get an Xa. The key feel on the Xa is terrible- I tried it extensively. Very PSR. I owned an XP60 until recently, and it had some of the best key response / feel ever. The Juno G has slightly shorter keys, but they are much firmer and have a nice, choppy release- they're pretty satisfying once you get used to them.

As far as the X6 keys go,they're similar to the XP60, but the keys are still smaller. But, again, very nice.

Why in the hell did Roland downsize all of their keys?!

Juno 60, Juno 106, Alpha Juno 1, JX-305, Juno-G
Also: DX7S, TG-500, Kawai K1 and MG-1

Re: Fantom XA Comparison Question!

20 Jan 2007, 04:07
Good advice here. I'll stay away from the Xa for sure.

That is dissapointing that the X6 has smaller keys than my old XP-60 though! I really liked the feel of the XP-60 before I sold it on ebay.

Re: Fantom XA Comparison Question!

20 Jan 2007, 07:06
Go with the G for starters, upgrade to X later if needed.
But beware the sustain problem (see topic).
______________
Juno-G + SRX-07
Sao Paulo - Brazil

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X